Plaster Shak

It’s unfortunate that they have been forced to downsize, but they still have some of the best around the Indianapolis area. I’m sure I’ll be going back time and again.

I have been going to this place for cement flower planters and statuary for decades! A couple of years ago I was on the search for something specific and had scoured the central parts of Indiana to no avail. Went back to Plaster Shack to see if anything new was in by chance, Don and Wendy said, "We have a catalog you can look at...."
We ordered, picked up, (they had then when promised) and and have been back to replace other items this year! We always enjoy our visits.

Very nice people. On the day we visited we found that they were closed. But a nice man came over to ask what we were looking for. He went ahead and opened up to sell us what we were looking to purchase. He told us that the I69 expansion was uprooting their business! I am hoping they will reopen after closing. Can't find a better place to find inexpensive plaster sculptures. Very cute assortment of figures. Highly recommend visiting.

Friendly and a huge selection. Looking for a concrete birdbath and something for the animal cemetery and found exactly what we wanted.

Around Christmas we went back to get some plaster molds to paint and decorate. They have a huge selection of very interesting molds. We left with about 10 pieces to work with over the winter months. Again, very friendly service and reasonable pricing.

Such amazing people, amazing place, and great things to paint. I've went here for 15 plus years. You can't go wrong with anything they have. Wonderful prices to!

I have been shopping at Plaster Shak for over 20 years. Wonderful place to shop, best customer service and always a very pleasant shopping experience. I highly recommend for any age! Thank you to all of the family for being so amazing and helpful!

Stopped to inquire about concrete fountains...bad memory, but Dad and Daughter were both equally friendly, helpful and very knowledgeable.
What a great place with great folks!
2 thumbs up! :)

Sad day drive by plaster shack and it was all gone I have a few pieces from here and would have added a lot more I will miss going there every few weeks to walk around and see what was brought in new I always took somthing home lol the owners were awesome people to meet and talk to will hope in the future they will come back but until then thank you for all the wonderful pieces I have thank you for your time to read this

I went to their booth at treasures looking for a certain statue for a funeral. They didn't have it so I called them and they had one left in stock. He went and got it and pulled it out for me. They made my day, for such somber occasion at least I had the perfect gift.

The owners are always so friendly and happy to answer questions. You can find a little bit of everything at this store (especially kitsch décor). I highly recommend a visit to every crafter.

This is an amazing place. the people are awesome, the prices are great couldn't ask for a better place to shop.

Excellent variety of plaster figurines and outdoor statues/fountains. Been there for decades. State is making him move due to the highway expansion. Please offer him support.

Ran by a really great family selling plaster crafts and concrete yard decor. Lots of unique plaster options that you can't find anywhere else.

This place is a real treasure. They have tons of plaster and cement items as well as art supplies at very reasonable prices.

Great place to find plaster statues, plaques, and other items for you to paint. Bad thing is they are being forced closed on 9-30.

Excellent selection and pricing. Super nice lady running shop.

Great customer service and the prices are reasonable. Will be back for sure.

Very friendly people, helpful when I needed assistance and super great prices!!!

I love this place. Want a great place for painting hobbies this is the place.

Lots of things to paint, plaster and concrete. This place makes painting and decorating affordable.