Goodfella's Pizza Pub

Been here a few times now. 1st time we stopped with the UTV and it was amazing. This place is 2 hours from our house so any time we are within 45 minutes of it we stop and get food either to dine in or carry out. We always get the pizza with the crust on the top.

Went on a Saturday midday. It wasn't too busy but got busy by the time I left. I ordered all the appatizers. They are very reasonably priced and were all good. I had the owners daughter as my server at the bar. She was very friendly and told me about the restaurant. I definitely will come back to try the pizza as it looked fantastic.

Our first time here and food is amazing. We had pizzas, bread sticks, and a calzone. And we have nothing bad to say about any of them. It was definitely the best food we have had. Charlie i believe is the name i kept hearing while i was waiting was very nice and polite. She was great with everyone that walked in and seemed to remember her regulars by name which is always good. Definitely recommend.

One of my very favorite restaurants! We usually get the pizza, but I recently tried the lasagna and it was delicious!! Also love the cheese garlic bread. And the owners are great people!! Highly recommend.

The best pizza, great service and the best prices. Quite a variety, something for everyone.

HUGE HUGE HUGE SHOUT OUT to the crew at Goodfella's Pizza!!! You all were amazing, food was absolutely amazing, and we had the best time with you all!!! Also a huge shout out to the kitchen staff!!! You guys did a hell of a job tonight!!!! You guys are the dream team!

The food is really good. The employees are friendly and they make good drink/food suggestions. It has a good atmosphere overall and is a good place to sit to talk and eat.

We celebrated a birthday there. Owners were very helpful and polite. Allowed us to bring in cake and gifts. Their pizza is awesome. Fresh and homemade. I strongly agree to give them a try.

Great pizza and reasonable price. Good people that run the place.

It was our first time there. It's pretty small on the inside but there is seating downstairs too (I think). We got there a bit before 5 on a weekday. We were greeted quickly and given menus. We tried the cheesy garlic bread that was served with marinara. It was a great first impression. All four of us loved it. Three of us ordered calzones and one ordered a pizza. We were all happy with our food. The crust was really good. My husband never eats his crusts from pizza but he ate this. I liked that they had two sizes of calzone. I took half mine home.

The service was friendly and efficient. Rachel has a great sense of humor and was quick to check on us and get refills. The staff helped each other too. It's a come as you are kinda place and I appreciated that. They also had carry out available and quite a few people came in for carry out while we were there.

I'd definitely ask about the specials before ordering. We learned that the special was mac n cheese after ordering but truth be told, it doesn't really matter. We'll be back soon!

Loved their Rueben Pizza it was amazing!! Bartender was so friendly and their spicy Italian pizza was awesome also!! They have great beer selection too!! We came from Kenosha and I would drive the 3 hours again just for the Reuben Pizza!!!

Shame on us for not having stopped here sooner. This pizza is outstanding. Excellent thin crust pizza with great taste. The calzones were top shelf as well. Everyone was very friendly and the service was great. We will be back again and again.

We have been searching for a great old school pizza joint and have found one in Goodfellas Pizza. The food is homemade and fabulous. Besides pizza, Goodfellas has excellent calzones, pasta and salads.

OMG! I cannot even explain how awesome this place is! I am from SW WI and here to visit my daughter. I'm originally from Chicago and oh, how I miss good Italian food! I have found the Italian Heaven I've been longing for. Simply amazing food! Fat Boy sandwich was SO good! Kids had great meals as well. Friendly, smiling & wonderful service. God Bless Goodfellas!!!!

Always good food and something for everyone! Their pizza is very yummy and the salads are awesome with homemade croutons. Service is always good too.

Best pizza in the town, the owner came out and delivered it to us way out of the way. We appreciate everything that you guys do!

Best place for Italian cuisine. Pizza is outstanding. Waitress's phenomenal. Very personable. We made it our place to go and enjoy every Friday for dinner. Try it. You will not want to go anywhere else. 👍

Bought a large Sausage,Mushroom and onion pizza. Toppings were just right. Sauce wasn't heavy and a great crust. Totally worth the 30min wait. It also was delivered curbside. Lots of people were in and out getting food tonight. A definite must if you are in the area. Great job!!!

Very friendly, great service and excellent pizza. The best pizza we have had since we moved to central Wisconsin. We will definitely be back.

The pizza was yummy. The poor lady taking phone orders could hardly keep up, dinning room & bar was packed, & kitchen was short staffed but they did an amazing job. Very good pizza