Preteroti's Spaghetti House

I've drove past this place many times and debated stopping. Today I was hungry and decided it was time to give it a try. Looking over the menu I opted for Calamari as an appetizer (it was a pretty generous portion and well made too.) I couldn't help but notice the spaghetti and meatballs said homemade and further elaborated that the recipe is a family recipe nearly a century old. The sauce and meatballs both were a knockout. Don't sleep on this place like I had, well worth the stop.

We were in town for my niece's graduation from the University and we went to Preteroti's after the ceremony. The staff were very friendly and the food was amazing. We were a group of 20 and no one had any complaints of their food. The only thing I did not like is that it is 1 1/2 hours from where I live. If I lived in Findlay I would certainly be a regular customer here.

Stopped in today for the first time. And it is such a nice and cozy atmosphere! The server, I believe Amy was really lovely and patient with us, as we were choosing the meal. Finally, we've decided on The Big Fat Tom, and it came in a decent size for the two with a side of salad along with the garlic bread! The lasagna was amazing! Never tried any better before! And then the dessert, tiramisu... Ohmygosh, it's really delicious! It's definitely worth the stop ! Thank you for experience!

The 3 Cheese Tortellini with Shrimp is ridiculous. One of the best meals I have ever had. I might do double shrimp next time as this really takes the Tortellini to the NEXT LEVEL!!!! Calamari was pretty good, but seriously.....the Tortellini/Shrimp combo are what dreams are made of!!!

I can’t say enough about how delicious the food is here. I didn’t include a picture of the tiramisu because it was so good I couldn’t put the fork down. Alfredo & bread made fresh every day, never frozen.

Only thing I would add is sweet tea because I hate stirring sugar for 5 minutes until it dissolves.

Brought a family group of 9 here for dinner on Tuesday. We had free meals for the kids and a couple of adults shared a meal... got out of there for $50 before tip!!! Wow!! Reasonably priced entrees with generous portions, creative recipes. Served by Micah, the owner's mom. She was gracious even when a kid spilled water 2 minutes into our visit. You'll see from the pics that chicken tenders are actually real chicken, breaded and sliced. Lasagna has prosciutto, pepperoni, ham, sausage, so much meat!! Salads are tasty and chock full of fresh greens, not just iceberg lettuce. The calamari was also fabulous, served with marinara sauce. Try them!! You won't be disappointed!!!

Second time visiting so had to update my first review with pictures. Absolutely delicious. Food is even better than our first visit. Staff are lovely and kind. Definitely worth the wait and money. Authentic Italian food. We got calamari, pizza bites, chicken Parmesan, saccottini, and tiramisu for dessert. Definitely will go again. 100% recommend this place.

We were in Findlay for the eclipse. I had the soccotoni. The food was great! I loved the red sauce. Micah was our server and she was so nice. Great food clean restaurant. We will be back!!

My children and I had a great dining experience here, the staff was very courteous and nice. My children ordered the their famous spaghettini meatballs and also their white sauce in linguine. The portions are huge and we also really love their garlic bread. Freshly baked with their special sauce it will melt in your mouth. It’s just that delicious I will definitely will be visiting here again.

This was my first time at the restaurant, and was dithering between spaghetti and meatballs or lasagna.

I wound up with lasagna and could not be happier with my choice.

It is easily in the top three or four lasagnas that I've ever had. It had a wonderful, thick layer of ricotta and plenty of meat sauce spread throughout the multiple layers of pasta. It was fantastic and Preteroti's has become a permanent part of my restaurant rotation when in town

The food was DELICIOUS!❤ omg.. the fried ravioli is to die for! I love the service.. so friendly! My hubby had the big bambino.. and I had the lasagna.. definately worth going. Huge servings.. great bread also!

Food is delicious and service was super fast and friendly!! The Spicey Sicilian was very good and not too spicey. The Lasagna was fantastic!! Fried Raviolis were good with the marinara. Servings are generous!

Great food has love as a main ingredient. And you can tell a whole lotta love has went into this delicious food! Huge servings for the price, delicious garlic toast, handmade thick and spiced sauce, perfectly browned lasagna noodles. Superb dining and wonderful, friendly and attentive waitstaff.

Sadly, since Brookside Pharmacy, this property has seen a few businesses come and go. But I think the right business has finally moved in and is here to stay.

My family has known the Preteroti family since the 1940s. These are good, honest and hardworking people that will fill your belly without emptying your wallet.

Highly recommended!!

Great service and amazing food. We're greeted immediately upon walking in. Multiple orders of awesome garlic bread to snack on.
Lasagna, Alfredo, and ravioli were all top notch. Per my five year old..."better than any place we've ever been"
We'll be back!

I love supporting local restaurants, and this is one of my go-tos. Tony and his staff are friendly and helpful. He uses family recipes, makes everything from scratch - including the pasta itself, and uses quality ingredients. Glad to see the menu expanding to include more fun things. As someone from an Italian family, I love this place. Most notably: the tiramisu is the best I’ve had this side of the Atlantic.

This place is amazing. Friendly staff Great food and it came out pretty quick. If you in the findlay area or coming to the area you need to check this place out. Authentic Italian food! Check this place out!! The cheesecake melts in your mouth. Best cheesecake I've ever had! We will definitely be coming back, goodbye Olive Garden.

We had a group of 11 for a get together last evening. First time there for most of them. All were very pleased! Service was awesome, food superb! Definitely be returning, thanks for a great experience!

New favorite Italian restaurant!! I’m new to the area and I am so glad I tried their food!! I ordered the Big Bambino and I’m leaving full and with leftovers for tomorrow! I recommend this to any pasta lover.

Best food and restaurant! I’ve been going since they have opened and the owners have seen my family grow! They make us feel like family when we come in. Always recommended!

Amazing food that keeps me coming back amazing service that feels very home like and the atmosphere is very cozy and welcoming