Stefano's Pizzeria (New York Style)

Being from downstate NY, I’m always on the hunt for authentic NY style pizza in the WNY region. Stefano’s came through! Solid crust, super cheesy, and a perfectly tart, subtle sauce.

Thank you! Me and my family passed by this town for pizza and we had an amazing experience here. Very recommended here.

Man, spare of the moment hunger hit me at 9:30 pm. The small Pepperoni pizza and mild wings were delicious. True NY style.

From ya friendly yinzer nieghbor. I suggest a stop in.

So tried this place for the first time. Pretty good pizza. Definitely a nice NY style pizza. Picked up a large cheese. Nice dough. Not too chewy. Good amount of cheese. Sauce was a bit bland but nothing some garlic powde didn't fix. Only complaint is the guy working there could cheer up a bit,didn't seem too happy. Maybe a bad night idk. Anyhow I'd definitely come back and try them again.

Great NY style pizza. Highly recommend

This was a great stop on our way back to Philadelphia. We highly recommend it.

I'm glad I found Stefano's on my way to Pavilion!! Delicious buffalo chicken pizza!

Pizza is delicious! I've never had a bad one here. Staff was helpful.

Freshly made pizza, a hand tossed crust. Pretty good selection of beverages, g great selection of toppings, and they make more than just pizza. Relaxed, comfortable atmosphere. Fast courteous service. Cash or card, order in, carry out, or delivery.

Quick stop on my way back to Pennsylvania. Pizza was good and cheesy. Staffs was friendly.

So delicious, very friendly gentleman that waited on us and prepared our food as well. Highly recommend checking this place out.

Had a turkey sub and it was pretty good, but asked for rolls to be toasted and they were not toasted and to be quite honest this is the fourth time I have asked for toasted roll for sub and have gotten untoasted so not sure why that is so difficult to do or get right but I have even emphasized to order taker to make sure rolls are toasted and still don't get it but sub was good otherwise, prices are a little steep but it is what it is, it's nice that they deliver and they are open quite late too.

Was hot a delicious.
Said 45 min for delivery up on east hill was only 31 min fast fast fast!

If you want Brooklyn style pizza or just want really good pizza, then look no further. I know good pizza from bad pizza. My wife and I really enjoyed his pizza. I would highly recommend this to a friend.

Great food and friendly service. Will definitely visit again

Stopped for Pizza and wings on our way to Washington and it was the best pizza we’ve had in a long time. Saw the name from the stop light and thought that sounds good and it was.

Tastes so good, makes you wanna slap yo momma!!! Im fit'n to call for a pizza right motha (explicit)ing now. Tawkin bout some exter cheese and paparazzi!!! GET U SOME!!! NOM SAYIN?

So so very friendly..not to mention NICE and the pizza was good.. They even told me about a PARK..
Letchworth..about 25 minutes from here..

Pizza and salad were really good and staff was very friendly.

We're from Williamsville went in late and the owner said " you'll love the pizza" ...... THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE ATE IN YEARS .....for real it is that good