Sammy's Pizza In Neenah

My husband has been going to Sammy's Pizza for over 35 yrs. He used to go with his mom when he was a little boy. Now he's married and brings his wife (me) and kids there. Sammy's is his favorite Pizza. A Tradition that will hopefully follow on through his children.

Old fashioned pizzeria, kinda worn looking. Great service, amazing pizza, reasonable price. Been in service for over 65 years. You know why when you taste their pie. I'll be here often in the future. Great place for families and Carry out.

This place was awesome! We had a large sausage and mushroom pizza, and our waitress (what a sweetheart!) gave us the last of the ranch dressing for the night! The soda was ice cold, and after dinner, you get an ice cream sandwich! We will definitely be back!

It was very busy when we were there. The server did a great job attending all the tables. She let us know it would take awhile to get our pizza which we were fine with. Even then it was quicker then expected. We were very satisfied. Love Sammy's.

BEST PIZZA in the valley and probably WI! Normally get take out, can take bit longer to bake than the chains so expect 30 to 45 min. The restaurant has nice servers. Be prepared to wait a bit, enjoy the moment, order some cheesy garlic bread to nibble on during the wait. WORTH IT EVERYTIME, TAKE OUT OR DINING IN.

Sammy’s is a fabulous restaurant and the staff is friendly and accommodating. We love their pizza! The garlic bread is superb and everything was cooked just perfectly 🤌

Love their pizza! and the garlic crust is so good! I normally like thick crust pizza more but they have me hooked. A friend introduced me and now I’m addicted. They are also always so friendly when I go get my pick up order:)

Our pizzas were very delicious! Our waitress was excellent.

From the moment we entered until when we left, we were treated very nicely. The menu is simple and I felt that the prices were fair. While we waited, we played a few of the claw machines by the entrance, which was a nice time waster. To top it all off, the pizza was nothing short of amazing. I ordered the house special and enjoyed it thoroughly. I'll probably be coming back here again. Also, if you save your receipts, your 16th order is free!

Very good thin crust pizza! I love the pepperoni. And if you dine in you get an ice cream sandwich for dessert. Highly recommend!

A great place for pizza for a family night out on a Sun. night. One of our favorites. The Cheese Garlic Bread is always a must. We had the 12 inch Sammy's Special. Others a large Pepperoni & a large Sausage for a family of four. It was good as always. Thin crust is pefect. Friendly efficient service. If you still have room they have complimentary ice cream sandwiches with pizza orders. We were all too full to have one. We will be back. Worth the little extra trip from Appleton to Neenah.

Quick in and out. Reasonably priced, excellent quality. Been going here for 35 yrs, never been let down.

The best pizza ANYWHERE and friendly, professional service... we're hooked for life ❤❤❤

This place is pure gold. Absolutely love the pizza and vibe. The pizza always cooked perfectly.

Very good pizza, went with the house special. Very good sauce and I like the thin crust. Plant of toppings and cheese. The aroma of pizza cooking when walking in was mouth watering. I highly recommend this place if you are looking for a good pizza in the Neenah area.

Great pizza at a great price and who doesn't love a free ice cream sandwich for desert.

Love Sammy's Pizza!
The atmosphere is decorated according to the holidays. Service is top notch.

Delicious! It's the best Pizza around... Better then Crankys

First time trying Sammy's Pizza, absolutely loved it! Definitely going again and again!!!!

Love their pizza. Thin crust is perfect. Don't get more than 2 toppings if you want to keep it together. Really nice people and great service.