Bartolettis Restaurant

This is one of my most favorite places to come on Earth. Chicken night is everything. The BEST you will ever have in your life. I ham not overexaggerating either. Come here once every year because that's the only time that I can. Will always come back and bring new people with. I wish I could always come here and am jealous of anybody that gets to.

I had a 6 oz tenderloin that was on special for $11.95. It was one of the best steaks I have had in a long time! It was delicious! It came with a salad, which I had their homemade Italian dressing. The dressing was very good. And I choose their steamed vegetables instead of a potato. They were very good also. The meal came with a little loaf of homemade bread, which looked delicious, but I do not eat bread or carbs, but the 2 other people I was with, had some, and said it was delicious! My only regret is that I don't live closer, so I could eat there every week! If you haven't eaten here, I highly recommend it!

Very good food, service and nice atmosphere. Truly enjoy a great dinner at a very reasonable price again!!!

Delicious 8oz tenderloin and fresh bread! Lots of food for the price. Nice atmosphere for our anniversary dinner.

Wisconsin supper club experience! The ambiance is old supper club charm, with a separated bar and dining room. It gets busy on weekends, so plan to have a drink or two at the bar while you wait.
The quantity of food is well worth the price, most dinners include a salad which is nice. The Friday Fish is delicious. My grandmother opts for the pasta which she says is excellent.
The staff gets busy, but they work hard and try their best to provide good service.

We were told about their Monday special. WOW we will definitely be going back. Everything was delicious!!!! We took a look at their regular menu, we're planning on going back for the Saturday prime rib special. The prices are just right for a family to be able to go out for a delicious dinner. DEFINITELY going back soon.

Where can you go for $5 on a Monday night and eat all the chicken and spaghetti you want? Nowhere other than Bartolettis. Delicious chicken great atmosphere. Friendly helpful staff. I will definitely return again and again.

It has been great. Good service and food is amazing.

We usually eat there once a week or so. We never had a bad meal yet. I recommend Bartoletti's to so many people! 🤩

All I can say is AMAZING. My wife and I visited the area for the fair and decided to take my cousin out for a steak dinner and decided to go to Bartolettis very last minute ( 20 minutes before they closed for the night) not only was the staff extremely nice even though I'm sure they had a hard day before us being the fair time but they went out of their way to make sure we knew we weren't imposing at all even though we had to stay a little later than what their time off was they didn't rush our meal at all and we're just so nice to us. Now onto the steak itself... now my wife and I are steak fans so we have been to many different steak places from Green Bay to Milwaukee to Lexington to Los Angeles and if your looking for a great steak this place does it right! My steak came out with amazing flavor almost wanting to slice off smaller bites to make it last longer. All around great experience

Had to come here two nights in a row just to be sure it was as good as I thought the first time! Melt in your mouth steak cooked perfectly. The meat ravioli was excellent and seasoned perfectly. Friendly staff. There was a bit of a wait due to popularity and space but the bar made the wait easy. Highly recommend!

Chicken and speghetti night can not be beaten! My favorite broasted chicken around.

I had surf and turf, lobster and steak done perfect. Steak had great flavor. Girlfriend had salmon and loved it. We go to A LOT of supper clubs and the food ranked up there with some of the best we’ve had. Same to be said for the old fashioned.

Dawn was our server very quick and friendly and quick to refill our drinks too!

All you can eat chicken and spaghetti for $5!!!

Broasted chicken night is always good 👍

I’ve usually had bad luck with the wait staff here, but the girl we had on Saturday night was amazing. So they are getting a 5 star today because of her. The food is always delicious.

Fish fry was great. Their menu has a variety of daily specials. I loved the side of gnocchis. Sit at the bar prior to your meal or wait for a table, but not long.
Waitresses are all nice and the food and service is great. Place was plenty busy and clean and well organized. It has been around for years and I can see they still keep standards up. We will return. Very reasonable prices. Go check it out.

Had a fish platter on a Fri evening and it was wonderful. The cod was SO white and fresh! Large portions and friendly staff

Nice food good price nice service nice view of River. All you can eat chicken and spaghetti on Monday night. They have this great sizzler steak too. Parking is ample but you may have to walk a bit. Pork chops are the best. A great night out cheap. A great value.