Picnic Pizza

For the first time I've had pizza that wasn't too greasy, not undercooked, not scalding hot and had crust of perfect thickness! Probably the best Sicilian pizza I've had as a Western New Yorker.

The staff is friendly and awesome. Too bad I've to drive 2 hours to get to this place, but I'd do it in a heartbeat if the date was worth it!

Ordered by phone,f ood arrived on time and we were met with a smile and a delicious pizza.

Delicious pizza 🥰🤤🤤
The actual prices are different from the website prices. They need to fix that ASAP :/
But the food is amazing.

Best NY style pizza in the area hands down.

Best pizza around in my opinion. Closest to NY style pizza. Crisp crust, tasty sauce and plenty of cheese. Employee 's are always pleasant. Pizza is generally ready before the told pick up time, so I always arrive a few minutes early. I live to far away for delivery, but they are well worth the drive!

Love there pizza and the ham and cheese subs. Friendly staff and great prices

Our food was great. The kids had pizza and drinks. I had a salad. I love their house Italian dressing..yumm. the atmosphere was mellow, the older guy had Sinatra playing. The staff made sure everything was ok. I like stopping in here

Fantastic pizza. The location is ok, it's in a plaza and the seats are hard booths, but who cares, most of us get carry out anyways. Subs are lovely as well!

the pizza is AMAZING. the mood is always great in their they always seem like they are having fun it may get a bit busy but they know how to handle a long line and their subs are very tasty i could go there everyday i would very much recommend it 10/10

We love their food. How ever I wish they would deliver to elcore. Prices are high but well worth it.

It's (I would say) one of the best places to eat pizza or have takeout. I've been having pizza from there throughout most of my life. I haven't found any place in my travels that can even get close to the taste of Picnic Pizza. Keep up the great work guys.

Always fresh and amazing taste!

Great staff and owners. Quick service and food is good quality!

Picnic special is the Italian sub that most dream of being. We come here pretty regularly and the service is fast, friendly and the food always consistently excellent. After so many visits through the years you would think they would falter at some point... One delivery they dorked up a bit and sent the wrong sub and this crew flew into action made the correct one and were back at my door in 20-25 minutes. Now that is what I call a home town pizza place that cares about their people. If you are on the fence . Don't be. Awesome pizza as well as some decent wings.

This pizza reminds me of the good NYC pizza we used to eat when I lived in Queens!! It has the right amount of drippy cheese oil, add some garlic and the crust is just as good. Yum!! I wish Picnic Pizza would open a store on the Southside of Elmira!! We would definitely go there and order delivery from there!!!

Can't go wrong here. Great tasting food.

Horseheads Picnic Pizza is THE best!!!! The barn girls and I are there just about weekly and the smiles we are greeted with are as good as the pizza and subs!!! Connie and staff are always happy to see you! Thanks guys always my favorite place to eat! Lisa

Went today and ordered a pizza. I went out to my car to wait until it was done. Next thing I know the cashier that took my order was bringing my order to my car. Awesome customer service. Oh and the food is amazing😃

Honestly, this pizza is perfect as far as I'm concerned. The subs are also second to none (especially Turkey, all-dressed.). All of this plus a great staff make this place my favourite pizza place in the world. Highly recommended 😃

All we can say is WOW ...what a great burger and sub ...and it was so wonderful to have a super nice girl on the phone to take our order and the delivery driver was equally as wonderful Thank you for making our experience AWESOME ...we will be ordering again and again