Stuc's Pizza - Neenah

Come see Paul at Stuc's for the most amazing old fashioneds and truly some of the best pizza in town! Great service, a beautiful bar, awesome food. You can't go wrong!!! You really should try the Gator!

Well here goes review 2.0
I truly miss the Gator, but Ashley, Jason, and the bar crew continue to impress with amazing drinks and incredible food! What an awesome local business. The old fashioneds are mixed stiff just like they should be and the food is fresh and amazing. Made with love and dedication.... Jason and Ashley lead a great crew. Yes, I'm biased.... but it's true! See you soon at Stuc's Neenah!

I always dream of going back home to Chicago to get good pizza. Never thought I run into a place that has the absolutely best pizza. I had an hot sausage and cheese thin crust pizza to go and garlic cheese bread I ate there the best n my kids love pizza

All I can say is wow! I am loving this newly built out pizza pub! Had a deep dish pizza and it was amazing! The craft beer selection out of this world! With top shelf Whiskey, and more! I truly appreciate everything the owner Jason is doing to make everyone enjoy the experience. Give it a try, you will not be disappointed. I will be back, hands down!

Since moving to Wisconsin from Chicago 15 years ago, I have been unable to find any pizza that even comes close to the pizza I was used to. That is, until now. Stucs pizza is the absolute best pizza in SE Wisconsin hands down! This pizza rivals some of the best in Chicago!

Not going to lie at first glance I was unsure about the pizza by the look of how much sauce I saw and how little cheese. Well, I was wrong. This pizza is delicious and definitely the best deep dish I’ve had since I can remember.

The cheese is really good, the ingredients taste great, and the part that gets overlooked sometimes…THE CRUST. The crust is crunchy but not dry and it evens everything out really well.

The garlic bread is good but not to die for. The ratio of bread to cheese is how I’d like but I think I would be okay with just ordering pizza in the future.

Overall, I recommend it here and someday I’ll have to come back and try a calzone and some pasta.

Stuc's Neenah is our family's favorite local pizza spot! Always delicious and always consistent high quality! Amazing beer selection as well!

Visited here after getting engaged as celebration. Friendly service and even friendlier staff. Waa able to meet the owner who was extremely nice. Atmosphere was welcoming and cozy not freezing like other places. Cheesy garlic bread was excellent, thought it couldn't be beat but then out came our entrees which were calzones. The calzones were perfect, so big we had left overs.I was worried about it not reheating well, but then it was as delicious as when we got it, crust was still nice unlike other pizza places. The price was good as well 3 calzones(really 6 by size) and cheesy bread for under $50.00. Would recommend this place to anyone, even if it is a 45min drive away.

Got myself some carry out after an extremely long day & let them choose the crust for my 9in - they chose hand tossed & it didn't disappoint. It was all set for me when I arrived. Staff was friendly. Definitely hit the spot!

Stuc's in Neenah has a great welcoming feel! My family & I enjoy all the pizzas but my personal favorites are the Stuc's special deep dish & the chicken BBQ on the thin crust! There's always a great amount of sauce & toppings! Plus, I really like how they use all high quality ingredients & have high standards.

Very clean and friendly. Has a huge menu and will even let you create your own. Service is outstanding and will treat you like family. Would highly recommend this place for your next meal.

The pizza at Stucs pizza and pints in Neenah is my absolute favorite! You can tell that they have great quality ingredients and they take the time to do things right. Passionate people and a great environment to enjoy a specialty beer and pizza!! The beer selection is fun and unique, it’s the perfect place to discover your new favorite beer! 100% will be coming back

Stucs calzones are the best. Even the small is enough to feed 2 people. Service here is great as well.

Best pizza around, period. I recommend the deep dish, but their calzones are phenomenal. My wife and I usually stop here every two weeks or so.

A guy I work with has been hyping this pizza for a year and a half and tonight we finally gave it a try. Going into it I was a little hesitant. I'm not a sweet sauce kind of person and some of the reviews said it was very sweet. After trying it, I have to say it was fantastic! The sauce is sweet, but not overbearing and it compliments the pizza very well. Will be back again for more!

The owner at the Neenah location is wonderful! He is extremely devoted to serving his community/customers and making sure they have a wonderful dining and/or take out experience. Haven’t felt that much compassion from a restaurant owner In quite some time. 10/10 recommend.

Kennedy was an awesome bartender!!

The deep dish special we had was fabulous, thank you cooking crew!!

I don’t love Canadian bacon or pineapple on my pizza. My buddy and I split one here and it was—no joke—one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Can’t wait to get more with some of my FAVORITE toppings. This is the best pizza in the Fox Valley and I’ve tried almost all of them.

Wow! Note that this isn't the Stuc's in Appleton (which is nice), but a new place under different/new management (I think).

It was great! Had a couple "standard" (off the menu) pizzas and they were easily the best pizzas I've had in the Fox Valley, maybe ever. Service was great, super attentive, and the new digs are really nice.

Their craft beer selection is awesome, too. If you liked "old" Stuc's, you'll *LOVE* this place.

Best pizza on the west side of the Mississippi! Excellent staff, food, and atmosphere!

We stopped here by mistake when we thought we were going to a different pizza joint. Our son wanted pizza, we didn't want the usual national franchise pizza & decided to give Stuc's a try...
When we entered we were greeted by the owner who was also making a pizza. I had explained the reason for being there, he told me he was the first employee here 32 years ago & that he bought the place 20 years ago.
The interior design is nice & felt comfortable.
There are many available pizza toppings. I pretty much feel, if you want it on your pizza, they have it. Including pineapple, no thanks! We kept it pretty simple with the 3 meat deep pan. We also had the garlic cheese bread appetizer. The garlic cheese bread & the pizza were good. I appreciate the free drink, & we will be back when we're in town again.