Tony's Pizzeria

Giving them 5 stars because I feel terrible, but these guys are very very expensive. I'm staying at the hotel down the street, I drive truck, and figured I'd order a pizza for myself from a local joint, while im here for my 10hr layover.

Searched Google, and these guys had 4.4 stars, so I tried to go to their website, which just opened the facebook login page on my browser. So I called and a gentleman answered the phone and I asked for a medium meat lovers, I was told they only have large and small, cool make it a large I'm hungry. He tells me what toppings come on it, all sounds great, then I hear alright that'll be 14.40 like 25 30 minutes, I think to myself wow decent deal, cool! I used to manage an oip, we regularly ran deals like that, especially before 3pm, so I didn't think anything of it. So I relax, change, and get back on my phone to read some of these glowing reviews!

Common complaint even in the 4 and 5 star range was "price" and one person mentioned paying "25.00 for a large 2 topping" and I thought to myself, there's no way on earth he said 40.40 did he? So I scramble to call back. Got a polite girl on the phone, and explained the situation, she went and asked and came back to tell me it's already in the oven nothing they can do.... so now I'm scrambling anxious that I can't allow myself to spend 40.00 on a pizza! and wow that's a wild price.

Not sure what to do, but I can't pick it up. Just paid rent and filled my oil tank at home im tapped out, and I'm not putting a 40.00 pizza on my credit card and making it a 43.00 pizza with interest, no offense lol

I'm sure they can slice it out tonight during dinner, but wowzers deffinetly make sure when a customer calls from an out of town number and your right next to hotels, and they order a 40.00 pizza, make sure they heard that price correctly! I mean my local pizza place with a similar Google rating makes me a totally unique deep dish, pan Sicilian sheet pizza with meatball, ricotta, and ziti. It's hard to find any good pizza shop that will make this pizza due to the ziti (it's so good btw) and it's 37.00 and some change... hence the number 40 wouldn't even register as correct in my brain for 1 pizza for 1 person. I was expecting 25 or so maybe pushing 30.

I'm sure the pizza is solid, everyone has great things to say about the food, and I wish I could have tried it. Very sorry guys.

A menu on Google would help as that's what I went for first but I don't know my Facebook login to login on my browser. I believe you can change the Google domain url to open the Facebook "app" instead of your browser inside your dashboard. Anyways I'm very sorry guys, I hope there's no hard feelings.

The pizza is the best in the entire valley they don't skimp on ingredients hot fresh and delicious...the restaurant is super clean this is my go to place for pizza there's no better pizza love it

Some of the best pizza I've had since moving to central NY. The service was pretty good, too, for being younger kids. We will definitely be going back. If you haven't tried them yet, give them a shot!

Stopped here on our way by on I-90. A little pricey when going for multiple toppings, but the pizza was loaded and good! Worth the price in my opinion. Staff was friendly, no complaints! Shared the pizza between three of us and still had some leftover.

I grew up with Tony's pizza & still order a pie whenever I'm visiting family in town. It's one of the few things I miss about Herkimer.

The pizza was great, and it's wife approved. She's the picky one. We always get three specific toppings and they put on plenty.

Can't really provide an rating for service because my mom ordered BUT the pizza is good in my opinion. I love pizza so maybe that why. I had the cheese one.

In area 4 traveling work assignment. Looked like a true classic operation. It is! 1st of all its a real pizza oven, not a conveyor system. Real ingredients and really nice people. Simply top notch. Bravo Tony's! Ciao 4 now but definitely C U soon!

Got take out pizza for maybe the 5th or 6th time... I don't write many reviews, but this is the first 2nd review I've written. It's good. The pizza is consistent, delicious & worth it! I also own a food business, and I always hear "we don't care what it costs, as long as it's worth it". Tony's has been worth it every time. Well done.

This was the first time my fiancee has had Tony's in Herkimer and he was so amazed, he couldn't stop eating it! We ordered a double cheese half pepperoni and the portions of cheese was just right, pepperoni was crispy. All around happy with this order! Thank you!

One of the best buffalo chicken salads, delicious pizza, playful and respectful staff, and community pictures on the walls. A favorite of ours!!!

Asked for the pepperoni on the well side, it was perfect and delicious!! 🍕

We just happened to be passing through on vacation and stopped for lunch. So glad we did. This place had awesome food and a cool pizza shop vibe.

Friendly service and Plenty of food for the money!
I ordered a Eggplant Parmesan sub today…this sub was loaded with cheese and eggplant..:Delicious & VERY FILLING!! and the price, as always,was good!
A few weeks ago I ordered a Upside down Pizza…let me tell you…It was loaded! Absolutely great food and affordable every tyme!!
I STRONGLY RECOMMEND THIS PLACE!

I cover 14 counties in Upstate NY and this is my must stop pizza place! The buffalo chicken pizza is the best I have ever had.

Hot damn, it's a little pricey but honestly 200% worth it. There's actually toppings on the pizza! It's not just some little sprinkles of bacon, pepperoni, sausage, etc. It's actually worth what you pay! Great service and better food, definitely gotta go.

This pizza is large and in charge! Loaded with toppings and crust with the cheese baked into it. It’s amazing. Also the chicken tenders are hands down the best in the area.

Absolutely mind blown! Owners are so friendly and personable! Never been a pizza fan but omg this place was phenomenal! We had the Buffalo chicken pizza and the sausage pizza! Had to grab more to take home! A must do stop on life's adventure!

First time I was ever in Herkimer decided to grab a slice from this place and honestly it was amazing, customer service was great and I liked that they use real blue cheese. I highly recommend this place so anyone looking for a good cheese slice

Excellent. This place makes an awesome pie. They use such high-quality ingredients that they don’t have to hide behind heaps of sugar and salt. These people know what they’re doing.