Anderson's Supper Club

I love coming here! Busy but not ever packed for a 2hr plus wait that I’ve ever had. Owner,bartenders, and waitresses do a fantastic job. I had the 8oz tenderloin and it cut like butter! Should have a taken a pic prior to eating it but couldn’t wait . Had a side of hot tortellini which I thought was a nice change. Cozy quiet dining room and that rustic feel. It’s like a hidden gem.

Place was busy so that means it's great! The menu was simply and easy to order from. My perch was a little over-battered for my taste but still was good. Hubby had the shrimp and Ribeye and said it was fabulous. Would go back again!

Awesome Prime rib, can’t wait till they start serving breakfast. Trail time is “Prime Time” at Anderson’s!!!

Fabulous prime rib! I got the prime and lobster combo, and my brother got the king cut. My dad got a queen. You can see my brother's cut is about three inches thick, no joke. If you've ever heard this place has them together and best prime rib, you've heard right. Still have doubts? Come see for yourself! You won't be disappointed.

What a great place to eat. Excellent service and food was delicious! The owner was so caring and polite too! We will be back!

I’ve been all over Wisconsin for a good steak and I have to say that the best prime rib that I ever had was at Anderson’s Supper Club. Great meal! You won’t be disappointed! Thanks Gary!

I’m sorry to say that I went back this year and it wasn’t that good. Had a very tough piece of prime rib so I don’t know what happened. Different owners perhaps?

Well worth the stop. Always great service and food and you can hear a good joke from Gary.

Fantastic Prime Rib tonight! Maiden Lake was 2.5hr wait, we sat at Andersons in minutes(good timing). I’ve had my share of prime rib special in this area, tonights’ topped them all. Excellent, attentive staff. Andersons will be our go-to on our next trip. Great job!

Super friendly staff and cheap food!

Our first time experiencing Andersons's last night. Took my husband, parents and nephew to celebrate my husband's birthday. We were so pleased with our meals and service. My husband orders Prime Rib all the time and said it was the BEST he has ever had. We will definitely be back!!

Great food & service in a rustic atmosphere.
They don't take reservations. It's a small place & we had a long wait at 6pm on a Saturday.
Next time we'll go earlier.

My kind of place , great food and good friends. Bar has a nice fresh look 👀 👍

Nice place! Had a great piece of Walleye and loved the bar.
Update: Came back next year and tacked the king cut prime rib, fantastic. Tool two days but ate every bit of it.

Haven't been here since probably 2 owner's ago. I had their Small plate BBQ Ribs. It was wonderful, cooked great, fell right off the bone. Very tasty as well. Service was very good both at the bar and for dinner. Will DEFINITELY be coming here again!!

The prime rib Anderson's serves on Saturdays was absolutely Fabulous! It was very busy and they had a well organized seating process. Excellent dining experience. We will go there again!!

Best place to have a steak dinner Around the north woods of wisconsin .
Here's a tip....
A t m does not work sometimes bring cash.

Pros:
Huge portions
Family style
Great food and drinks

Cons:
27th of May and it was pretty warm inside.  Not awful but definitely could've been cooler.

Nice neighborhood restaurant.
6pm on a Saturday, not very many people so we were a little weary at first, but no reason to be.
Memorial day weekend, other local places were packed.
Restaurant was fairly hot, not a typical cool supper club.
Ordered a brandy old fashioned sour, very good.
Funny detail, tried ordering a special drink on a little card on the table and nobody in the restaurant knew what it was which wasn't a big deal, neither did we :) So we got a the old fashioned instead.
Rolls were excellent, had chicken noodle soup which was good.
Got water midway through our soups and salad which wasn't a big deal because we got our drinks right away.
Rolls came in a cool bucket with a towel inside.
The theme here is real laid back, family style supper club but has a nice wood themed dining room.
No cloth napkin to put on your lap that are usually found in most supper clubs, but it wasn't a big deal.
Locals eventually filled the bar and were a little loud as its one open room, but it wasn't too big of a deal.
Water came with a coaster on the table which was a nice touch.
Prime rib came, cooked med-rare. Got the queen and it filled the whole plate. Giant. Fries, baby reds, and homemade chips were all excellent. Huge portions! Prices weren't bad at all.
Had a younger waitress who was fantastic.
She was genuine, friendly, and accommodating.
Truly couldn't be happier with this experience!

The owner was extremely accommodating to our party. Very attentive staff. Food was excellent. Will definitely be going back

Best Old Fashions around, ribs were awesome, stuffed shrimp was awesome!!

Review is for andersons supper club. Had a great tasting beer and a MOUNTAIN of well made food. Talked with the owner while we had our beer. Give them some business. It's a great family run place.