Colombo's Cafe & Pastries

A beautiful upscale restaurant with amazing food and great service with the best dessert if you're hungry looking for a place be sure to stop in

This place has amazing food. The menu has a lot of variety of Italian dishes,prepared and homemade with care. The bartender inside the restaurant is great and makes you feel at home. The servers are very polite and they double check to see if you need anything else to complete 💯 evening. Atmosphere is very comfortable.

Good new place in center of Hyannis. The shrimp fri diavolo wirh squid ink pasta was spot. My wife had the eggplant sandwich and although good was disappointed by the bread. Was a bit soggy and should have used different bread. Scallop/bacon pizza was also delicious. Will be back on my next visit to this new addition!!

We love Colombo’s! We typically sit at the bar facing outside. Sarah and the other bartender were great today. We went to try brunch but ended up still having lunch. It’s hard not to have their gnocchi! They make delicious espresso martinis. Every time we go, we are never disappointed.

Absolutely amazing food!! Told us wait would be an hour, 15 minutes later they called us back and said they could seat us!! I enjoyed the Buratta Linguini incredibly and I loved the turtle cheesecake. The street music was FANTASTIC, there was a birthday in our party and our waiter went over and requested songs for us!! Our waitress was fantastic, they were incredibly busy and they were able to keep up and check on us. Not to mention the amazing cars they have?? Wow!! There is a reason it’s so busy, this Italian place is not to be missed!! Thank you Colombo’s!!

Our bartender (Connor I think it was) took great care of us. Great drinks, delicious dessert. Must visit when in Cape Cod.

Atmosphere, it could be better. I get the look he’s going for but it needs updating. Server was friendly, hostess friendly. We were seated promptly with no res. They were very short staffed which they informed you about prior to seating you which was nice. But our meal was great. We shared the spinach salad which was great but the stems could have been cut off. I had the Tuscany chicken with homemade sausage with sun dried tomatoes and he had the chicken sultan boca, both were excellent. We had the carrot cake for dessert which was awesome as well.

Love Columbo's. They make all their own pasta in house. Was there tonite with my two college aged kids. My son had the chicken parm. My daughter had the gnocchi. I had a special. Bone in Swordfish. My son loved his chicken parm. Big portion, he could hardly finish. My daughter liked her gnocchi. A bit too much butter was her feedback. She has had this dish several times previously and it's usually perfect. But the gnocchi were fresh and soft. My bone in Swordfish was incredible. Cooked medium rare, melted in my mouth. Fresh with a nice light lemon beurre blanc. Really good. Large portion. Oh and the bread was fresh, and hot, served with excellent olive oil. Waitress was excellent. Looking forward to our next meal at Columbo's.

Great food and wine selection! This place is popular during dinner so put your name down early. Definitely recommend the eggplant parmigiana. Great ambiance and helpful staff. Hope this helps!

Delicious !!! Love the variety of the menu, they cover all the bases, pastries and gelato included 😋...The scallops and bacon pizza was dreamy, pizza crust is perfection 👍. Short rib ragu is a must!

Recommended by others. Kim was our server. She was great. Very quick. Pleasant. Food was good. Margarita was ok. Overall a very nice experience. I’d go back again

We came to celebrate our 4 year wedding anniversary. The service was excellent.
We shared the Mussels appetizer. My husband had the Chicken and Alfredo. I had the Colombo A LA Paella with Shrimp, Mussels, Scallops, Chicken and a 1 lb Lobster added.
For dessert he had the New York Cheesecake with Raspberry Sauce, and I had the Carrot Cake.
We can't wait to come back.

When here early on a Saturday night. Got seated right away at a nice booth. Drinks were ordered and served promptly. Opted for a wedge salad to start, which was very good. We had the Chicken and Veal Parmigian, and both were very good as well. I would suggest that for the price of the meal, you should get a little more pasta, we felt the portion was a bit small. Would visit again to try something different.

Wonderful atmosphere and great service. We are in Hyannis for work and we were told to come here. Our server was very nice and have us recommendations based on what we were looking for which was seafood. I got the Frutti Di Mare. The seafood tasted fresh and the sauces were a perfect combination for the shrimp and scallops. I would definitely recommend to anyone who is coming here.

Great atmosphere, welcoming host and attentive staff. Great food. Very clean and pleasant dining area. I had their seafood items and all were amazing. My server Eric was superb! I need to come back soon!

Food and service were outstanding. I travel for work and, frankly, get tired of eating out but if every restaurant was as good as Colombo's, my attitude might change. My server Kylie was super. She helped me pull together a meal of sides and a special small serving of linguini bolonaise that was exactly what I wanted. Fabulous dinner.

One of our favorite places to dine...on the Cape or anywhere. We had an excellent meal last night at Columbo's. We were fortunate enough to be able to dine outside. Tables were appropriately spaced, staff was impeccable in following safety protocols. Hostess and waitress were fabulous....efficient and great personalities. I had the Linguine Burrata and it was DIVINE. My husband had the manicotti and meatballs which he said was delicious - and a huge portion! Warm bread served with olive oil was sooooo good. Prices are fantastic. Thank you for another wonderful meal.

Great food and terrific service! We decided to eat outside, they have a really nice set up, with tables set up long a stretch of sidewalk which is blocked off from pedestrians. I had filet mignon...it was awesome, with red potatoes and asparagus. Everything was great. Definitely on the go back list!

The waitress was very nice. They gave 2 bread for us. The Meatball was very good and the tomato sauce with the meatball was excellent. My wife had the pasta with clams. She liked it . Everybody was very friendly. I'm local to the cape and i will go again

The gnocchi could have been the best I have ever had, and I have had my fare share having grown up in Italian restaurants.The texture was spot-on (not an easy feat) and the accompanying sauces and preparation an eleven out of ten. Their desserts are nothing short of devine. We had one at the restaurant and got two to go! The hostess was as polite and pleasant as she wanted to be. Our server was engaging and funny. Will be back for sure.
Keep up the good work y'all and thanks for exceeding expectations! Also not an easy feat :)