Odd Fellows Pizza Co.

Who knew that we'd find some of the best pizza we've had in Oregon in the small town of Willamina? We've been looking for some top tier quality pizza for almost a year now, and Odd Fellows is the first place that checks all of our boxes.

The atmosphere is pretty chill and family friendly, and the service is busy but attentive, just as you'd expect in a small restaurant that stays busy.

We have tried a few pies, but recommend the meat lovers, which boasts a great blend of flavors. The sausage is yummy, and all the flavors blend well. Leftovers reheat well in a toaster oven, but it's peak if you can eat it right there.

The only downside is how long it can take to get your food - grab a beer and expect to wait a bit, maybe half an hour. It's worth it, though... We are glad to have this gem of a pizza joint close to our new home!

Will forever and always love this place. By far my favorite pizza around!

Most small towns you wouldn't find a pizza parlor that's this good but odd fellows is killing it.

My family came for the open mic last Sat. The pizza is so good! The dough is delicious 😋 Plenty of toppings, they definitely don't skimp on them. The service was great too! Kind workers and helpful. We live in a town 30 mins away but will make the drive for this pizza and service. Thank you to the chef and staff!

Pizza was pretty good. The venue was fantastic. Quaint, comfortable and intimate. We just saw our favorite band The Hooten Hallers there and this was one of the best shows we've seen for sure !!!!
Thanks Wilamina and Thanks Odd Fellows Pizza!!!

Excellent pizza - love the crust! The new remodel is nice with a beautiful painted mural on the wall. Perfect stop on the way to the beach!

Great pizza (love the crust!), excellent and attentive service even with the staffing shortages - an all around good experience. This was only our second time there and I was a little concerned about the negative reviews I saw, but decided we should see for ourselves, and I'm so glad we did.

Different cooks, different finished product but overall delish.

The pizza was very well prepared. Crust was perfect. It was open mic night which was a great addition.
Would highly recommend Odd Fellows Pizza.
Great food and atmosphere!

Our first time here and we were pleasantly surprised. The pizza wasn't the usual type, you know, like the chain places. The crust was more Artesia (delicious), toppings and cheese we're fresh. Staff was very helpful and friendly, & the dinner was clean and comfortable. Will definitely be going there again.

First time eating their pizza. We ordered the large combination. It is the best pizza I've ever had. I liked the little sauce, little cheese, and large chunks of vegetables. And buttery garlic taste of the crust. It was so good. Its was also larger than expected. Loved it.

Great pizza, cool place, awesome drinks!!

Great handmade pizzas, and friendly staff. Family friendly atmosphere.

Delicious pizza and great friendly customer service. The toppings are fresh and taste so good-and crust was awesome! I was very impressed by this pizza place, and will definitely be going back.

My favorite place to eat pizza in the valley. The owner is very kind and so us the staff. Pretty good pizza. My kids love the video games. I love that they have live music in the back too. Good beers on tap

Now that new personnel has been hired, their pizza is back on track and delicious !!! You will not be disappointed if you give them a try again.

Oddfellows is the real deal. Forget those pizza chain's who serve broiled man hole covers, get a decent quality pizza instead. I recommend trying the "Bulldog" a speciality pizza like no other. They may cost a little more ($25 for a Lg) but it's worth every penny 🍕

Amazing pizza!! Totally worth the $26 for an 18" in pizza. Didnt skimp on any toppings, and whatever they do it's just super yummy. Stopped by on our way through town and not what I expected from a small little town pizza shop!

I absolutely love their pizza!! Always delicious and the staff are great.

Great and chill vibe environment, friendly and respectful employees. Every time I eat here or have it to go I’m never disappointed, the pizza is really good. Plus they have an outside patio, a pinball machine, a couple arcade games, an internet jukebox, minibar, and a couple claw machines.