Pudder's

First time visit. Ordered the build-your-own burger, which was quite good. Good fries as well. Nice staff. Definitely would return. Located in a 160-year-old historic building which adds to the atmosphere. Recommended.

Super fun place. Bar tender was so fun and interactive. Food was amazing. Try the MFGS burger. It's fun and interesting.

Phenomenal time! Extremely friendly people and delicious food. The owner, Brain, was a great guy to talk to!

They were very accommodating. Two of my family members wanted shirts, and they were willing to ship them to our address.

Great food, great service, great atmosphere, Great place to relax and enjoy yourself. Oddly, I saw no place on the review options to rate their pizza. We always get the philly cheese steak pizza... In my opinion, it's amazing! I recommend getting the largest pizza they offer and taking the leftovers home. It tastes as good reheated in the oven as it did when we ordered it! The bacon jam is also excellent. Their fried pickles are great although i've never had a bad fried pickle! Very friendly and inviting atmosphere.

Really tasty Tater Kegs! 😋
The Food was great and we had good service. Was a bit more noise than I would have liked, but okay for a Sunday. Definitely a place to go back soon!

Had a great lunch at Pudder’s today. I’ve been to this restaurant several times and never been disappointed. The food portions are always generous and delicious. Today in fact I ordered 15 boneless wings and ended up receiving 22 (guess they were feeling generous). If you are in the mood for wings or boneless wings, try the homemade sweet and spicy bbq sauce. Do know that this place can get extremely busy and I have heard of 45-60 minute waits to get in before. Your best chance of getting in and out quick is to visit in off hours of the day instead of right at lunch or dinner.

Wow! We stopped after picking up a purchase in green castle. The food was such a high quality. We had bacon jam pizza, wings and loaded tots. And blue moon draft. Yum yum and more yum. Hope to be back.

Pudder's has a casual, family friendly vibe. We experienced great customer service and the food was wonderful! The fried cauliflower was outstanding!

First time there. Owner recommended the pizza and wings. They did not disappoint! Best pizza I have ever had, which says a lot! And wings were awesome also! Will definitely be back.

DELICIOUS!!! we stopped here on our way to Edinburgh and had some of the best food. Don’t skip the Tater Kegs or fried pickles- so good. Bacon Jam burger and buffalo chicken grilled cheese were mouth watering. We will definitely make our way back here!

Our party flew in late Wednesday night and asked our host where a good place to eat was and he casually mentioned Pudders. They did not disappoint our whole group from Utah. Service was friendly and the food was AWESOME!! We had the tater kegs, loaded chips, Buffalo grilled cheese, Orem Burger, Blue burger and the fried cheesecake. Went back two more times it was seriously that good! On our last visit most of us ordered the MFGS and we were not disappointed! Thanks Bryan and crew for making our visit extra special!

Went to puffers after a competition in the area and was met with great service and a lovely environment. Genie made an amazing margarita and was full of great conversation! Even got the chance to meet the owner and learn more about the business! Would definitely recommend to anyone in town!

Excellent restaurant off the square in Shelbyville. I had a meeting in the area and got there a bit early. To kill some time I walked around this adorable little town square. Although there is construction improving the square all of the businesses and the road is open. Service and food were amazing and the decor is great. If I'm in the area again I'll definitely stop in. Heck, I might even drive down again, stop for a bite to eat, and do some more looking around. Terrific find!

We ended up at Pudder's for the eclipse. Good choice! Food was great - Bleu Burger and a Philly Wrap. And wonderful onion rings. No pix - cameras were busy elsewhere. Staff was very accommodating. Definitely stopping in again next time we're in Shelbyville.

my husband and i went in to eat for lunch this afternoon and these girls were running around with how busy they were. our server, kacey was working bar and dining room but she was joking with us and kept a smile on her face! best service and the food was great, those pickle chips are the best

We love Pudders! We come here almost weekly! The service is ALWAYS top notch and the food is wonderful! We have never have had a poor experience! Pudders is always our go-to dining spot in town!

Stumbled upon this place. Almost everything is home made. The prices are reasonable. The building is older and classic and very clean. Very good food. Hidden gem in Shelbyville.

Came here with the family and discovered a place with great prices and menu options. Everything we tried was delicious and there is something on the menu for everyone!

This place was really good and a great atmosphere. I had the pizza and it was delicious. The prices are good too.

Great place, great service and delicious pizza! I was actually surprised how low the prices were!

The pizza was as good as it looked online and I'm a bit saddened this place is over 100 miles away from me but maybe I'll pass by just to eat here again.