Renna's Pizza

I have been eating Rennas pizza for over 30yrs. Is it exactly the same as it was then? No, but then again what is? Just because it's not exactly the same doesn't make it bad it's still absolutely delicious. More than anything for me it's the Nostalgia of it all. The mall might not be the same but when I sit in Rennas it helps bring back good memories! 🍕

Quick and easy slice just like I remember as a kid. Atmosphere hasn’t changed a bit.

I've been eating this pizza since the '70s. Every bite tastes as good as the first time I had their 🍕! If you like thin crust, this is the best place. Locally owned & operated for years. Hand tossed crust. My other favorite here is the fresh-made orangeade they make. Delicious! If you haven't tried Renna's stop in & give 'em a try!

New owner, very sweet. Clean place, still very good pizza, music. Nice place happy to see people in there again.

Incredible. Nowhere else to get true New York style pizza in the area except for their sister restaurant Mio gelato. Oh and Mangia Allegany.

I go here multiple times a week because I go to school nearby. The people are awesome. Food is great. This is a staple for jcc students and the best food in the price range. The rubix cube pizza too has also been a life saver before class. Awesome

OMG this is the best pizza place in all of Olean, this sliced perfection. Every bite is like tasting a little bit of heaven. Dont miss out by considering this place just get there and eat. Save a few bucks and order yourself a whole pie.

Great pizza, disappointed that they didn't have any anchovies so had mushroom and black olives, still great pizza

Love this pizza! Gotta be fresh and hot pepper flakes and garlic on it. Been enjoying this for 40 years!!!

The best NY style pizza for miles. Everything about this pizza is amazing. Growing up here, if you leave its one of the things on top of wveryones list that they always miss because its just that amazing. And you cant have a slice without a fresh orangeade! You can dine in take out or even have it delivered. If you want amazing pizza this is the pizza for you☺

My fiance and I order here on the regular. If you love new York style pizza, this place is for you! I see people complaining about the price.. just so ya know it would be cheaper to buy a full pie than to buy all your slices separately. 😉

Every time I'm in Olean I stop over by the mall and go to renna's pizzeria. I love the pizza, and for $7 you can get two pepperoni slices and a small Pepsi. That's cheaper than a McDonald's meal nowadays. I highly recommend Renna's for your quick afternoon stop or for your evening dinner. Not only do they have other things to eat besides pizza, The staff is very polite as well..

This is my favorite pizza of all time. I really enjoy the flavor of the sauce and the thinner crust. I now live an hour from Renna’s. Every time I’m back in the area I buy a whole pizza and bring it back home. I only wish there was one in the south towns of Buffalo.

Finally, it seems, the amazing taste of Rennas pizza from my childhood is back. Not sure what happened, but for a while it just wasn't good. But now it's back to being GREAT!!

Pizza Pie was Wonderful delicious and great

All I can say is "YUM"! Our family has been customers at Renna's for as long as I can remember. By far, one of our absolute favorite places to eat.

Best pizza in town, New York, and the country as far as I'm concerned. Same recipe for over 30+ years that has a taste that sets the bar for pizza everywhere.

Been a mall staple for at least 40 years. I make the trip everytime I come home.

Not the same mall experiance as it was in the 80s.... but the pizza is still the best

Best pizza in Olean, ive tried all the spots, this wins.

This is the only pizza place I think of since I moved upstate. They have such delicious pizza and I havent been able to find anything close to as good up here. I miss the pizza here! 🍕