Bonelli's

One of the best Italian food experiences I have ever had! It is not fast by any means but when you bite into your food, you can taste why. I have zero complaints. The atmosphere was warm and cozy, fresh bread was delicious, and the staff was so friendly. I recommend calling for a reservation just to ensure you get a spot when you want one.

Experiencing Bonelli's for the first time tonight, and it WONT be our last. Amazing service, welcoming atmosphere, feels like home!! We got two salads, Baked ziti with meatballs and vodka sauce, and Alfredo, it was high-quality, fresh, and flavorful. We' ll be back!!

The food is absolutely incredible. I love the pesto and t-moneys white sauce. Consistent. Everytime. The service is also incredible. Ashleigh is the best server we have ever had (ever!).
You must make a reservation before though.
Outside heaters keep you warm on cold nights so sitting outside is still enjoyable. Live music outside some nights too. We always love to bring family and friends here when they are in town.

Bonelli's is such a fun, local Italian restaurant! Ashley is a knowledgeable and attentive waitress who had excellent vibes. The food is always so delicious, and Dom the owner checks in on us almost every time we come! Love supporting them and everything they have going on.

Hidden gem in Pensacola! This Italian restaurant is one you won’t want to miss. The food was delicious. Their menu doesn’t lie when it says the food will take while to come out; it is made TO ORDER. Well worth the wait. Our server, Anna, was wonderful. She had great recommendations for the food and was very attentive. The restaurant is unique in that it acquired a home next to the property and renovated the inside to be an extension of the restaurant. The main building offers outdoor seating and inside seating near the kitchen. Between the two buildings is a canopy area offering outdoor seating and a fire pit. I highly recommend visiting!

Best Italian in Pensacola! Joey (Bonelli) is a fantastic host and his staff is amazing! Have been there numerous times with very large parties and everyone has raved about the dishes they ordered! You MUST give it a shot! I guarantee you will be back (again and again and etc…)!!

We took my daughter here for her 14th birthday. The food is great. The portions are big. The prices match what you get. You have to make a reservation or you will not get in. It's very intimate. The service is awesome. I highly recommend this place. If you order the mushrooms, I hope you like garlic. The chicken parm with angel hair pasta was my favorite out of everything we ordered

Cozy small restaurant, with authentic food, generous portions, awesome food quality, and world class service.

Waitress was Hannah and the owner made rounds to all tables during our dinner.

I think this is the best Italian in Pensacola.

The five star ratings given for Bonelli's are all so much deserved. The aroma in the air was the first sign, I knew my meal would be tasty. Just a heads up make a reservation. Outdoor seating is also available. I had a glass of Moscato from the wine list. They also have a full bar available. I love the way the sauces are named on the menu. The portions are HUGE ! Everything was great from the bread, meatballs and mushrooms appetizers, chicken parmesan, house special to the service and atmosphere. One thing I wish I had done was order desert first. I was too stuffed to even think about desert. Bonelli's is ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

This was the best pasta I’ve ever had, would 10/10 recommend. The service was great as well, and the food was a bit slow but you could tell it was made to order with how fresh everything was. I got the shrimp Diavolo and the shrimp was so fresh and cooked perfectly, although the medium spice is not as spicy as I had hoped (I’ll go up to hot next time). The portions are nicely sized and the bread+dip is a nice snack while waiting for the food.

We made reservations for four on a Friday night. We were seated immediately. Our server, Amy was friendly, efficient and very knowledgable. Charming and small the restaurant is clean and well maintained. They also have a couple of outdoor areas, perfect for cooler times of the year. Inside is small and the smells from the kitchen are like a symphony for your nose.

I will have to admit I have never encountered a restaurant where half the menu is based on various sauces and heat(spice) levels. Which myself being a fan of spicy foods, I found quite attractive. This allows you to "build your own" pasta dishes. I would add the servings are Italian family size, HUGE! So either way, sharing entrees or bringing leftovers back for later you could eat for days!

At any rate be sure and check out the "specials" these are original chef creations and were quite good. We had the first special which was a ravioli based layered dish with crumbled meatballs, vodka sauce Italian sausage and lots of cheese on top. What could be bad?

Folks this is truly a fine, family run establishment. It's not what I would call refined dining but the service is good and the food is certainly elevated and delicious. If you're in the Pensacola area dont miss this jewel.

