Benny Meleto's

We have enjoyed Benny’s at many different locations but this one was great. I called ahead one day to have a large pizza picked up right before the NFL playoff first round. I figured I would still be waiting on such a high demand day. However, I walked in 10 min early and my pizza was hot and ready to go home for the game. The pizza was delicious…especially the crust. I will always use Benny’s as my pizza source where available.

Good food.
Nice setting.
Pizza ie gigantic, which is awesome.
Prices good.
Fed 8 of us with 1 pizza..

Got the pepperoni pizza with a drizzle of hot honey. The slice is huge and the pizza is great! I like a place that knows what they do well and that's all they do.

Amazing pizza big Ole slices that just make you excited to bite in and see if you can tackle it. They have pizza challenge to if you wanted to try to finish a whole pizza with someone and win prizes. Very nice employees and good pizza. Definitely a place to give a try.

Taste - perfect
Atmosphere- perfect
Service - perfect
Portion size - remind me to bring a friend.

Really good place.

What a good place to get an excellent slice of pizza and a soda. This is a small no frills laid back pizza joint. I had the Pepperoni pizza which is huge. The price is unbelievable inexpensive at $6. If your walking around downtown Winchester you have to go get a slice of pizza.

Best pizza around! The pizzas are huge! The pizza box can double as a dog bed. A slice is almost the size of a baby! The taste it incredible!
Cheese slice is $5
With pepperoni and garlic mushrooms it's $6!

Love this pizza in Winchester, VA. I CANNOT GET OVER THE SIZE OF ONE SLICE OF PIZZA - the size I dream about eating. Today we ordered our first full size pizza and it did not disappoint. The crust is just fantastic, not too thick but sort of light. It’s not just a novelty due to the unique size - the pizza is very delicious! Go try it!

Growing up on Long island in New York, I grew up with good pizza! Since moving down to Virginia, it's been a little bit harder to find.
This place does it right! Delicious pizza, and huge slices. Fun atmosphere, good selection of sodas in the cooler, and really good prices. I really can't say enough good stuff about them. If you like real pizza, you've gotta try this place!

Huge pizza, we went on a Sunday evening and it wasn't busy at all. We got a half cheese half pepperoni pizza. It was very good, the crust was very good as well. Quick service. They do not have fountain drinks, just cans and bottles. The slices are very hard to eat but its definitely fun.
Bathrooms were clean when we went.
Cute little area for kids to eat in.
I can imagine it gets crowded on weekend nights.

This place and its pizza are very nostalgic and fun! I have seen this place get busy, but it is often easy to get a seat and service. The folks working there are always a delight. Thanks Benny's for bringing this awesome staple to Winchester!

If you love pizza, this is the place to go. Not only is the pizza big, but it is delicious!!!

Amazing pizza at a really great price! Conveniently located right on the walking mall around shops and offices, Benny Meleto's offers a selection of pizza slices from their 28" pies. The crust is super thin and the crust very soft inside and crispy outside. There's indoor seating and the awesomest ice cream sandwiches! Staff is always friendly and service is super fast, so it's a great option for a quick lunch as well. Highly recommend grabbing some slices before heading to Broken Window brewery right up the street from there!

Best pizza I have ever had wow just a great place to visit a must see to believe place.

We found this little gem by accident while passing through Winchester. It’s a small little pizza place with BIG pizza slices. I had a slice of cheese, simple and to the point, I’d never seen a slice of pizza that size. The sauce was delicious, the crust was flavorful and had a perfect crunch, if had to do it again, I’d ask for extra cheese but that’s just me. Next time we come, we’ll definitely get the entire pizza pie. Yummy! 🍕

Very good by-the-slice pizza. Not good for a date, unless you’re a teenager. But nice if you or your group is hungry for pizza and doesn’t have a lot of time. People can also get different slices rather than sharing a pizza that isn’t their favorite.

Huge pizzas, but absolutely delicious. I'm super picky when it comes to pizzas, grease levels, crust, the whole 9 yards. I was honestly scared to get one of the and not like it, but mad alive this was one of the best pizzas I've ever had. 5/5 👌🍕

Amazing pizza, first time here but definitely will not be the last. Had to drive 30 minutes to get here and it was definitely worth the drive. 1 pizza fed my entire family of 6 and still had 2 slices left

Great huge pizza slices! Stopped for lunch while shopping. Very quick service, good seating and friendly staff.

Great pizza, friendly staff, definitely worth a visit. Their pizzas are huge, also ava by the slice.