New York Grilled Cheese Wilton Manors

*** The Best Grill Cheese I Ever Had ***
This was my first time at New York Grilled Cheese. The service was great but be prepared to wait a while for your food.

After eating here and tasting my grill cheese sandwich, I can see now why it was so crowded. The food was definitely worth the wait.

I had the Village Vegan sandwich. It literally melts in your mouth. I've had many grill cheese sandwiches in my life and this one was absolutely the best I've ever had.

Highly Recommend. 5 stars!

I visited New York Grilled Cheese Co. tonight and ordered the Blue Buffalo sandwich with a mushroom bisque instead of the usual tomato soup. The sandwich was delicious, with tender chicken strips, tangy buffalo sauce, and melted blue cheese on sourdough bread. The mushroom bisque was a pleasant surprise, as it had a clear broth with a sweet flavor that complemented the sandwich well. I think it was a better choice than the tomato soup, but I know some people might disagree. The waiter was friendly and seemed happy that I enjoyed the food. I would recommend this place to anyone who loves grilled cheese and wants to try something different. It was a satisfying and flavorful meal that hit the spot.

One of my absolute favorite places to eat. The food is amazing and never disappoints. Can be a little pricey but so worth it in my opinion and it’s very filling. I’ll never stop coming here and recommending it to people. The staff is great as well and the variety of beers are endless. The tomato soup here is better than any other place I’ve tried.

I love this place!!! It hits the spot always !!! My bf and I got the porkster 7.5/10 and my favorite the 5th ave add max and cheese!! 10/10 Jewelz was very sweet Thankyou guys !!

I love coming to this NY grilled cheese location and having Aaron as our server. He provides great recommendations and made us laugh every time. The food is amazing, and my favorite thing to get is the Soho Sweet. Highly recommend!

I loveeeee this place! We were greeted by Aaron, and he is just the absolute BEST! The food is amazing with many options of grilled cheese sandwiches and the fries are fire. I opted for the basic one, but basic it was not! I paired it with glass of Prosecco and had a great time here. It looks small from the outside but it extends all the way to the back. A cozy and fun environment with friendly people. I enjoy coming here anytime I’m in Wilton manors.

Must try! Who doesn’t like a good grilled cheese to start with??? We selected 3 plus the cheese & truffles fries. Everything was so flavourful. My favourite was definitely the Buffalo chicken grilled cheese but everything looks so good that it’s hard to make a selection. It comes with tomato soup to dip it in. This soup is the best tomato soup I’ve ever had and I thought I was making a good one myself. The lady who was working there really really love the menu and it shows! So if you’re around in Wilton Manors, this has to be on your must try places.

The food here is amazing, you can't go wrong with any of the options on the menu. Also recommend getting extra tomato bisque because you'll want to have more later. The wait for the food was pretty quick, I'd say around ~5-10 minutes and the staff were professional.

This was the best grilled cheese and pulled pork I have ever had! The Brooklyn Porkster was so tender and cheesy. Our server Aaron was hilarious and super attentive. We will definitely be back the next time we are in town.

Definitely going back! Upon entering this establishment you are immediately greeted and seated.
Our server was Andrew and he did not disappoint! Andrew was patient and of course knowledgeable of the items on menu, even mentioned his favorite " 5th Avenue" -which was very good. I had the Vegan Poutine and it was delicious! Great location, loved the energy, awesome vibes, truly reminded me of back in New York where you would find some hidden gem with good food and a judgement-free zone🏳‍🌈

The best grilled cheese I've ever had! What a great experience throughout.

Went to get lunch somewhere new and I'm so glad I found this spot. The staff members were welcoming and the food was freshly made.

Such a gem right in the middle of Wilton Manors. If I had known sooner, I would have frequented this restaurant!

This is our go to late night spot for the best grilled cheese sandwiches in the area. Also, the tomato bisque soup is super tasty and complements all the grilled cheese sandwiches. Be prepared to wait some nights as it can get really busy, but the wait totally worth it.
The wait staff this always nice, friendly and helpful. The place is always clean.
They keep adding new seasonal flavors to the menu, so there’s always something new to try.

