Coney Island Inn

My husband and I go to Coney Island Inn for breakfast every week and the food is always really good, service is excellent (we usually sit in Danielle's section, but the whole staff is great!) and the atmosphere is just perfect. The hubs always has the exact same breakfast, but I occasionally switch up what I have. There has not been a single disappointing visit! We have brought friends and family with us as well. You cannot beat the food or the prices at Coney Island Inn!

Waitress was excellent even though it was quite busy. Wife had Open Face Roast Beef. Very good. Flavor anyone could love. Pork Chops OK. No real seasoning to make them "pop." But I rated 5 stars based on the coleslaw. I've traveled all over and I order coleslaw regularly. Best I've ever had. Beats KFC 🍗 or any others. Good portion sizes too. I'll go back just based on the coleslaw alone. Prices are reasonable.

Amazing food and amazing service, my husband and I came for the breakfast date.This was our first time here. He got the chopped steak and I got Country fried steak, both came with home fries 2 eggs and toast. We paid $21.00 for both of our meals.We will definitely be back.

I ordered their cheeseburger, but I got THE BEST cheeseburger ever so 5 stars. The service was a little slow but it was good. The table was dirty when we got there but it was cleaned up quickly.

Nostalgic little diner tucked in historic building. Food was tasty and fresh. Service was fast.

We stopped in on a rainy Friday morning for breakfast. We seated ourselves. The place was pretty crowded, and we sat at a un bussed table.
Liz came by and greeted us and cleaned off the table.
I got something different this morning which was a marinated steak, eggs, toast, and hashbrowns. My wife got bacon, eggs, and toast.
All the food was perfect! The service was quite fast, considering how full the place was.
They even brought extra coffee!
Prices are very reasonable.

The food was great and they give you plenty. It was also delicious.The waitress was attentive and friendly. We will definitely be back.

I have been a customer here for years... The Coney Burgers are absolutely the best, and the entire place is just like stepping back in time... to a time where life was simpler... and better... I just ordered dinner from there... and I know I will once again be enjoying food from a great place.

Got the traditional Coneys with mustard and onions with hand cut FF and it didnt disappoint. Hot fresh food and our server was professional, courteous and attentive.

A mom and pop place for good hot dogs, sauce, and fresh cut fries. Will go again. I want to try the gyro next time.

Stopped in for a quick bite after doing a job on the square, great staff. Food was amazing. Great environment in a historic setting. Will definitely be back when I’m in town !

Same waitress I had couple yrs ago or so. Think her name is Tasha? Not exactly sure . She has been there awhile& has earned everything she gets.

I do love the food! & the fact that it's trapped in time. My Dad loved this place when he was alive. So it's nice to have somewhere to go that was from long ago. I'm a lil mixed about the decor. It's nice that everything is still the same, however they could have at least peeled the old wallpaper off before they painted. Would look a lil better. But the service is great, and it's like a mom & pops restaurant. So if that's what you're looking for, try this out.

Very friendly down home restaurant. It has been many years since I visited this restaurant. Like 43 yrs ago. The waitress was awesome and always concerned about how we were as well as our food. I have no photos to share as my son had a big day in court.

Shared breakfast time woth my grandpa. Good food good service. Job well well done. Thank you!

Best waitresses and great breakfast also a wonderful food spot!

You all took care of me more than you may think! I appreciate you all. I'm always asking people how was their visit and you all should be happy with more kind words than not! In all seriousness! Good job people! You've fed so many and I'm SURE they're grateful for your services! ~God bless you all~!

Great little diner, staff is friendly. Food is quality and cooked right. Stop in and give them a try.

This place was great. The food was really good, very well priced. All the staff were so friendly.

They have the best stuffed pepper soup…love it