Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks

So good and amazing pricing! The lunch special has amazing values my favorite is the chicken parm on the garlic knot. Tried the cannoli today and it was amazing. Every server Ive had here is very kind.

I went for dinner and got a seat inside just make sure to go early to beat the dinner rush because it’s a small place inside. I got greeted by my server Emily and she was nice and friendly! For appetizers got garlic knots and antipasto salad both was delicious! Entrees got the Antonella pie large pizza and beef Stromboli both was tasty! It was a lot of food so got lots of left overs and Emily was nice to box up all our food and wasn’t expecting that since I’m used to doing it by myself but was very appreciated! Food and service was excellent! Definitely recommend if you are craving Italian food in the winter park area!

Omg! The food was AMAZING 🤩 I had eggplant Parmesan, with Caesar salad and broccoli. My husband had the chicken parmigiana with minestrone. The service was impeccable. Everyone was very friendly from the moment we walked in the door. Definitely a hidden gem

Amazing food.
First time getting a Hawaii slice that had white cheese and the ham was thinly sliced. It was good

Also ordered the SMALL Antonella Stromboli and it was HUGE

Our server was so friendly.

Place is small. Just a heads up there's like 3 tables

This was my 2nd time visiting and the food did not disappoint. NY-style, thin crust pizza with excellent sauce and the right amount of cheese. Also, their lunch specials are such a generous portion for the price. I had the Garlic Knot Chicken Parmesan and it was everything you could imagine it would be. The garlic bread was so buttery and light, it really is the highlight of the dish. I'll definitely be back to try something else.

High quality food and people! It is a little too small and hard to get in at certain times, but it's worth it if you do. Delivery business is strong too, so do that if you don't want to wait. Lunch is affordable, dinner a little pricey. Excellent food though, and family owned. Sauce is homemade. Clean and cute. They have improved their little outdoor porch with heating lamps and rain cover for drizzly days.

Pizza was delicious and the gluten free crust was crazy good.

Staff was so kind and reassured that the pizza was gluten free and I’d 100% come back for more.

Greek salad was great too.

Soooo delicious!! The soup! The Pizza!! Where do I begin! Unassuming little place with big flavor!! Clean and absolutely super friendly!! Definitely coming back to try more!!!

So yummy! I tried to eat light, but the small antipasto salad was a ton of delicious food! I also got a bite of my guy's cheese slice and Antonella a boli, OMG wow! Oh and we had the best ever mozzarella sticks! We'll be regulars!

Small little pizza joint, great quality! One of the better pizzas you can get in Florida!

Absolutely amazing family run Italian restaurant. Their sauce is to die for! The large calzone can easily feed 4 adults. Great salads, bread and the sides of meatballs and sausage were delicious!

Met with a great friend here for the first time she had the Antonella Stromboli, small and I had a slice of cheese pizza and a cheese Calzone, small. Amazingly authentic New York style pizza. And this New York born Pizza lover knows her stuff! It is a small quaint little restaurant with a small Patio and Big flavors. The hostess and server went above and beyond with their customer service. This is definitely the pizzeria to come to when you want a cozy atmosphere to catch up with friends or family. I hope even when they go into a new location their customer service never changes. Thanks guys for such a great evening.

The pizza here always fresh and warm. I go to Antonella’s at least once a week. I have never had one bad experience here and I have been a returning customer for a year. The staff is wonderful, kind, and attentive.

This place is the best and reminds me of home (NY/CT). Everyone who works here is super nice, and always treat us like family. Whether it’s giving my son dough to play with or making him a special dessert (he’s obsessed with their chocolate cake) — they go above and beyond. Highly recommend.

What a hidden gem!! We stumbled upon this place for our 7th anniversary and we are so glad we did! The food was delicious! The service was amazing! And they treated us so specially! Highly recommended!

Delicious pizza. The Antonella's Pie is one of my top 3 favorite pizzas in Orlando. Their location is a very small spot in Winter Park near Rollins College. Customer service has always been spot on each time I went. Parking can be a bit of a pain in their plaza but the pizza is absolutely worth it!

Te best gluten free pizza and pasta I’ve ever had ! 🥺 if it was closer to where I live I wouldn’t go anywhere else for pizza

Intimate environment due to extremely limited seating. Staff was extremely friendly and accommodating. Loved the fried calamari (with fried banana peppers.) They use a bit too much garlic for my taste and their sauce was a bit too sweet, but overall a lovely experience!

The food was amazing but the real star for me today was Mary. She will truly make you feel like family. Probably the best service I have had in years! The eggplant garlic knot sliders for lunch were delicious. Thank you again!

One of the best Greek salads I've had. Great food. Great staff. You will feel like family.