Tony's Pizza &Pasta Restaurant

Met up with friends here recently. The interior gives that typical pizzeria nostalgic feel.
We were super excited over the many vegan options, I went for a Vegan chicken Stromboli...oh my goodness. It was SO good! The dough itself was heavenly enough and the Stromboli stayed hottttt. It was a huge portion.
Only deducted a star for wait time; if you plan to get something other than pizza don't be surprised for it to take a bit (but so worth the wait). We had garlic knots and good company so it was no big deal.
Thankyou Tony's for thinking of the vegans!

Got a plain pie on a wednesday night during dinner rush. Wait time was about 50 minutes but was worth the wait. Great flavor, was hot, and only $12. With the price of pies sometimes reaching 20+ you cant go wrong. Again worth the wait!

Ordered while staying away for work and the food and service were excellent! The chicken parmigiana was very well cooked and had great flavor, while I was waiting for the food I ordered a slice of pizza to hold me over and it was great. The staff were friendly and attentive to customers. Would highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a good meal at a very reasonable price!!

Our family loves Tony's Pizza. Their food is delicious! The eggplant parm is my favorite and the kids love their pizza. They also offer vegan meals which are delicious. The waitresses are always friendly and provide great service. The owners are so kind and offer our community exceptional Italian food.

We have been looking for a good pizza place in sussex county for so long. Moving here from bergen County, it has been a challenge finding good pizza. I'm so happy this place was recommended to us! We recently had lots of out of town guests and ordered a variety of foods. Everything was delicious! The pizza is so good! Our vegan family members loved the vegan pizza and vegan meatball hero!

Asked my wife to get me a sandwich on her way home. She came back with this beast and I couldn’t be happier lol. First time eating from here so here goes. Visually it looks like someone wanted to make a good looking sandwich———and they totally hit it out of the park. This thing is four inches tall fully stuffed but layered so well that it doesn’t all collapse when you bite it, sending all the topping to one side or just falls off. Also it tastes just as good as it looks and half of that sandwich will hit the spot, full thing and you need a blanket and a comfy couch. If the rest of the food is anything like the attention paid to this sandwich, I will definitely get food from here again.

Nice family owned business.
I was sitting at the table waiting for our 2 pizza pies we ordered.
There was a nice hospitable woman, clearly an owner who had made some nice comments on playfulness with my son. As we were walking out the doors, my daughter dropped both pizzas on the floor, and the pizza was all over the box. I got pretty upset at her. The nice lady saw what happened and made me 2 new pies as a replacement. She also consoled me to not to be upset with my child. She's was right, even if I had my reasons at the time. Her actions were truly beautiful. Not to mention extremely generous.
This place not only has exceptional service, the pizza and food there is excellent and the prices are even better. This is my Italian food place from now on! They are fantastic!

Great pizza, fresh sauce. There cold cut subs are huge, half of a sub is filling enough. Reasonably priced also.

Been going here for a long time. I appreciate them staying open after the ski area closes, for my ride home snack. Every meal is great. Great variety of slices with different toppings. This time I got the buffalo chicken and the vegetable lovers slice and white slice with broccoli. In the past when Im not showing up at closing time, the sandwiches and meals were the best.

I just had the eggplant parm sandwich. This is one of the best items on the menu. It was delicious. Layers and layers of soft eggplant mixed with a homemade-tasting sauce. It's not easy to get a good eggplant parm. They give you a great amount of eggplant too. Please go if you are a fan of this sandwich. I was thoroughly satisfied...

I love this place i come here every time i have a break at dance. The food is delicious and the staff is more than welcoming and friendly. Just be warned that there can be huge lines at times.

We LOVED trying Tony's for lunch today!! Incredible vegan options, and our server Amanda was so sweet and helpful. Don't hesitate- come here for your next meal.

I love this place. The pizza in my opinion is the best in the area and it's always cooked to order. The service is fast and friendly and the atmosphere is just like I remember the pizza places from the 80s.

Great spot with vegan options! Very attentive and the food was good. I liked that they kept the old style menu.

I always try to stop here when im in area .love the food

Delicious pizza have a good Wednesday deal

The food is great here. I stopped in for an Angelo's special sandwich and it was as good as I remembered. This was the goto Italian when I lived in the area and, from what I can still is

The salad I got was great. Especially the grilled chicken. It was nice and big but not overwhelming. I brought a nice portion of leftovers home. They had a high chair for my toddler and were great with him. They brought an extra little plate for him so he could eat a portion of our meal (he's only 16 months). The waitress was friendly and active with our table. I have no complaints.

Very slow service but food was worth the wait. Took an hour for a call ahead pizza for pick up on a Saturday afternoon.

I've always had great experiences at Tony's. From the food to the people, everything is exactly what you'd want it to be. I would highly suggest trying their birch beer if that's your thing. Their buffalo chicken pizza is delicious and their personal pizza is what I would expect for a small from other places. Definitely the place to go if you're looking for a family run pizza place.