Pies & Pints - Fayetteville, WV

Excellent fresh pizza and ice cold brews. Huge roasted cloves of garlic made my day! The server was right on time and very nice and the prices were reasonable. A nice place to get a pizza and wings!

Pies and Pints was one of the top recommendations I got when searching for food places around New River, so on my trip here, a friend and I had to check it out!

The Food: A friend and I decided to split a large pizza and some wings. We went with the "Steak and Mushroom Pizza" and the "Char-Grilled Hot Wings". the Steak and Mushroom pizza was absolutely delicious! Big pieces of cut up steak paired with the creamy white sauce and mushrooms made for a perfect pie. The large is really big, so splitting it up between two people left us incredibly full. The slices were cooked perfectly and the crust was nice and firm. The wings were also really good! You can really taste the char grill on the wings, which added that nice smokey flavor. It wasn't spicy, but paired with some blue cheese or ranch really elevated it.

The Service: Service was good! Staff were very friendly and attentive. This place can get really packed fast, so if you go during peak dinner time, you may have to wait a while. They do let you put your name/number down and will call when a table clears. But you can always walk up tot he bar for an open spot for faster service.

The Atmosphere: Very nice place to relax and have some great food/drinks. Definitely a very social atmosphere that is nice to spend time at. There's plenty of tables to sit at, and there's a section for people to wait for their turn. Parking is also a little limited as well.

Overall, a 5/5! The food was amazing, the atmosphere was very chill and relaxing, and the service was great! I'll be back for sure!

I went here with my 8 year old daughter and we shared a 1/2 cheese 1/2 pepperoni pizza… it was a very good pizza, lots of flavor and good crunch! They have a large and delicious beer selection along with a nice happy hour starting at 3… Very clean restaurant and bathroom, quiet and comfortable setting, we had fantastic service… highly recommend eating here if in the Fayetteville area…

No wait, really friendly service, clean restaurant. We ordered the wings for an appetizer and they were delicious. Perfectly cooked. We ordered a large Cuban pizza and holy cow, don’t sleep on this one. Perfect crust, large would easily serve 3-4 people especially if you get apps too, the two of us brought half home. I’m only sorry we won’t be able to try them all. Highly recommend.

What a spectacular find in small town Fayetteville WV. Huge open areas throughout the bar/ restaurant. Many places throughput to socialize! The pizzas are phenomenal and the service is excellent. If you're fortunate enough to get Josh or Sam you will NOT be disappointed. Cushioned playground area in the back with a slide for the kids to play! Definitely put it on your to do list if you're in the area....the one and only downfall is parking can be a bear!!

Busy for a Saturday night but I didn't have to wait because I sat at the bar. The bartender was kind and let me try several beers before I made my choice. The pizza was delicious and arrived quickly for how busy they were. The beer was good too!

One of the best pizzas I've ever eaten anywhere! I had the goat cheese, peppadew, onion and honey pizza. Definitely a highlight of my visit to the New River Gorge.

Great range of pizza options from the novel to the old familiars. Nice range of beers on tap and in bottles/cans, with a relaxed vibe and friendly service. Nice outdoor seating area and a play set for kids too.

Wow wow wow. That was PHENOMENAL. I took a risk and ordered a pizza (with vegan cheese) for the first time in over two years and am so happy I did. I ordered the regular sized margarita pizza which was bussin. Delicious crust, the cheese actually worked (which surprised me because Daiya isn't that good), and everything was great.

It was really busy on a Sunday at 4:30 though so you know that it's great. What a lovely place.

Had a fantastic time with my wife, here on a Saturday evening. We had the Nashville Hot Chicken Pie and it was fantastic. Delicious and spicy. I love pizza with chicken and the pickles was a great touch! A few draft beers and a mixed drink to top it all off. I look forward to going back again!

Pie and pints is a staple in Fayetville. Perfect spot to carb load and enjoy a couple cold brews and hearty pizza after a long day at the new, whether you're climbing, rafting, hiking, or just passing through. We often see other groups that we ran into during the day here for dinner, it's a great gathering spot. The nachos were my favorite dish here. It really gets busy and there's often a long line, especially if you have a big group, so plan accordingly!

This was my first time here but was told I would love it and did! The pizza is "craft" pizza, not your average pie. Their selection and combinations are unique and tasty. The ingredients seemed fresh. If you order a large, you can get it half and half and get more pizza than two smalls, for less the cost. We also had "pizza skins" for a starter, which were very good. While I'm not a drinker, I noticed the choice of beers was expansive and unique.

Great pizza. Great beer selection including a great n/a selection. Friendly service. Fresh and tasty salad for those that want. Nothing to not like.

Hands down amazing place to eat or grab a drink. Great atmosphere and delicious food.

Great little gem! What a find during our trip down South. Clean restaurant, plenty of seating both inside and out. Pizza was perfectly cooked, not soggy in the middle, good crisp. The steak was cooked well, but not overdone. Nice thick pieces. Hannah was a wonderful server with great suggestions. Fast service and quality food. Samantha was a friendly, quick and accommodating bartender. There is a play area outside for the kids. Parking is in the back. The alleyway for parking is to the left of the building.

Tip: now that area has the newest National Park wait times may vary. We arrived around 8:20 pm and were given a 30 min eta for seating. They close at 9 p.m. We were seated within 5 minutes after ordering a drink from the bar. Be prepared to wait or call ahead if they take reservations. Worth the wait and the service is great. They do have an area for games. And, a large stall bathroom for wheelchairs to fit nicely that can be reached without steps.

Great spot for lunch and a drink! Great cocktail menu with a large selection of local beer, and the sandwiches hit the spot! We've also tried the pizza at the Charleston location, which are unique and highly recommended!

Pizza was so good, loved that there were 2 gluten free crust options. Will definitely go back when in the area. The restaurant is not dog friendly, but there are picnic tables nearby to get carry out and eat at.

We frequent the Pies and Pints in Cincinnati, so visiting the original was fun. Their pizzas range from traditional to inventive, but yummy. The crust is always perfect, but deciding what to put on it can be a challenge - there are just so many options!

The best pizza anywhere. It ranks right up there with our NYC favorites. I love that you can get half of anything so you can try multiples or for those times when no one can agree. My personal favorite is grape and Gorgonzola even though I didn’t it get it this go around. We tried more. We always come back when we are in town.

Great selection of craft beer on tap. Delectable artisan pizza! Super server. Cool vibes. Packed house.