BaySide Tavern

This place is so good that even though we are only here for 4 days we've already gone for dinner twice. Both times were great. Their soup of the day has also been good both times. (the other one was Creamy Tomato but I was too hungry to snap a pic) The service was excellent, you get good portions, and their prices are reasonable. Fair warning it is a sit yourself place and it fills up quick. Also those who don't like noise probably should skip this place as it can get noisy. (But I don't mind - especially when the food is good)

Bacon cheesebuger was delicious. Large hand pattied juicy 1/3 pound burger. Almost too huge for one person to eat alone. Onion rings were golden brown, crispy and perfect! Come hungry!!

This is what I think of as a true tavern. Excellent food - we actually went back the next day.

We had a wonderful lunch of Philly cheese steak and chili. Both were delicious. The service was the best we have had in a long time. The atmosphere was perfect on a cold winter day

Such a cool bar. Huge wrap around bar with a lot of antique touches. Didn't have any of the food, but the drinks were amazing. They had a really good cider beer on tap.

Cool bartender...liked good music. Great history at this place. Exterior remodel took me by surprise but remains virtually the same on the inside. Chili was really good. The Turkey MJ sandwich was really good. Drinks were tasty.

One of the last original establishments in Fish Creek. A nice bar and grill with great food and loud friendly atmosphere. The grilled cheese was great. So was the chicken bacon and Swiss sandwich. RC cola was also tasty. Bring the family or stop in for a beer and watch the game. Try them out.

The pickles are very high quality. I love how well they listen when I order extra pickles. The service is great, but the other customers kept slamming dice on the bar top and it was annoying.

Busy, busy Friday night at Bayside Tavern. There were lines. Since there were only two of us, we found a seat almost right away. Our waitress was relatively new to her position, but considering the crowd we felt we received good service. Delicious beer battered walleye served with tasty baked beans and coleslaw. Highly recommend it.

Bill is an awesome bartender! Eaten here 4 times and food was prompt and service always courteous. Perfect if you are craving pizza, burgers, brats even a fish sandwich. Chili also kicked! Plus they have B&B for dessert!

Carly makes the best Bloody Mary's EVERRRRRRR! Perfectly paired with a brunch of fried cauliflower and a mushroom burger. Carly is the best, but no matter who you get at the Bayside, they will not disappoint 😁

Best Cincinnati style chili! Got mine loaded, with sour cream, onions, and stuff. So good. The staff was fantastic as well. Highly recommend!

Mature Bar is amazing. Pub food is well above average. Lovely staff. Open ALL YEAR. Great WiFi for Door County.

A family run Door County staple that we can always count on! Love the soup of the day and sandwich!🤤😆

#1 spot in Fish Creek. It's not like this gem in Fish Creek needs anymore great reviews and I know by telling everyone I am screwing myself for the next time I am trying to find a seat in the bar.
You'll love it. Cheers 🥂🍻

Had a fabulous Reubens! Nice atmosphere and bartender was pleasant. Good Bloody Mary.

We had a nice relaxing time having dinner with our kids. The kids had mac & cheese woth zero complaints. They both had rootbeer. My husband and I had some spotted cow. He and fish n chips and i had a BLT grilled cheese. Our server was super nice. Looks like a fun place to go with kids and also without! All of our meals came with a pickle

Very friendly and warm atmosphere. A special shout out to our bartender, William, who was very friendly, always had a smile on his face, and make us feel so very welcomed. Thank you, William!

Cool atmosphere, great menu, famous for Bills chili. Very large bar.

The chili is "Kickass". Plenty to eat. Not crowded when we went 1900 (7p.m.) Lot's of parking.