On a Roll

One of the local favorites..fresh ingredients is the key to their success. The people over there are also very friendly. The food quantity is really good. Affordable prices for the quantity and quality. Upgrade to the whole sub and share between two people!

Get the local special. I just found this place after hiking and the region and I'm very glad I did. The guy behind the counter recommended a local specialty chicken sandwich. That was phenomenal.

The employees' personalities are fun! The food is fantastic!! They were quick, friendly, and the food is so worth our stop on the way to Seneca Lake.

The best subs and salads in town! Service is amazing and the consistency is spot on everytime! Rogers Dumpster Rentals loves the crew here and the food!

Looks so unassuming, but they make great food. Opened in 1986, the building looks it, but don't let that fool you. The ingredients are fresh, and I don't know where the rolls come from, but they are excellent.

Happened upon this place and I’m glad I did. Rolls were super fresh and soft. I got a chicken wing sandwich that was out of this world. Prices are reasonable. I recommend upping to a whole versus a half it is a better deal for $1.25 more. If I am ever in the area again this will be a must stop.

Man oh man, I mean wow!! What an absolute gem here in Horseheads. I was passing through and stopped for lunch and grabbed the turkey sub with all the toppings on it. The sub was absolutely incredible, very tasty and loaded up with toppings! The guy who made my sub was super nice and the vibe from the workers in general was a positive one. This is my new lunch spot when passing into town, great stuff!

My bf and I just left there. I tried a sub called the bear and it was delicious! They are always super friendly there. Haven’t had a bad experience ever.

Great variety of food. The crew there is super friendly, seems to know almost everyone that comes in and always remembers my normal meal. Never had a bad meal or experience there.

Had my first spiedie here. Instant classic. The portions are generous, the prices are reasonable, and the food is delicious. Must stop by here if you’re in the area.

Outstanding food (I suggest the chicken speedy) and outstanding service. Genuinely one of the best restaurants in the area.

Excellent customer service and a delicious chicken wing salad! Definitely going back!

Came back to town from Phoenix. Went in to have what I remembered as the best sandwiches. I was not disappointed. Brought the family and had the classic Italian, the Reuben and Chicken Speedies. So good that my wife and son made me take them back before we left town. Thanks On a Roll crew!

Amazing place to settle down, small but really enjoyable. The service is the best I've seen in this town locally and I'd say it's better than some of the fine dining around here too. The prices for their sizes of subs and salads is pretty on the point. Fresh used ingredients from what I've tasted and it's all cooked to order. So far? 10 out of 10 for me!

Great little place for wonderful food. Staff is excellent and the food was amazing!

The staff and the food here are spectacular. The folks running this place and all the employees seem to genuinely enjoy their work, and they are always on top of it, even when it gets crowded. Subs, salads, everything is money. You’ll enjoy the experience.

Best chicken speedies around! The staff is always so friendly too!

I was telling one of my friends that I really wanted a watermelon salad and she told me about this amazing place. We stopped in this afternoon, and it was like no other place in that everyone behind the counter was friendly, we were welcomed as soon as we walked in the door. We both ordered watermelon salads and I have to tell you, this was the best I’ve ever had. I will definitely be coming there every week throughout the summer to get my fix! Thank you so much!!

Yes the interior decor is simple and yes the building is old BUT neither of them matter when the sub is this good. I highly recommend ordering the Italian with provolone and grilled mushrooms. Price is very reasonable and the service was outstanding.

We got the meatball sub. The food was delicious - exactly the warm meal we needed. Staff was quick and very friendly!