Warning: This place has a plethora of cheese. Hope that's your thing.
My dish did not fall short in the cheese department! My Mac and Cheese w/bacon Grilled Cheese Sandwich was hot, ooey gooey, creamy, fatty, scrumptious, and CHEESY! The waffle style bread was crunchy and perfect. My waffle fries on the side were crunchy, but was missing seasoning.
A 98 yr old man once gave me advice to "Toast your bread and add ingredients to it". I think I did that today. Also, I will add this place is in dedication to an unforgettable spirit "Magic" Michael Entenza, he passed too soon at age 24.
I was greeted immediately when I walked in the door, and was free to seat myself. My server made recommendations on the menu and was personable throughout my visit.
The menu has plentiful choices and shows considerations for dietary needs suck as vegan, vegetarian, and gluten conscious.
Dining room may be petite, but the environment and decoration on the walls keeps your mind busy. I love this neat little place!! Can't wait to come back.

Went for a special occasion on a weeknight. Employee with curly black hair was very attentive, and sweet. Originally went for the poutine but ended up liking the other items I ordered more; wall street grinder, blue Buffalo, Truffle fries, garlic fries, even the tomato soup. I have zero interest in tomato soup and I loved it. And the commercials on the tv are hilarious, even though they're repeated.

Please open one in Kendall or dade. I'm too far away from you. :(

The food was absolutely delicious!!! From the fries to the grilled cheese. But the real star of the show is the amazing tomato bisque. Get the bigger bowl. Trust me. It turns your grilled cheese sandwich up a notch, one couldn't think to dream of. Everytime I visit, I'll be sure to stop in!

This was our first time to New York Grilled Cheese, and it was awesome. Mom wanted some comfort food for Mother's day, and I'm came across NY Grilled Cheese on Google. We were quite pleased. Ben was our server and provided excellent service. He made good recommendations. We hardly had to wait, and the food was on point. This was the 3rd restaurant I've been to in Wilton Manner, and the service as well as as the food has been spot on. If you are in the mood for comfort food (grilled cheese sandwich, tomato bisque, and fries) NY Grilled Cheese is the best place to go!

First time here and it won’t be the last! The food was so delicious and the service was wonderful! Small joint but didn’t matter - it all worked out and in the end we left with VERY full bellies.

Make a point to stop here if you’re in Wilton Manors. The food is great (and huge— come hungry). I had the mushroom grilled cheese that was on special for $10 and my dad had the one with all the meats. Grilled cheese sounds simple, but the choices are unique and interesting, yet still comfort food with the side of tomato bisque for dipping. We shared fries with garlic aioli and cheese curds— perfect, crispy, cheesy, tangy garlic heaven in your mouth.
Food was out quickly and Jules made sure we had everything we needed and kept our sodas full.
Thanks for a great experience!

One of my favorite go to meals as a child was of course Grilled Cheese. As I got older I added a cup of Tomato Basil soup to that go to menu. Yesterday I finally had a chance to visit and I was just like a little girl perched at the tip of my seat excited to see the grown up version of
My GO TO MEAL… I ordered the Broadway and it was delicious. I think what made the experience even more gratifying was the happy welcome when I walked in. I was of course caught up in taking my pictures for the review and each time I was approached by the staff I giggled as I was either snapping a picture or getting a call talking about how I was excited to finally be at the location. The funny part is I left happy and excited to have eaten. Later on that evening we went to a Halloween party down the street and about 1:00 in the morning we ended up at the same location. Normally I don’t return in less than 12 hours maybe 12 days… so for me to have the same feeling and enjoy another moment here fulfilled my love for grilled cheese and tomato bisque… staff was busy and although the morning team was amazing the night team was courteous but not as friendly as before. At the end our waiter referenced was it better than the Broadway earlier? I realized he was paying attention but with so many people who were either dressed in costume, a few drinks in and no seats available, he was just busy and deserved the same accolade as the morning waiter. Just for the record I had the Wall Street Grinder.. so in fairness the Broadway was a 10 for me but the Wall Street Grinder 9.75 because I was exhausted from dancing… To make sure… I am planning another trip back soon as I am dreaming (literally dreamed) of the bacon lollipops… we added fries too last night but the couple next to me ordered theirs with all the works and I almost got the urge to reach over and grab a piece of theirs.

For now this place is delectable! And I am planning to bring my adult kids with me next time as I feel the years of grilled cheese meals at home just went to another level…

Only been here twice and I’m in love! First, the place was nice and clean both times I went and the server was also very nice and attentive. Now…THE GRILLED CHEESE😍 so so so good and even the tomato bisque (and I don’t even like tomatoes) I had the Broadway Classic and the Time Square Pizza Melt, they are both 10/10.