PIZZA 1905 Lake Mary

Pretty good, you can eat in at one of the few tables or take out. Nice folks serve the deep dish Chicago style pie, which is very large and tasty. I like my pizza piping hot and next time I will ask them to keep it a little longer in the oven. For take out it is perfect since it’s probably going to be warmed up at home.

I usually order a Small Pepperoni with extra cheese for my lunch / dinner. Growing up in Upstate New York, mom and pop pizza restaurants are better than National Chains. Yes I can get a Large 1 topping for $10 (at a National Chain), the same price as a Small 1 topping $10 (at a mom and pop place) but Pizza 1905 is that mom and pop place that taste and feel like actual pizza instead of bread and little toppings per slice.

I keep saying this is my favorite pizza spot please come and try what's new now ask for the pulled pork sub wednesday to friday let's support local and what originates from them as the best pizza in town. The picture is the 24” pizza

Quick service,I got the two slices and a water, with extra cheese. One of the few places that actually gave me extra cheese, so much it was all melted and yum. The slices were really huge, especially for the cheap price. The pizza was so good too.

I was very pleased to have purchased a gorgeous pizza from these nice folks, they understand how a quality pie should look and taste! I have been trying out different spots for pizza lately and these folks “know what time it is!”

Update from 1 star to 5 stars. The staff here have gone above and beyond to correct, the issue. Could not have asked for a better response. Thank you, for the professionalism that you showed in correcting the problem.

Have ordered before and had great service until tonight. Spoke to two different people and repeated the order several times, order was still delivered wrong. Absolute horrible service. Pizza that was delivered had onions and mushrooms. Pizza that was ordered was onions and pepperoni. I am allergic to mushrooms. They did not answer their phones after several phone calls from two different phones, less than a minute after the delivery driver left, without the ability to leave a message. $32 for pizza and $5 tip down the drain. Would leave negative stars if able to. Obviously we were the last order for the night, as no care was even given to the delivery and preparation of the food. For a place that has such great pizza, it’s horrible to know that such lack of care or concern is given to customers at the end of the night.

This place is amazing! Best pizza since I moved to Florida from NY!! The pizza was cooked perfectly the employees were super friendly! Kuudos to Chris who made our pizza you killed it bro!! If yall are content eating some nasty hungry Howie pizza pop over to a pizza 1905 so you can see what real pizza tastes like 🍕 highly recommend it

Very good pizza and garlic knots! Friendly staff very welcoming! Definitely will be back!

If you’re looking for a deep dish pizza this is the place to go!!! Holy cow I as it incredible. And the service was very friendly both over the phone and while waiting.

Thank you! We will be back

It was such an amazing place. The staff was amazing and the only place I can really say that had the real NY Pizza taste. I'm from The Bronx tried all the places down here. This definitely was the place to go. Surely will be missed.

I LOVE this place!! The staff is so friendly and make you feel at home. I am from NY and half Italian and had no idea FL had authentic Italian. The pizza is great!! My new favorite place :)

1905 has the best pizza in lake mary and anywhere else around! knocks everyone else out of the competition. the bianca pizza is my favorite also their garlic knots are to die for! i travel 20 minutes away to and from at least once a month or whenever i can just for some yummy pizza i swear! and ontop of that the staff is always full of smiles and so friendly! i went in during a hurricane and they were open and told me to take a free soda can and told me to stay safe! they truly care for their food and their customers!

The owner is from Italy the staff is super friendly. The pizza is large foldable NY style slices a bit pricey but well worth it. The best ingredients and Pizza I have found in Lake Mary, highly recommended. The stromboli and pepperoni pizza are great!

We are on vacation and ordered from 1905. Pizza was delicious and so was the calzone. Food was delivered to our hotel room hot and fresh. Customer service is on point. Very friendly and personable staff. Delivery guy was told he could call and we would come down to get the pizza yet he took the extra time to bring it directly to our room. We will definitely order again. The food was wonderful. I would have posted a picture but we are already eating it 😆

Great pizza and stromboli!! Went here for lunch today and got the bianca pizza and a meat lovers stromboli. They both were amazing. The pizza had great crunch taste. The stromboli was PACKED with meats and cheese. We ordered a side of meatballs for our little one and they were great too! The dining room is small but nice. In the future we will probably order for delivery or get takeout. Overall great experience. Love what they are doing here.

I’m not one to write reviews, tonight I am taking the time to do so. I have to say I was quite nervous to give pizza 1905 a try do to the fact that I’ve never heard of them before here in Seminole County and I also read a few reviews that weren’t so good about them. But they proved those reviews wrong maybe those days weren’t their days but that Chicago Deep Dish Pizza was the best I’ve ever had. Very filling, had enough with one slice definitely had some leftovers the next day best believe. Thank god we found them. No more driving to Orlando for deep dish. Looking forward to trying the other pizzas and desserts they serve. Thanks !

I'm from Chicago and will typically never order pizza when I'm out of State because nothing will compare. Pizza 1905 came pretty darn close using quality ingredients and great tasting sauce! Quick and friendly service which is hard to find lately. I eat out way too often so very few places impress me enough to leave a review - so Well done 1905!

Since there open I been going to this pizza place, Never a long wait green quality great taste clean location very great price

Tried this place for the first time and loved it !

From here on out I'll skip ordering from some "corporate" pizza chain and give these guys the business instead. Can't wait to try out some of the other menu items like their calzones or deep-dish pizza.

Very high quality pizza. I ordered from here for a family dinner with friends while on vacation in Orlando and everyone enjoyed everything we ate. The staff were super nice and very patient as it was my first time ordering from this place.
To me, I don’t recall eating a better pizza in my life. I could tell ingredients are fresh. I will definitely eat there again the next time we are in Orlando.