Sinatra’s Pizzeria II -Oneida

I called at 3:30 to have a pick up time of 6:15 it was ready.. I called early cuz it was Halloween nite I knew it would be busy.. We ordered a ham and onion calzone and 10 everything wings. The calzone was delicious I loved the garlic topping!! There is an old pizza place that in Oneida had the biggest calzones this place is way bigger (look at photo).. fed two of us could have fed 3 we thru away some. The wings were ok I love a lot of flavor everything wings are my favorite and hard to find good ones in my opinion.. I ordered crispy they were not but still not bad so don’t get me wrong.. we also picked up a piece of carrot cake. The price was less then 40$.. the spot they are doing business in has had a lot of pizza places all not good so if your from Oneida check them out they are across from Red Apple.. I want to see positive growth in Oneida I will promote business with reviews that are worthy!! Thank you Sinatras (love the name btw fan of old blue eyes)

I tried their cauliflower pizza. It was fantastic! Crust was tasty, like a dough one I had chicken bacon ranch ! Yummy! Also got an antipasto that was loaded with meat abd 2 kinds of cheeses, very generous reasonable pricing! The service was great , Lindsay was so nice and willing to answer questions. Oneida is lucky to have t h em and yes I ordered again! Great pizza!
M

I've ordered from Sinatra's more than a few times between both locations.

Their food is consistent in quality and taste and always good, as is their customer service.

The pizza is lighter on the sauce and has a bit of a sweeter taste. I have a few friends who don't care much for the sauce, but that's personal preference of course. I really enjoy it. The sauce is also smooth.

The dough itself is so good.

Calzones are a must. They are ginormous and I easily get three meals out of one.

Their everything sauce on their wings is my new favorite. I also love that you can ask for all flats or all drums. (For a small fee, but that fee is worth it so my husband and I don't fight over the flats 😉)

Overall Sinatra's is a great local business, with great food, great service, and they do a lot to give back to the community.

This place is honestly one of the best pizza/ everything spots in Oneida the gentleman that’s runs it is absolutely by the best businessman iv spoke to out here in this area, highly recommended for anytime of day. Wonderful spot! Check em out!

Don't judge this place by the revolving door of pizzarias that have been in and out of this location. We had the chicken riggies, baked ziti, and garlic bread and they were all amazing. Happy to have a new takeout option in Oneida with great food. Can't wait to have the pizza and wings this weekend!

The owner is a very nice guy. My grandson loves this place. Have not had a bad meal yet

Not only are the owners and staff AMAZING , but their pizza, wings and anything else you get there is hands down THE BEST!! So happy to have you guys in Oneida!!

First time ordering from here, I got a large cheese and 15 wings… not only was it affordable but also very fresh and both PERFECTLY cooked!

Chicken riggies are absolutely awesome,pizzas are very delicious as well.Still trying Sinatra's entire menu. I'm stuck on there Chicken Riggies for now "There so good".

All the food has been awesome ! There chicken riggies and the chicken riggie dip is fantastic 😋 the wings are lg and meaty . The pizzas are very good. The subs have alot of meat and toppings on them . The delivery person is on time and courteous. And the deserts are fantastic . Once they start having pasta dinners, they will be very busy. May they stay in oneida for a long time.. Steve stafford

By far the best pizza and wings I've had in a long time the pizza was nice and crispy not too much sauce or toppings and the wings were nice and crispy just the way I like it and still juicy inside and just the right amount of sauce their kind and curtiuos and the customer service is outstanding I'll recommend this to all my family and friends and everyone who asked

I love how huge the slices are! Got the everything wings tonight! Wow, delicious!!!

Excellent eat in experience, super funny staff, great food

I ordered the Philly with greens and a side of utica greens both were delicious let's keep this pizza shop busy folks definitely worth ur money 💰

Ordered a fish fry. It was very good. The staff is very friendly and attentive.

Very attentive staff that takes pride in the food, a small business that gives back to our community

Best lasagna around and the chicken riggies is top notch!

Everyone at both locations: friendly and helpful. Their food is amazing.

Chicken riggie very good this time a little to hot 🥵
But very good 👍