A Little Slice of Italy

We selected Annie who owns and operates A Little Slice of Italy as our caterer for our wedding on 12/9/2023. She did an AMAZING JOB! We met at her restaurant months before the wedding to discuss our wants and needs and she checked every single box to ensure a perfect feast! Wonderful communication and reassurance that everything would be handled without an issue. We met once again closer to the wedding to cover the details and finalize our selection and guest count – again more reassurance that the buffet would be sure to please every guest we had. We decided on a ziti with Italian sausage, chicken parmesan, bread sticks, and Caesar salad. Everything was absolutely delicious! We had compliments all night about the food! There were roughly 250+ guests and they certainly didn’t go hungry! Our niece (3 years old) literally wiped her plate clean with her bare hands. Side note, the fan favorite were the bread sticks 😊 I’m pretty sure one of my groomsmen ate about 8 of them, ha!! We are certainly excited to devour our leftovers!

Additionally, Annie took care of our dessert and handmade 250 cupcakes! The guests said they just melted in their mouths – best icing we’ve every tasted! They were stunning with the perfect amount of decorative toppings that matched the wedding colors. She also made a wedding dress and suit out of the cupcakes and was able to do a last-minute color change to make our desserts extra special. They were beautifully crafted and made for a wonderful display! I’m hoping someone took a picture because I’d love to add it to this review!

If anyone is looking for a caterer for their big day or any other event, I would highly recommend Annie at A Little Slice of Italy. You will not be disappointed! Or stop at the restaurant and divulge yourself in the amazing selection of scrumptious food! Thanks again for making our special day extra special! You rock!

My new favorite pizza place!! Just had the veggie with Canadian Bacon, couldn't have been any better. Don't forget the extra soft, large chocolate chip cookies 😋. I can't wait to go back for more of everything. Thanks Lindsey for a great experience 👍

The deep dish has a non-traditional thinner crust style (but is still deep dish), and was fantastic. Their Chicken Alfredo pizza has become my fiancee's favorite (and she normally never likes anything other than cheese pizza.)

Their sandwiches are also amazing, and very reasonably priced.

The prices match the quality (you pay a little more and get amazing quality when compared to other places), and the staff is super friendly.

I would recommend anyone passing through Colfax to take a stop at A Little Slice of Italy. (Just be mindful of the building, it's not quite square.)

One of the best dishes of lasagna I have ever had in my life! You will not believe the flavor added by the meat and a special spice that you will taste when you bite into the lasagna! Oh oh oh so dang good!
You have to check this place out!!

Delicious pizza and their Wednesday buffet is something you must experience. We have a spectacular nook in our Village. Service is polite and pleasant.

Excellent pizza, the other dishes are very good.

My favorite pizza in the area! The chicken bacon ranch is the household favorite!

A true hidden gem in a small town 👌. Perfectly Awesome pizza! Fresh baked chocolate chip cookie and ice cream for dessert. Thanks Lindsay for the great service too!

By far the best small town pizza shop I have ever been to. The fiance and I have enjoyed Little Slice of Italy every weekend since we stumbled across them. Every pizza they make is delishous, very friendly staff, fair pricing. Love the small town atmosphere. Highly recommend you try this place!

Awesome little restaurant with the best pizza around. Staff are super friendly. We love this place, add a side salad with your pizza and it will be perfect!

nice staff, good food, overall great place.

I've been to a handful of small town pizza places but this ones by far my favorite. Kind and friendly staff, and delicious pizzas. Would highly recommend.

Got the gyro pizza, I’m in love. New favorite pizza. Excellent service, and seem like good people.

Amazing pizza. Staff are friendly and do their best to communicate when busy. Several orders and little to no mistakes.

The best pizza North of Chicago

Server, Brittany, was awesome. She kept me informed of timing of order, the restaurant was extremely busy.

Fabulous experience all around! Very friendly staff, two delicious pizzas and topped our dining experience off perfectly with Cedar Crest ice cream!

Great, cozy little place. Great pizza as well as other food options. Has great workers and has been part of the community for years.

Great service, good food and the waitress always had a smile on her face and I didn't have to wait long to get my food. And the ice cream is really good.

The staff are super friendly and willing to help you enjoy your meal. Wonderful pizza.