Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Neenah/Menasha

Clean!! Clean!! Clean restaurant. There’s a lot to be said about a business that keeps every aspect of their property clean. If the building is tended that well then one could only assume the food is cared for the same way. The pizza did not disappoint…hot fresh and delicious!! Amazing interaction with employee that took my payment. Glass Nickel Pizza Co. is definitely getting a spot on my saved places in Wisconsin

Fantastic gluten free pizza, which as a new Celiac I really appreciate. So if you are wondering where to eat and missing your pizza days this is a great place to go!

I absolutely love ordering from this location! The pizzas are always cooked to perfection and the toppings are generous. The sandwiches are tasty and full of flavor. And they have a big variety of sides- something the other chains don't. Whether I call in my order or do it through the website I always get amazing customer service. The staff are really friendly and are always smiling. The delivery drivers always bring my food hot and they follow any instructions I leave for them. The lobby is clean and the soda cooler is well stocked. Wait times may be longer during rush times but it's totally worth the wait!

Fast & friendly service. Their rewards are so worth it!

Got the chicken alfredo and it was delicious! The "side salad" that came with my pasta was HUGE!! It was delicious and probably weighed more than my pasta. The service was super fast. They delivered faster than the original estimated time. It was crazy! Loved it and will order it again. 👍

Clean restaurant and rest rooms. Food was as ordered and very good.

Really good food! Loved the wings and mac and cheese bites. Chicken cordon bleu pizza was delicious but the honey mustard sauce was a bit over powering on it even with light on the sauce. Definitely will order again the next time we are in town. They even went out of their way to deliver to us as we are in a semi and couldn't come to them.

Top quality pizza and great specialty pizza's. Had my pizza delivered to my home and had it in about 25 minutes. So yeah, a delicious hot fresh pizza that gets to your door quickly deserves all five stars. Also delivery driver was the owner who was super friendly. If you have not had their pizza, its a must have.

I just move to the area from Illinois. Glass Nickel Pizza is the bomb!!!! I love that they offer 'true' thin crust. You can tell that this company takes pride in their pizza. The staff is amazing and super polite!! The prices are reasonable and the food is delicious. I'll never order from anywhere else!

We ate there and the staff was very friendly! Great food as always!

Absolutely love all the different flavors of pizza.

I order from Glass Nickel all of the time. Aside from longer waits during rush hours (which is understandable and I'm perfectly okay with), everything is always terrific!

The pizza is always amazing! The service was spot on as well! I love the gyro specialty pizza!

The food here was amazing and so was staff. Prices are a little higher then average, but I promise you won't be disappointed. I really liked that they had a large variety of pizza as well as Subs and salads. If you're looking for good quality food I definitely recommend this place

Pizza delivered right at time I requested to my assisted living facility. Pizza delicious Definitely will order again. My friend and I really enjoyed it. Would highly recommend the thin crust pizza

Came in around 10ish tonight to get some pizza to go. The wait time was a little longer than usual due to some staff training, but the staff was so friendly and accommodating that we didn't mind one bit.
So here is my "negative" review I said I would give the highschool student who took our order. I was "sooo" offended by your mopping in our presence. (Kidding! You all were so friendly! 10/10 will absolutely give delicious Glass Nickel and their awesome staff our business many times in the future!!!)

One of the best pizzas in the Valley. The service is always great with friendly staff and excellent customer service.

This is the most professional place around here. They actually care about there customers and will go outta there way for you. Ive called a few minutes before they close and they still took my order before any other place wouldnt. There food is always amazing too 😊 I would recommend this place to anyone that wants fresh good food and great customer service 😊🍝🍕🍞🧀🍴

Not even hours had gone by since my tastebuds issued a decisive "executive ban" on anything from here, but they're customer service, value, quality, and expertly executed style in which they're handling business amid the threat of Covid19, make enough of a statement that I urge you try for yourself. There was just something about the flavors here that I, personally, couldn't seem to find level ground with.

Great pizza!!!! Our favorite!

Very good pizza. All kinds of different styles I've never seen before. Very creative style names.