Old Mill Cafe

I had a wonderful dining experience at this restaurant! The seafood linguine and crab and artichoke appetizer were delicious, and the food was exceptional. The waitress provided excellent service, and I was pleasantly surprised when the chef personally came to our table, showing a great level of care and hospitality. Highly recommended!

I freely admit that I am a BLT snob. We stopped at the old Mill Café on the recommendation of a friend. I ordered a BLT on rye bread, and it was perfect. The bacon was crisp and not fatty, the bread perfectly grilled, there was plenty of lettuce and tomato, just the right amount of mayo. The avocado could have been a hair more ripe (or maybe I should learn not to order it out of season). The service was friendly & fun. My son loved his Mac n cheese and the turkey burnt ends on top. Great spot!

We stopped here just by chance on the way home from Olympic National Park to the Maple Valley area. The entire family was happy including the kids 😁. I would highly recommend this place. I got the Kobe beef burger and onion rings. I don't say this lightly; it may have been the best burger ever!

This place is awesome! The service was spectacular and the atmosphere was suiting. The best part was the food. OMG goodness of flavor, we highly recommend eating here if your in town. Even if your not and your 30 min to an hour away it’s well worth the drive.

I came here the other day with my husband and we were delighted! The food was incredible. We stopped in for breakfast just because we had never tried this spot for breakfast before. it wasn’t all that busy but we were skeptical when we only saw one cook in the kitchen. We were pleasantly surprised when our food came out within minutes of ordering. The cook did an excellent job she made everything perfectly! i will absolutely be back! My service was amazing as well. She was nice and cheerful. I think her name was savannah but i could be mistaken. Either way this place was lovely and i can’t wait to be back.

The staff, particularly Megan, went above and beyond to make sure I was taken care of with my food allergies. Food was fast and prompt, service was friendly, and the food is really good!

My family and I stopped in at the Old Mill Cafe for brunch and were not disappointed! There is so much history and decor to feast your eyes on! The Dungeness crab Benedict was DELICIOUS!!

We were geocaching in the area I needed to stop for lunch. This place looked exciting from the outside and once we got inside, it was even better. The server was absolutely lovely and provided professional efficient service. We really enjoyed our food and the decor. Absolutely wonderful visit. We definitely would love to come back.

Comfort food at its best! We came here for breakfast on a cold bright Sunday morning. I had the combo plate - perfectly done eggs over easy, crisped home fries, ham, and a biscuit/ gravy. Life just doesn’t get any better! My wife had the French toast with marionberry syrup, equally as good! The staff was great and the atmosphere is very family and friendly. Don’t miss a meal here - it’s a real treat!

Very much enjoyed our brunch here today. We both had Eggs Benedict. They offered a few varieties of this entree. Crab, California style, etc. It was very good. Service was attentive & friendly.

Breakfast was delicious! Spicy pancakes were outstanding! Loved the atmosphere! Awesome cafe!

What a treat to enjoy a diversified delicious menu combined with such a unique and comfortable atmosphere.
This restaurant will go the extra mile to create a great dining experience!

My wife and I had a rough morning getting tires on the car and needed grub something fierce. We stopped in and immediately liked the decor and vibe of the Old Mill. It being our first time, we stuck to ordering a couple of traditional diner dishes. She had the country fried steak and I had the sausage gravy Bennie. Both were stellar. The staff was prompt and friendly without being overbearing. 5 stars and a must stop if you're in the area. On Sunday they close at 1:30, but are open longer on weekdays.

I've been here several times and I'm a regular now. I really enjoy the food here. I definitely recommend it.

Had a great breakfast here. The country fried steak is thin, crisp, and tender! The sausage gravy is flavorsome and packed with sausage.

The servers are great. Thanks, Anna!

Also, it's cute as a bug's ear.

My husband and I are regulars here and we love bringing our friends and family! All of the employees are so wonderful and the food is amazing. If you are a soup lover you have to try Dave’s soups on any given day, they are to die for. Sometimes after a walk we stop in just to try whatever the soup of the day is. Savannah the new owner is so nice and treats us like family as does our favorite server Megan.

Food was good, atmosphere was very good, service was really good. We ate there after a long travel day and then a couple nights later we'd had another long day and decided to go back because "we know what we'll be getting". We enjoyed both meals

Cypress made us Amazing burgers, he is awesome, definitely deserves raise. New management is doing something right.

The fabulous Railroad Reuben had sold out (the cornbeef takes 5 hours to cook, but we couldn't wait another hour) the day we went for Early Bird dinner. We decided to ask for their Old Mill Burger with an addition of sautéed mushrooms. It was absolutely delicious. Had a side of onion tings too.

We were vacationing from Boston and found this hidden gem - I can say with confidence this was one of the best places we ate at during our entire 10 day stay in the state. You can tell the chef, Chris (who came out to greet guests at the end of the evening), takes pride in and is great at his craft. My father, who always orders Reubens, said it was the best he’s ever had. Our server was delightful, attentive, and just an all around great hostess. The atmosphere is friendly, with vestiges of their namesake (an old sawmill) on the walls. If we lived within a 50 mile radius, we would definitely be regulars!