Old Towne Inn Supper Club

I’ve been coming to Old Towne for probably the last 20-30 years, and since the previous owners sold, it has been as good, or possibly better, than it ever was. One difference that I miss is the garlic toast with the cheese spread and whipped dessert in the salad buffet.

I don’t want to give my secret out, and now it’s not quite as secret, but… the ribs, when they’re good, they’re like a 9.5/10 even when they’re not amazing they’re still about an 8/10

They increased a bit in price in the last year or two, but I can’t stop coming back.

I’m pretty sure they’re open on Sundays now, just waiting now to call an order of ribs to-go in. (P.s. if you’re just getting the ribs to-go it’s an awesome price again ~$26)

I just rated the atmosphere a 4/5 cause it’s nice, but nothing crazy. The views out over the highway can be a nice painted sky for dinner.

We gave them super short notice (24 hr) for a holiday party and that night they were also doing karaoke in the bar side so that actually turned out being A LOT of fun. Not advocating to give super short notice, just letting you know.

Blane even sold me a gallon of their house made bbq sauce so I could try to recreate them for my family Christmas this year.

We’re having a get together at my house in a few weeks and I will absolutely be getting about 5 racks to go.

Also, what a great opportunity for employment around Westby.

I did not have one complaint about anything.... from the taking my reservation. Being so courteous and fit Me and the wife in.The waitress was just right on top of everything. Courteous and informative, Love the small talk and banter..I wish I would have remembered her name. That's the only gripe that I have...lol But the food was amazing Cooked to perfection and it was so delicious. The wife got pork chops and lobster tail. I ended Up getting a prime rib , Garlic mashed potatoes. A lobster Tail plus all the fixings the salad bar was full and everything was fresh. Crispy. I gotta stop talking about it My mouth is watering we can't wait to get back there We will definitely be going back,and back ,and back and Bringing some friend and family back to this gem! Thanks for everything Me and my wife absolutely loved this place thank you for everything.

A friend recommended Old Towne Inn & we weren’t disappointed. We were seated right away & had a very gracious & attentive waitress. The salad bar was one of the best I’ve seen. There was a variety of choices & everything was fresh. The prime rib, walleye dinners were very tasty & the shrimp cocktail was impressive with very large shrimp. The onion rings were obviously homemade with a great batter. We will definitely be back!

We had the Lenten buffet and enjoyed everything offered. Salad bar was fantastic and the Berens Brandy old fashioned was the best ever.

We were in the area and looking for a supper club for dinner. This was a cozy restaurant, not quite the same ambience as other supper clubs we've been to, but still very nice. The food was delicious but we were most impressed with the service from our waitress. Super friendly and efficient. Will definitely eat here again the next time we're in this part of Wisconsin.

We had a group of about 20. They served us quickly, and the food was awesome. It has an old supper club feel, which is not all bad, but does date the place a bit. We have been before, and will return again!

Best salad bar in the area.

Great waitstaff.

Pleasant atmosphere to dine in.

Prime rib was tender, juicy, and had good flavor.

We stopped here for supper and was pleasantly surprised with the whole experience. The bar was very nice and the old-fashion was very tasty. The soup was great. Excellent salad bar with most fixings. I had the hickory grilled pork chop that was very tasty and tender. My wife had the smothered grilled Chicken breast, also very tasty and tender. We felt their prices were very fair for the quality of the food we had. We will be going back again.

Stellar food and excellent service. If you like supper clubs this is a can't miss experience.

Finally able to stop at old Towne Inn Supper club in Westby. No wait, wonderful staff and absolutely delicious food. Unfortunately, my man dug in too fast to his lobster tails I couldn’t get pics of our entree’s.

We enjoyed our meals! We all tried something different! Our waitress who has been there for 40 years was very pleasant!

True definition of a Wisconsin Supperclub. Fantastic salad bar, steak was perfect!

Really good steak, seafood, salad bar, prime rib. A little pricey but well worth it.

2nd time in 2 years we have been to this area of Wisconsin. Both times we ate here, both times we had the Parmesan encrusted Walleye, yum!
Includes soup and salad bar!
If you are close, just do it!

First time eating since new owners. EXCELLENT food and drinks. Definitely on the list to return. Reservations are a must.

Very good food and outstanding service from our hostess and the staff.
Our first time there and we will be back.

We stayed at the Westby House B & B and decided to have dinner at the Ole Towne Inn one night. Dinner was fantastic, the service was great, highly recommend this place for a night out! We had the bacon wrapped filet mignon, and the super seafood feast and were blown away how good both were. Some of the best food we've had in a long time!

Had my patents 60th anniversary there last week. Very accommodating. Redtrictions on what foods you could have for special events. Food was very good. Salad bar is always clean and fresh. Friday night fish is always great. Our servers were superb and friendly. Love it

Wonderful food, and tried their flight of Old Fashioneds. So much fun!

Stopped in at 7. Got seated right away. Host and hostess were very friendly and polite.
Food was great. Fish and augratin were fantastic. I think we got the best waiter that we have ever had anywhere.
Roman was awesome. We wish the food industry was overwhelmed with people of his caliber. He made our dining night out so pleasant and enjoyable. Thanks Roman. Keep up the great job your doing.
Your attention to detail and making sure everything is satisfactory at the table was so great.
Thanks Again
Tom,Nat,Carol,Donny