Christianos Pizza

What a cool place. We were just driving past, and it looked good, so we stopped. So glad we did. We ordered the tomato garlic bread and 2 calzones. Everything had authentic flavors, and the portions were very generous. For desert we shared a canoli. Service was great and very attentive. We will definitely return when we are in the area.

Went with 14 hungry fishermen. As usual, Christianos didn't let us down. From Pizza to great Italian entrees and sandwiches there is something for everyone. The food was hot and the Spotted Cow was ice cold. We had Chicken Milano, Shrimp Primavera in a great cream sauce, Alfredo, Calzones and sandwiches. Bread is made there and the garlic bread is awesome. All hit the spot and we're delicious. This was our second time here and we will be back. Our server, Lily was excellent...always checking to make sure everything was right...If you go ask for Lily and tell her I sent you!

I've been to other Christiano's. They've always been excellent. This one is no exception. The thin crust pizza is the best, and their garlic bread is perfect. The view of Green Lake in the distance is beautiful.

LOVE the pizza at Christianos!! Actually all of their food is great. Service is top notch and the staff is very friendly and professional! Always a very nice dining or take out experience!!

We were there for a surprise birthday party. The staff was so awesome. They were happy to be a part of this and anticipated all of our needs. The food was soooo good. I would highly recommend Christianos Pizza

Every time I'm here, they are phenomenal. Excellent service, high-quality ingredients, outstanding food - and I appreciate the fact that they are closed on Sundays, which was traditional years ago. Family owned, and attention to detail regarding homemade sauces and pizza dough. They'll have my business for life.

Great restaurant and friendly service. The calzone wasn't great (too much bread and hardly any stuff inside). But overall a nice restaurant.

pizza here is very tasty. our server was very nice, it is a bit expensive but i would recommend.

Have driven past a few times and on a whim stopped it. My daughter and I enjoyed a very fine meal.. a 15 in pizza with a meatball and bread stick appetizer.. all very good..

It's been a couple of years since we've last been there. Atmosphere was about the same.

Garlic bread is awesome (but big)

Came for the pizza and it's still DELICIOUS!
Super generous on fantastic Italian sausage .

We don't live in the arena, but when we come up to green lake area, will definitely come back again.

Beer selection is ok, not great, could be better but reasonable.

I recently put in an order for a few pizza's for my crew working in the area. I spoke with a girl named Olivia and I have to say I received some of the best customer service I have ever had at any food establishment. I was indecisive about my order and couldn't determine what exactly I needed for the volume of people I was feeding, she explained everything to me and made things much clearer. Rock Solid service and food!

The service and atmosphere makes this place a great stop for us; coffee and dessert are always great choices!

This place has been fantastic both times we went there. The pizza is great, and the service is astounding. I am not sure if they are family owned, but the staff quick and attentive. We will definitely be returning on our next road trip through this area.

Pretty Sure Christianos is THE best pizza in Wisconsin. Their thin crust tavern style pizza can rival many Chicago neighborhood spots. The crust is nice and thin. The sauce is savory and balanced. It's a great value and they deliver! Anytime I'm in Green Lake, I have to get a pizza.

Great Experience
My wife and I ordered the lunch pizza and one soda special. We were expecting a small one topping and were surprised that we could have up to six toppings for$8.95. They did not skimp on the toppings. We could only eat half of it because it so so big and we wanted gelato. A one scoop almond, coconut, fudge was delicious and more than satisfied our craving for something sweet. We will be back.

Ordered the Clazone. Deeelicious! Looking forward to having a pizza the next time :)

Update, ate here with a daughter tonight and the food and service were very good. They also do a real good job with a gluten free selection. Very happy with dinner here tonight.

Was there as part of a group and had buffet style pizza and salad\bread sticks. Food was fine and price per person reasonable (included soft drinks). Overall, a good experience.
Update.. was here with son and grandson for dinner. Food was served reasonably fast, service was good and food was excellent. Very tasty with well portioned helpings. The garlic bread was delicious. Very good dining experience. One negative... The dining area was quite loud. Lots of hard surfaces for reflected sound

What a wonderful experience great food and staff, aways from home but well worth it

Excellent staff and delicious food ! Definitely will be going back soon !

You are missing out big if you haven't already eaten here. Our favorite is the Combo Danza, and it has a crispy crust and ingredients to the edges!! Only pizzas we will ever order!!!