The Sicilian Baker Peoria

Wow! We just stopped in after dinner and we were pleasantly surprised. The staff was so helpful and answered our questions. Our favorite was a delicious light pastry called a Lobster Tail. We are definitely coming back for that again.

Cute little bakery and dessert spot attached to an amazing restaurant. We walked through the restaurant to get in after eating dinner. The selection was plentiful and colorful. My husband ordered a few take home chocolate pastries, and I ordered a gelato. I ordered the biscoff cookie gelato but ended up getting some kind of cookies and cream one. It tasted good so I didn’t fuss or ask for an exchange. Overall neat find and we will be back!

Very friendly folks here, and wow, are they selling some lovely, delicious desserts! Everything looks good, but I chose two to share at home: the Nutella Lobster Tail and the classic Tiramisu. Both were great, but I especially like the Lobster Tail with its crunchy, croissant-like layers. I would absolutely come here again for a treat!

These are some of the best Italian baked goods I've ever had state side. The cannoli are the stars of the show, but their tiramisu is my favorite item to indulge in. I've been three times, and each time the staff are wonderfully kind and patient. My only two nitpicks are that the fruit-flavored cannoli creams taste a little artificial, and that the adjoining restaurant The Sicilian Butcher is a little loud which can make it hard to hear.

What a cute place to have lunch!
We all shared a charcuterie board and the flaming cheese appetizer with a bottle of red wine. Would definitely go back to try their pizza!

Tried their tiramisu, and let me tell you it was one of the beat ones I’ve ever tried.

YA’LL I come here on Sunday evening and got cakes 🍰 . The best cakes , the only place I found cakes made like in Italy 🇮🇹 and Romania . DELICIOUS 😋!!!! The young lady was very nice and smiley . Good job YA’LL at this business . I will come back 💯.

Our waitress Genesis was amazing! Great food as well. Would highly recommend this restaurant.

This rating is based solely on the Berry Mascarpone Tartlet.

What pure joy was experienced while devouring this subtle delicacy! From the light and flaky phyllo pastry shell, to the light and creamy, but not too sweet, mascarpone, to the fresh and bursting trio of berries that rested atop this masterful pastry.

Each layer wove a tapestry of texture that would make even Anton Ego pause mid-chew as synapses started firing, revealing a dessert experience finally attained!

They're only like six bucks... get a couple.

Best Cannoli Ever!
The Ricotta of filling in these canolies can not be beat. Super friendly and delightful customer service.

Service, quality ingredients, meatballs!!! Amazing! Anrancinia delicious! Red wine, casual atmosphere, not too loud! Get the Board!

We came in after our anniversary dinner and Lexi and Sherri were AMAZING! They helped us pick out the best desserts to end the night. Highly recommend and we'll be back because of them!

Excellent choice of desserts that taste amazing. Well worth a visit.

Everything here is great. My particular favorite are the lobster tails. They are filled completely from end to end with a ton of amazing pastry cream. The tiramisu is solid too. You can't go wrong with anything they have.

Went here after wanting to forever for the first time. It is such a lovely place to walk into. I got the espresso and vanilla bean Gelato, rasberry sorbetto, and a tiramisu this time. You could taste the quality with every bite. Can't wait to come back and try the coffee and more treats. One day I want to try the food too. ☕😋💕

Thank you! A gorgeous woman made me a cannoli at about 10pm. I drove for hours and this was the highlight of my drive. It was perfect!!!! Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!

We tried everything. The cannolis are huge and rich. Shareable. Coffee was good. The staff was amazing. For a first time customer they were so patient and even offered samples of cannoli fillings. (There's a lot)

Ordered the cannoli and lobster tail… amazing!

We loved it. Came for some baked goods. They did not disappoint. Will be going back for sure.

Great food, an hour wait but very worth it! Awesome service