Tobey's Donut Shop

Really good donuts. Great selection. You have to get there early, or some flavors will sell out. We ended up getting donuts twice on our weekend getaway. Everything was great.

Stayed in the Finger Lakes for a girls weekend. We got breakfast from Tobey’s both days we were there. Super friendly staff. Amazing breakfast sandwiches! We got them on Kaiser rolls, and they were so fresh & delicious!! We also got donuts. Oh my lord!!!! They were out of this world delicious!!! I live 4 hours away, and I’d drive back just to get the donuts!! (Sorry no pictures of them, we ate them too quick!)

My dad and I came in on a Saturday morning around 9:30 and these guys were popping- but we got seated and served super fast. The food was delicious, and the coffee and donuts where divine. Every member of staff was efficient, helpful, and kind. 2 coffees, 2 donuts, and 2 omelettes and the total came to under $50 for breakfast for 2 people- so an incredible value especially for the quality of the food. I've lived in the area for years and hadn't stopped in, but now I think I've got a new favorite spot! Best donuts ever.

Staying in Watkins Glen for the weekend was looking for a place for breakfast. It's listed as a donut shop let me tell you I'm so glad we went. They have more than just donuts all be it the donuts are amazing. So if you are looking for donuts and or breakfast you must go. We ended up going both days that we are there. Who doesn't love donuts as an appetizer before breakfast.

We stopped here to grap a breakfast sandwich and donuts before visiting Letchworth Park. It was because of previous reviews that we went here. They didn't disappoint. The service was friendly, our sandwiches were delicious and so were the donuts. There's a beautiful park right across the street, too.

We spent a few days enjoying the outdoors around Watkins Glen, and we didn't want to wake up early or cook for ourselves one morning. We didn't realize Tobey's breakfast service ends at 11AM. We made it Tobey's just before breakfast ended fortunately and left satsified and happy to not wash dishes on vacation. We sampled a few of their donuts and ate a delicious simple breakfast. Their hashbrowns are delightfuly seasoned for good flavor, and french toast was tasty. The donut selection was running low, but since I know supply and demand determines how much they make and they were about to close at 1PM it was understandable.

Camping and hiking at Watkins Glen State Park for the weekend and wanted a great breakfast. Google did not disappoint. We didn't have the donuts, but they looked delicious in the case! We had an omelette and and egg/bacon/toast breakfast. Delicious! We will definitely stop by again when we are in Watkins Glen, hopefully for donuts next time!

Jill is awesome and so personable! We came in and ordered two donuts as well as two omelettes and toast. I had an apple-stuffed donut. My fiance had an apple cider donut. Both were delicious---much better than chain donuts (looking at you, Dunkin'!)

Our omelettes, both with sausage, were served SUPER fast! I ordered sourdough toast with mine and made tasty little sandwiches! I was so close to moaning while eating our breakfast it was almost criminal! 🤣

Price was reasonable. We would love to come back Friday morning before we leave town!

Delicious donuts! Fresh and yummy! If you’re in the Watkins Glen area, I highly recommend you stop by and pick a dozen! The donuts tasted fresh! I also ordered a bacon egg sandwich which was good too but could use more bacon but still tasted good nonetheless. They have a full menu so if you aren’t in a donut mood then you have other food to choose from. Check this place out for sure!!

Awesome Donuts! First time in Watkins Glen and found this cute place around noon and they close at 1. So the selection of donuts was somewhat limited but what we got was very good. The Bizmark - a cinnamon roll iced with vanilla frosting - was pretty special. Awesome fluffy texture! Loved this shop!

Excellent donuts. My group loved their Bismarck cinnamon rolls. But as others have said, they can sell out if you get there too late. We got there around 9 AM on Saturday and they still had plenty left, but we’re mostly sold out when we arrived closer to 11 on another day.

Their donuts are super fresh, not too sweet and just plain delicious. They also have great eggs, toast, and hot breakfast.
The service was also great! Everyone is friendly and helpful.

Amazing donuts!! Seriously, I don’t know how they get them so fluffy and moist. Good variety of donuts too. And the staff is super friendly. Good coffee! They also serve full breakfast and sell cold drinks to go.

I drove from Silver Lake to Watkins Glen just for these donuts. I am a born and raised Chicagoan, and I will be back for more. You made our vacation in October. These delightful treats will never disappoint you. Keep doing you Bo Bo

This is a great shop with delicious food made just the way I wanted. I tried to take a picture of my meal, but it was too hard to stop eating it. Oh, well! You'll have to settle for a picture of my half eaten meal.
This is a lovely area to visit. I am staying in the Sugar Hill State Forest where there is free camping and great trails for horseback riding. Finger Lakes National Forest is also nearby. Lots of great places for a nomad and traveling storyteller to to enjoy.
I suspect I'll visit all of these places again.

Killer breakfast spot and tasty donuts. Def will be back if ever in the area.

Tobey knows breakfast! Best breakfast so far in upstate NY.

Yum!!!!! So goooooood. Sans everyone was so super friendly. You can get donuts and breakfast sandwiches to go or you can have a full sit down breakfast. Peppermint patty donut was incredible!

Girls wine weekend! We stopped in for breakfast. The donuts are so so delicious!!! So good we stopped in the second morning for breakfast sandwiches. Highly recommend!!

I see some negative reviews on this place but let me tell you. The coffee and the donuts outshine anything or any complaint about this place. I have been coming to this place for years and Hands down - THE BEST DONUTS - in the world. And I say that having lived in NYC and travelled all over. Whether you get a chocolate glazed or a bizmark - these donuts are soft, melt in your mouth, made in house, and simply the best. Makes magical places like Watkins Glen even more special.