Joey Fratello's Pizzeria

Delicious option for lunch or dinner on the road. I called to order when we were ab 25min away and when I arrived everything was ready, warm and tasting amazing. I loved that you can customize your calzone. Friendly and helpful staff as well.

Joey’s was a nice, local surprise for my wife and I! The pizza was really good and the server Dustin was friendly and welcoming. They put so many toppings on their pizza too! Definitely a place to check out if you’re visiting Findlay and a refreshing change from the chains.

One of the best pizza places hands down! Fresh ingredients, and sauce is delicious. If in Findlay it is worth a try.

probably the best and or my favorite pizza i’ve ever had.
i just get the pepperoni and it’s 100% legit

Finally found the greatest pizza in Findlay!! Classic supreme is amazing!! The staff is very friendly every time, and sure didn't lie about there homemade pizzas!!

Joey Fratello's lived up to other reviews. Went for the first time, not the last. The calzone was excellent. Had Ricotta and the top crust was a bit crunchy with sauce on the side. Staff was nice and accommodating. Highly recommended.

Ordered pizza at 5:44pm tonight and 7:48pm it arrived and I was kinda upset at first but when I sat down to eat it was hot like it just came out of the oven. This is the best pizza in town and worth the wait.

Often it's the hole in the wall restaurants that make the best pizza and Joey Fratello's Pizzeria is no exception. From a preliminary glance, this place is kind of dump. It's crowded, pizza boxes and ingredients stacked everywhere, tables stuffed into every available open space and that sweet, familiar feeling that everything you touch has just a hint of grease on it.

Not sure this place would pass an FDA inspection but, at the same time, I hope they never come calling because the food is absolutely phenomenal.

I ordered your basic cheese/pepperoni pizza and while it took a while for it to be made, when it came I was overjoyed at what I was putting into my mouth. Seriously, some of the best pizza I've had in awhile.

On another note, the staff was incredibly nice and enjoyable. While our order was messed up (one of our pizzas wasn't delivered with the rest of the meal), no one could really be upset because our waiter was so nice.

In terms of prices, they're pretty competitive. Sure, you'll pay less ordering from Dominos, but for the quality of the food you're getting, this is far superior. Plus the portions are generous. I had four slices and left satisfied.

The ONLY downside was that drink refills aren't free. It's okay because I typically get water anyway, but anyone who wants a soda will have to pay for it by the can.

Overall, I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who's looking for a good pie in downtown Findlay.

Very cozy place. Really enjoyed the pizza. Garlic bread was amazing!! Staff was super friendly . Definitely worth the drive to try this pizza.

Literally one of the best pizza I have ever eaten.

After trying many pizza spots. This is by far my favorite, pizza is great, subs are delicious, and the salads are wonderful.

Ate here for the 1st time, and believe me when I say it's now my favorite pizza ever! I had the Tuscan chicken and it's amazing! What a great place!

One of the best pizza shops in Findlay Ohio! Always a great time.

Hands down the best pizza in the Findlay area…They know how to make the perfect crust with freshest sauce and toppings. It is no wonder that are always busy. With the plethora of pizza places in town, Joeys stands tall on its product and excels at serving the customers.

We heard about this place, we are really glad we tried it. Excellent Pizza. Great price, great service.
Would highly recommend!

Best pizza in Findlay! The crust was amazing and the flavors were excellent!

Great pizza! Look forward to it every time I'm in the area.

It was my wife and I's first time there. They were pretty busy, but the service was excellent and so was the food. We got mozzarella sticks and a large pizza. My wife got bacon and pineapple on her half and I went with pepperoni on my half. We were both happy. The prices are good. If you haven't tried yet, why not give it a try. It's definitely worth it on my opinion

Ohio is not a state with good pizza especially compared to Chicago.. this pizza is pretty good. Sauce is ok, cheese petty decent. If you want a good pizza and are in Findlay stop here. You be pretty satisfied. Parking sucks.

Amazing food, friendly services, portion sizes are great for price. Extremely delicious!