Casey's New Buffalo

William was a great waiter, he seved us quickly and gave us hot food. The Hamburgers were juicy and tasted! I definitely would come back!

We really loved our meal! We split the rib sandwich and the blackberry burger. Wow wish I had my own burger. Truffle fries were great, ordered them extra crispy too! Tried a side of fried cod and that was good too but kinda soggy by the time I ate it back at the hotel (takeout). Also tried the Sweet potato tots. If I go again I'm going straight for the blackberry burger and sweet potato tots.

The food was delicious. I had the Mac n cheese and added shrimp. The shrimp were perfect but the Mac was a little bland. My bf had a pot roast sandwich. It was delicious and tender but messy. The structural integrity of the bun didn't hold up to the gravy on the meat. Very relaxed atmosphere. Server could have been more attentive for as slow as they were on a Monday afternoon. But to be fair, I think we may have caught this on a bad day for them? The menu looked interesting and detailed and the food was great just not overly impressed by the experience this time.

This place was awesome 😎 food was so good! We got a lot as you can see! Drinks were on point and there was a band! Good times and vibes

Fantastic cocktails, friendly service. Best crab cakes I’ve ever had! The pot roast stroganoff will live rent free in my dreams. Can’t wait to go back. 🥰

I had a party of about 30 people and when we showed up thw place was packed but they got us seated right away and our service was top notch. The food was great. I would definitely suggest this place to everyone I know and will be going back this spring.

Absolutely perfect dining experience. Food and drinks were perfect. Service was impeccable. Can't wait to go back. We had cheese curds, the rib sandwich, and the jalapeno blackberry cheeseburger. Everything was outstanding.

Fun place close to the water. Ambiance is open and friendly.

Food was great. Perch poboy and fries. Waiter was great too!

Thank you!

Absolutely loved this place. The location is so cozy near the beach area here. Kaitlyn (I think that’s her name I saw it on our bill) was just SO amazing. Super friendly and checked in on us often. She recommended the Mahi Po Boy and it was super tasty. Their Pineapple Slaw is also perfection. I’ll definitely be back since I travel a lot from Chicago to Detroit.

Great spot for grabbing food or watching a game (if at or near the bar). We stopped by for drinks and apps and it is much easier to get food here over other places. The apps where great. We had the calamari, chips & dip, and truffle fries… not foods that are easy to mess up, but I did see lots of options on their menu that was rather impressive for ‘bar food’. Lots of fish options I would try and the salad section looks fresh and delightful! Have been here more than once and would come back again. I haven’t seen the outdoor space but it looks nice in the photos!

Casey's is a great place to sit down with friends and have drinks. Staff are very friendly.. Will stop by this place next time we are in town!
Came back to Casey's this weekend and ordered the Mac and cheese with shrimp and it was awesome! It was so good that we had to stop back on the way out of town to get some mac and cheese to go.
Came back this weekend and had the mac n cheese of course! My husband had the tacos they were outstanding. Sat outside on their back patio. It was so nice!
Had a "dont take me for pome-granted" it was awesome! Julie was our waitress. She was friendly and fast.
Hope to be back soon.

Stopped by on our way home from MI and enjoyed the bloody Mary's and mac and cheese! Kaitlyn was by herself and did a great job holding down the fort! Resturant was fairly crowded and she did a super job making sure everyone was taken care of !

You get comfortable neighborhood vibe at Casey’s New Buffalo. Great menu, really good food with friendly service. Kaitlyn was super helpful and fun. We’ll be back!

A friend of mine and I both had the fish sandwich and both of us liked it. Two other guys had fish tacos and liked those. Cup of coffee was nice and big and, most importantly, hot. Server was very friendly. The sweet potato tots could have been a bit crispier but they were tasty. Prices were maybe slightly high but okay. Would definitely go again.

Suzanne was amazing and the Southwest Salad was as good as any I have ever had. Great conversation at the friendly bar. You never know which interesting people you may meet.

Great service and flavorful food. We ate at the bar where the waitress was helpful figuring out what would suit our group best and she was spot on. We recommend the Mahi-mahi dishes and the Mac with pulled pork. The calamari was tender but a bit spicy. I loved it but it was unexpected. Give this place a try and you should be happy with your meal and experience.

Had drinks at the indoor bar, great service and atmosphere

Had good music, with great song list! The food (Mahi Tacos) was good! My friends drinks were good and well made. The place was packed with two bachelorette parties, and a couple birthday parties. For as busy as it was, the servers were on top of it! Great time.

Has a cool backyard bar & patio area to enjoy live music. Great service, Nice beer selection. We enjoyed the mahi tacos, crab cakes, and fried pickles. My only complaint is the beer needs to be colder.

Fun times great atmosphere, they had a live band that was funny because the young lady did not know the songs she was singing 🙂 but she gave it a good ole Bison try lol. My sons had drinks and hung out at the bar they enjoyed themselves. It was a good experience.

First time at Casey's and loved everything about it. Great food, nice outside venue with live music. The service was very helpful in guiding us through the menu and wonderful drink options. Would go again