Gemignani's Italian Restaurant

Cozy atmosphere and delicious food. Really love the tomato soup (it’s so good!) and garlic shrimp rigatoni.

Always great. Fantastic food and service to match.

Went again tonight. We love this place. Had an off menu item recommended by Nelson, who is awesome.

Great little Italian restaurant in the heart of hancock. Lots of the homemade items made from scratch.. phenomenal food an atmosphere. Service was great and so was all the food. Highly recommend this place. Also they have free birthday dinner, awesome plus. Good wine and beer selection makes this place an easy go to..

We had a very nice Birthday dinner for our Exchange student Anja. Was a great choice and we saved it for right before her returning home to Italy 🇮🇹.

Good restaurant. Excellent food, perfectly prepared. This is the second time we've been here and it's still really good. Service is also friendly and fast. Wine portions were a little stingy. For the price, they could up the serving by a third. I recommend reservations.

Small, quaint place with surprisingly good service and food. We ordered Chicken Alfredo and Eggplant, both were very good. Went outside and they had shoveled a path thru the deep snow to my truck. Give them your business

Food was amazing! Very flavorful. I would definitely eat here again.

We stopped in for an early dinner the place was pretty busy the food is decent as well. The service was good.

What a wonderful surprise! Looks understated on the outside but the food was terrific. The Million Dollar Brussel Sprouts were delicious. We both had the rigatoni with sausage (really bright flavors-yum!) and my husband loved the minestrone. The tiramisu was very good with a dark chocolate sauce drizzle and a chocolate covered espresso bean as nice added touches . Service was top notch! We will likely dine here again before we head back down state.

Always great, free birthday meal such a deal! Sausage rigatoni is good makkara.

I got the spaghetti and meatballs with marinara sauce (thick sauce and excellent flavor) also a side of asparagus and tomatoes..My husband got eggplant parmesan, they knocked it out of the park on all. Ive lived here for 3 years and have not been in. My son visited and he and his girlfriend had dinner there. The next day I tasted a cold meatball and was amazed at how good it was straight out of the fridge.(Quality food, not salty as I read a review below) Cozy small place and best to make reservation or call ahead.

Our experience and dinners were amazing! Everything is homemade and is delicious with fantastic service! We had tomato basil soup, Tuscan pizza, chicken Marsala, Vegan mushroom lasagna and the spaghetti and meatballs. Those meatballs should be patented!! We were all stuffed, but we couldn’t pass up the desserts after everything else was so good. They did not disappoint! Tirimisu, White chocolate raspberry Gelato and chocolate chip Canollis. We will be back for sure!

Everything tasted fresh and it was well presented and prepared.

Was shocked to find authentic Italian in the Northern UP. This place is legit and will not disappoint. Will be back on my next trip.

Really good food and the staff was able to weather an unexpected rush.

Traditional American Italian food with some nice local changes.

It was my wife's birthday and she said it couldn't have been a better way to celebrate. We will definitely be back any time we are in the area.

Very nice food... Try out the basil pesto pasta

We came in 20min before close; the staff was so friendly.
I had the garlic shrimp Alfredo dish- which was awesome.
My wife loved the eggplant dish.
Would definitely come back again!

Food was very good, atmosphere was great. I like the marinara sauce, gnocchi, the pizza, Italian ice cream, and breaded mozzarella. The only complaint I have would be the portion size is a bit small for the pasta.

Was in town after a trip to Isle Royale. This restaurant was packed! Clearly a local favorite. The waiting staff did a great job taking care of everyone despite the rush of people. They were friendly, kind, and efficient. Food was excellent and worth the cost! I’d eat here regularly if I lived nearby. Check it out!

Great service and excellent food. Exceptional tomato bisque. Amazing. Marinara sauce is awesome. I got the Atlantic salmon and it was cooked to perfection (rare without asking, if you don't like rare, make sure you mention that you want it more done--but I would get it rare in a heartbeat).