El Pastorcito Mexican Restaurante

Our first visit and will definitely not be our last. I had the Monster Burrito. Hands down the best burrito I've ever had!! Delicious food, friendly staff, and comfortable atmosphere.

EDIT: They did add chile de árbol in a cup in my bag!

The first time I've ordered from El Pastorcito was from DoorDash and so far I think I found my go-to place for Mexican food with a noticeable seafood menu! I've been flirting with doing a pescatarian diet for years and was more than happy to see this place's options.

In this case I got a Shrimp Burrito but was hoping they would add Chile de Árbol after reading a Karen's review. The Karen complained about how she didn't expect her food to be spicy, but that's how you separate noobs from pros when it comes to spicy foods.

Unfortunately my Shrimp Burrito didn't come with chile de árbol which was only a minor request I made via DoorDash but that's okay. Seeing their profile on the site, they ended up being very busy and who can blame them? It's Tuesday, February 14th which obviously mean it's both Taco Tuesday and Valentine's Day!

Either way, I really enjoyed my Shrimp Burrito despite no chile de árbol and in its own way beats out another seafood burrito from a nearby Mexican restaurant despite it not having grilled tilapia. It's certainly a satisfying​ burrito to have!

If anything, I'm going to be eating at El Pastorcito more especially in-person because of it's seafood menu and with how good the Shrimp Burrito is both regular and by itself, I found a place that matches my tastes!

Happy Valentine's Day to the staff! You got yourself a new customer!

Probably the best steak taco I've ever eaten. MUY BUENO!!! Brings me back to the beautiful south, the flavor and atmosphere is so authentic I had to snap back to reality when my meal was over. MUCHOS GRACIAS EL PASTORCITO's it was just what I needed and I will definitely be back, frequently. 🤗

Authentic and delicious! .... The skirt steak was amazing! Went back the following week to have it again. Plus the salsa bar was a nice touch

I love Mexican food and theirs is fantastic. I had the Enchiladas Banderas. They are one of the few places open during the arctic freeze. Love the salsa bar too.

There restaurant itself is quite small but welcoming. I really appreciate the salsa bar and the salsas bet all quite good. The food was really fantastic but - be warned - the portion sizes are huge! I'll get at least three meals out of my entree. I would highly recommend the fish tacos!

Finally getting a opportunity to review this place. Me and my wife LOVE Mexican food and this place was amazing. I got their deluxe nachos and you get what you pay for. It was heaped with toppings! It came with some salsa that was initially spicy but cooled down right away and was full of flavor. My wife got the cheesesteak burrito. I would def order from here again!

Awesome food!! Great service

Best tacos in town .Especially the Al Pastor Tacos nd Cabeza d res 💙💙💙💙💙

Always delicious, so much flavor in the dishes, and large portions. Actually authentic Mexican food, not "Americanized authentic Mexican food." Table chips salsa was delicious, and the bottles of fresh Rojo and Verde they bring with the meal are awesome!!!

I have personally only had great experiences here, and at their food truck, too, and I have visited both many times!

This is the first review I have ever done but feel like I need to say something. We have now ordered from here twice. The food is absolutely AMAZING. Highly recommend anything that is covered in the cheese sauce (YUM). The horchata is delicious! Our food has been nice and warm when it comes. We like the chimichangas. They are the perfect texture. Highly recommend!!!

My boyfriend and I eat here a lot! It's our favorite Mexican resturant.

He always gets the Carne Asada. He's tried it multiple places and this was the most flavorful! I like their burritos and they are huge. I typically get 2-3 meals out of it!

Highly recomend!

Cheese steak burrito is the best in town. Horchata and nachos are delicious also. Always friendly and nice every time I go in!

Always delicious! Love the marinated pork tacos!

Really neat restaurant with a cozy atmosphere. Other places will serve you your salsa with your chips, but at this place they have a little salsa bar where they have plenty of varieties to choose from. I really like that idea!
The portions are also very generous— I had the fish taco lunch special and could only finish one. It was so delicious though, I wish my stomach was as big as my eyes!! Definitely a place to check out if you’re in the mood for Mexican cuisine. Socially awkward introverts, prepare to get excited: They do deliveries too!

Loved the atmosphere and the food was delicious!

My initial experience puts this in my top 5 Mexican restaurants in Wisconsin. Their Chili Verde sauce is enough to make me want to visit again. I look forward to future visits to try out more items from their menu.

I found this restaurant by accident and I am so glad I did. I love the food. Saving I love the food is not even enough. This food is so great that some times I actually dream about it and have to put in an order when I wake up. Silly, but true. The staff is very friendly and the food comes out fast and is soooooooooooooooo delicious. I have never tasted better Mexican food and I have been to Mexico.

Loved the variety of homemade salsa/hot sauce! Very good food. The steak and chicken meat were a little too salty and I like salt! I would go back again. The salsa bar is an excellent idea I wish all Mexican places had!

Husband and I shared the single steak, chicken and shrimp fajitas. Plenty of food. Homemade shells. The best part is the salsa bar! Small establishment or shall I say cozy. Friendly waitstaff. And they serve late night. Truly authentic cuisine! We will be back. Thanks for the wonderful food.