Centerville Pie Company

Cute little pie shop, can pick up some cold or hot dessert pies ready to eat or some frozen dinner pies to be cooked at home. They have a few other assorted to go lunches and baked goods such as scones or muffins. Doesn't seem to offer sit in dining/eating anymore but the food was still very tasty at home.

I just had my first (of many) Apple pie(s) from Centerville Pie Company. It is the best frozen apple pie I've ever had. And one of the best overall, frozen or fresh. Although frozen and then reheated, it tasted like fresh baked. I honestly did not think frozen pie could have such flaky rich crust and apples that remained crisp and crunchy, amazing!

I still mourn their now closed restaurant. The chicken pies (better than anything you can make at home!) are superb, better than the store-bought pies which carry their name. The staff is always pleasant and happy to see you. Located in a sideways strip mall on Rt. 28, this is a local treasure everyone should support and embrace. Tell your friends...

First time visitor but not the last! Picked up a Chocolate Cream Pie for Thanksgiving and the family said it was the best they have ever had! Can't wait to order more! The staff was friendly and high energy for a busy day!

Went here with my brother, sister, and cousin. The breakfast was amazing. I had a lobster benedict which was to die for. Then we had dessert pies. I live in Florida but there Key Lime pie is perhaps the best that I've had. I had the chocolate bread pudding which was great. Donna was our server... she was fantastic!

The key lime and apple pie were so delicious. The staff there are friendly, pleasant and go above board to make sure you are a happy customer.

Their pie shop is Centerville is fantastic and offers tasty pies but my review is for the their frozen Shepard's pie I got from stop and shop. These other reviews seem aggressive regarding the frozen pies, I thought it was very tasty, my only suggestion is that it could use another filling with the beef and corn, maybe some carrots or peas? Maybe add both! I ended up cooking some peas on the side and just added it to my pie. Crust was very good. A bit pricey but it's no more expensive than Marie Callenders pies at the store and IMO much tastier. Cheers.

Back and forth often to the Cape and this is a favorite request from family. Always great staff and yummy.

Pies are pricey.....much cheaper at the grocery store....
However!.......they are awesome!
Worth the money!

Your Chicken Pie is the most delicious savory pie I’ve ever eaten! Cooler in hand, we picked up the large Chicken Pie & small Thanksgiving Pie for transport back to NYC from the Cape. A tasty culinary experience enjoyed by all! Next up on the menu will be the Thanksgiving Pie…sure to be a hit! FYI…The much anticipated arrival of Wegman’s will be opening up its 1st market in Manhattan in 2023 - PLEASE connect with them!

The Best! So many varieties of pies - the savory are my favorite. Each one is delicious but you can’t go wrong with the the original and the Buffalo chicken is awesome. Owners are such nice people. I asked about a food allergy and she said just to call ahead and they would make a special pie for my daughter :)
I always have one in my freezer to pop in the oven to wow dinner guests or just feed my family

I buy their chicken pie at Marshall's farm stand in Gloucester and it's the best chicken pie I've ever had. Generous chicken content where other bakers have little.
BTW. They're frozen in shrink wrap but are great to throw in the freezer for an easy tasty meal.

We used Centerville Pie Company to supply desserts for our wedding, and they were delicious! Our guests loved having their pies and they were wonderful to work with. Coordinating our pie order and delivery was so easy, and we greatly appreciate all that they did to make our day special. We highly recommend them for your dessert needs!

Absolutely the best chicken pot pie ever. My children gave it an eleven / scale 1-10 (10 being the best). Goldbelley delivered and all went well…

Just the best, from the people to the food. Have been a fan for years. Everything from savory to sweet is a hit in our house. It is the only place that comes close to my mother's pies, and I will tell you that is beyond a high compliment. Don't miss out on their cookies even though the name says "pie". Oh, and at Thanksgiving time, that Thanksgiving pie is not to be missed.

Wife and I stopped here to get a treat for our 5yr anniversary. We got their key lime pie, a whoopie pie and a chocolate chip cookie. The cookies are ridiculously good, its like an entire nice quality chocolate bar packed into a nice big cookie. The key lime pie was outstanding and garnished nicely. My wife liked the whoopie pie, but those aren't my thing so can't really comment.

Absolutely worth the stop, they have all kinds of savory pies too.

Awesome chicken pot pie - worlds above any others at the grocery stores! Very generous amount of real, quality chicken, great flavor without the typical overload of salt, and perfect crust!

Quality pies. Especially the chicken and Shepard pie. Fruit pies are very good also. Stay away from the pies they sell frozen in a box from various stores around the cape. At least 50 percent of the time, they are horrible. Have never had any bad pies purchased at the store. Can not wait for them to open the Sandwich location.

This chicken pot pie tastes homemade never had a better one. It is absolutely delicious and chock-full of big pieces of white meat chicken. This is the second chicken pot pie I have bought from Centerville pie Company and I will buy hundreds more if The quality stays the same because the quality right now is superb love it.

I ordered your pies this spring through Goldbelly. They are wonderful! I have sent pies to family and friends who have raved. My personal favorite is the chicken pie. The pies have been sold out online for weeks. I faithfully check everyday looking to see if they are restocked. Please comeback soon! That chicken pie has been the go to comfort meal for my family on quarantine down days.