Michaelangelo's Pizza & Subs

I've been past this location dozens and dozens of times for the past 15 years or so. And I am now wishing I would've ate here sooner. Everything was Amazing from the staff that talks to you like you are family, the cleanliness or everything, and the food was way better than I could've ever imagined. Thank You to all those that work at Michaelangelo's, Please keep up the Amazing food, and experience.

We are always trying new places when we visit Emerald Isle. The service was good. They were friendly and attentive. We ordered pizza and hot wings. The pizza was freshly cooked and delicious! The hot wings were great, the kids ate them all up. The pizza was a large size and lasted a couple days which is a plus.. This was well worth the visit. Will definitely return.

21Aug.2023 Family friendly pizza 🍕 spot. GREAT customer service and delicious food. I’m so glad me and my best friend stopped in to grab a slice for lunch. Best choice ever.

Large selection of fresh toppings and pizza crust was crispy outside and soft inside. This place gets pretty busy, but they are efficient, so the food comes out fast. All servers wear a unique hat.

We ate lunch on the way out of town and there has been renovations since our last visit. Open space and upgrades look great! The stuffed pizza was my favorite!

Been eating this pizza for over two decades (and in both on and off season) and it’s consistently wonderful. I love the fresh sauce. I don’t get the complaints on long wait times during the summer - it’s packed, of course it’s going to take a long time. Staff are always polite and my order has always been hot and ready at the promised time.

This is our favorite pizza spot, and location out of the 2 we’ve tried! The food is great, the staff are wonderful! It’s always a must when we’re in town!

I don't usually order slices so we order a whole fresh pizza and it is always delish! Subs are also wonderful. Only con is their soda/tea but I think it's due to the water quality in EI. Their pastas are average but a good alternative if not in the mood for pizza.

The Pizzeria is very clean & the food is delicious! When I bring the family, to our yearly trip to the area,we eat lunch at this location; before we get to strolling on the beach.Enjoy talking to all the tourists that visit,many of them arriving from nearby States,a few from the Northeast or the the West coast.Bring the family & enjoy yourselves...

I like their pizzas and subs. We came by when they just opened, and they already had pizzas ready. They had a variety of pizzas, i wanted to try them all!

Very cute place. Standard beach decor. Well lit with an upbeat vibe. Reggae playing is always welcome. I got a cheeseburger, fries, and a (large!) slice of pizza; plenty for two adults. Portions are generous, food was fresh. Really hit the spot. The staff was friendly and helpful. Good place for people watching.

Pizza's are huge and good! But they can get pretty busy on the weekend and there wasn't much order when it got super busy. Note: pizza is very large. One slice is maybe double the size of an average sized one.

Great Pizza, nice humans, and sold us some excellent pizza dough to make at home. Pizzas turned out great!

We go every visit! Love it! Great for family with our four kids!

Pizza by the slice! Multiple toppings! The sauce is not too sweet, and the crust is the perfect combination of thin and soft! If you live NY style pizza, this is a great place for you!

Regardless if you are bringing your kids to your favorite pizza place when you came here, are a local or it’s your first time in the area Michaelangelo’s is an island institution for a very good reason.
Solid, great tasting food at a reasonable price.
I’ve been a local, and am now bringing my kids to the island and can say there are many great places for food. However none have been around as long and provide such great food at a reasonable price. We make it a point to get at least one meal here every visit.

We really enjoy it here. It has become a tradition to stop on our way out Emerald Isle. They have some of the best by the slice pizza I have ever had!

We stopped in to get take out on a recent Sat.even. i had never been here before. so i asked for menu and ordered my pizza. When he said $24...I said oh i
need to make a change..was not expecting for it to be that much! Nice
People and changed my order with no
Problem! Good pizza. Crust is a little chewy but flavor makes up for it! I will be
BACK

First off, the gentleman who took my order was a absolute gem! Attentive to our dinner needs. We got a HUGE large pizza super fresh! Delicious! Topped it off with some recommended cookies and boy they did not disappoint! Absolutely amazing! Highly recommend this amazing local pizza place!

One of our must-stops whenever we visit the island. Literally some of the best pizza I've ever had.