I'm sure it gets really busy so reservations are recommended.
We will definitely be going back!

UrbanCowgill
February 2023

Everything from scratch!! Worth the wait!! Staff is awesome especially" Alli " thank you. Outside patio was attractive with live easy listening music. Keep in mind the Portions were large.Make a reservation at least 2 days in advance folk's!There was also extra parking across the street in front of old Dollar general. Thank you Bonelli's!!

Listen here. To all yall 1/2 star reviewers... how could yall say anything negative about this restaurant!? Everyone contributed to my great experience. Wonderful service service, ambiance, delicious drinks and the best ribeye pasta I could ever ask for. The big time chef came n visited my table and I showered him with complements. The man knows what he is doing and every dish is crafted with art and care. If yall can't wait for your food knowing that go somewhere else... like olive garden. Also shout out to the staff they work so hard. BONELLI'S is simply delicious. I'll be back from new orleans soon enough.

Italy is on my bucket list, one day I hope to go. I've always wondered how true Italian food tastes until today, I think I have an idea now. Bonelli's is an unassuming family owned Italian restaurant with amazing food. First off, please make a reservation, it's a very small space.
I love caprese, so I started out with the half caprese salad. Judging by the size of the half, the whole must be huge! I then ordered the IL Diavolo sauce with rigatoni and shrimp. I ordered it Gina's hot which is a mixture of jalapenos, habaneros and red pepper flakes. My friend had the Eggplant Parmigiano and she loved it. Megan was our server and it is obvious that she loves her job. She described everything we asked in detail and made suggestions for our meal. Truly outstanding service. Not to mention the total thrill of sitting on the covered patio as it rained, snug and cozy. I love it. ❤

WOW. This place was absolutely phenomenal. This place was truly 10/10. I love the vibe and when we first got there it was freezing outside, the hostess quickly came to us and told us to come with her to the bar area where it was warm which was very nice while waiting. We went ahead and started off with some drinks and got a bottle of the Pinot Grigio and I got an espresso martini as well lol. Espresso martinis can be a hit or miss and this one was excellent. Loved the wine and how it paired with our meals. We have tried lots of restaurants. Angelina’s used to be our favorite Italian but after eating this I will come here every time. I told my husband that my tastebuds were literally exploding it was that good. When we finished our shrimp appetizer we were eating the sauce plain it was that good!! This place definitely deserves a 5 star review. Our waitress was also such a sweet girl. Everyone there was so nice and welcoming it felt homey. It’s going to be tough not eating here every single time we go out for dinner now haha. Love this place. Great job Bonelli’s!! Thanks for an amazing dinner and experience!!

Had an absolutely amazing experience! We had a date night, no reservation so we sat at the bar. The bartender, Justin is amazing! Great conversation, food was fantastic, atmosphere was laid back. Overall a great experience!

I can't say enough good things about this spot. My wife and I had heard great things, but it took us a while to make our way here. I've never had Italian food this good. My wife and I ordered an appetizer, 3 entrees, and dessert, and I swear all of them were equally foodgasmic. Meaning, your eyes roll up in your head when you take your first bite because it's THAT good.

The wait staff was fantastic too. We had to sit on the patio because they're reservation only most weekends, and our other couple with kids cancelled on us last second. They didn't have any two person seating inside. It was cold and windy the night we went. The wait staff made sure the outside heaters were close and kept my wife warm! Our server, Amy, was amazing!

Such a wonderful experience. Thank you everyone at Bonelli's!!

My favorite Italian option in the area. Authentic dishes with great wine pairings. Would recommend as a date night option for sure!! Just make sure to call in advance to make a reservation as they are always on a wait from my experience. Either way it's worth the wait!!

Friendly atmosphere and most of all, great food!!! Reasonable price. Worth the wait if you have to. Highly recommend 👍

Celebrate my birthday at Bonelli’s and that was more then what I could ask for ! First we came before our reservation and they made sure we have a place to seat and drink until our table was ready, the bartender was so nice !
The food was amazing, the special rib on ravioli was wow wow wow!
Eggplant parmesano was yummy and I have a feeling that the chicken parm will be even better. Definitely coming back , and will recommend friends to visit it as well!☺✨⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