Mickey's N.Y. Pizza

AMAZING! Best meatball sub and chicken parm sub I have EVER had! Also tried the BBQ chicken pizza and it was amazing as well. They are super busy but no surprise there since the food is AMAZING! Even with the amount of customers they handled it well and were realistic about wait times. I ordered pickup and the wait was about an hour. Which is fine and totally worth the wait, I just made sure the next time I planned ahead and ordered appropriately time wise. They have a ton of staff in the back working diligently and I'm sure it isn't always easy but the few times I have gone since discovering this place they have been super friendly, pleasant and attentive. I will probably be eating here way more than I should for the time being because I can't wait to try more of the menu!

I Can't be more happy that I found somewhere in new Hampshire that actually makes Pizza , what most places call pizza is a joke , great crust great sauce great cheese and the right ratios, also cooked properly which is another area most pizza places suffer greatly. This place deserves the N.Y. pizza name . And they also deserve more credit to keep them going! Hopefully they can soon be recognized as NH's best!

The BBQ wings were so good, I will be ordering them again ( want to try all the flavors now ). The ham and cheese sub was really full of the perfect sandwich favor combo, just a little too much mustard. My husband loved the buffalo chicken pizza, he wished it had blue cheese crumbles on it lol .And the red velvet cake is super fluffy and light.

My wife and I have been going for years. Always great service and food. We are realling enjoying thier new chopped Italian sub.

Always great food, great service, staff is always very friendly. Love how they always come out with new specials to try. Tried the chopped Italian sub and it was delicious.

Delicious! We enjoyed a margherita pizza, Buffalo wings and fries. The service was welcoming and friendly. Went on Sunday night and place was busy. We will be back!

I saw a video on Instagram about the chopped Italian sub. I looked up where they were and saw it was less than 2 hours I figured why not!
I was beyond happy I made the trip. The chopped sub was delicious. We also ordered a Sicilian style pizza. The girl at the counter was super friendly, welcoming and helpful in what we ordered. She also checked in to see how the pizza was and wished us a safe trip back. I truly don’t think I have Visited an establishment and felt that welcome in a very long time especially in today’s world, this place is definitely worth another trip, for not just the food, but the friendly atmosphere as well.

AMAZING NY style pizza!! Omg so delicious! It is hard to find pizza this good, especially in NH. I live in MA an hour away and would come to get this pizza. Salad was super fresh and great portion. Friendly staff. Classic pizzeria vibe to sit inside with a few small tables. Pepsi products for drinks. Take out order was ready quickly.

This is my go to spot! The food is AMAZING! Pricing is fair and Tammy is the absolute best. She gets things done! She is always so bubbly and a joy to be around. I cannot say enough about this place <3

It was so hard for me to eat this Nashville hot chicken sandwich. As soon as I laid eyes on it, I began to develope feelings for it. Intimate feelings. (Hope my wife doesn’t see this.) I had to remind myself that I’m a family man and I can’t put that on the line for a sandwich that I barely know.
As I took that first bite, I felt a bittersweet satisfaction rush through me. Like an arctic chill, but a little spicier. It was love at first bite. I still love my wife tho.

Tried out Mickey's N.Y. Pizza in Derry. Large pepperoni (18 inch) well done and bourbon BBQ wings. The pizza was cooked perfectly, crust was nice and crisp, sauce was abundant and flavorful, pepperonis were huge and flavorful too. The pizza had a ton of flavor and I wouldn’t change anything about it. This is some of my favorite pizza I’ve had in New Hampshire. The wings were damn near perfect and the sauce was excellent. Definitely some of the best pizza in New Hampshire easily, go check them out. I’ll definitely be ordering from here more often.

Its 8:38 pm the night before Easter 🐣. I spent the first part of the day cooking at work ,then got my prep done for Easter after that! Was kinda spent, I don't like to order out but it was late so I got mickey's. I've had your vodka roni a few times, and as always it was great! Ty you so much for making my night a little easier. Happy Easter
-kyle

I love the pizza here and the subs!! My favorite is the chicken Philly sub and spicy fries. I love the employees there as well. They definitely go above par expectation wise and are very friendly ! There’s a reason this place is always busy!!

Unreal! We saw the chopped sub on instagram and immediately knew we had to try it. Did NOT disappoint. The girl at the counter was so friendly and service was quick! Worth the hour drive and will definitely do it again. 10/10!

Amazing food, great service, and kid friendly atmosphere! 10/10 recommend.

Amazing food! I catered my Christmas party from here and it was so easy to work with the restaurant. The food was delicious and amazing. We got the meatballs and pasta and the meatballs were so tender and flavorful. We also got Greek salad and the house dressing was delicious. The vodka sauce pepperoni Sicilian pizza and the margarita Sicilian pizza were amazing. And the wings were so juicy and tender and meaty and flavorful. Will definitely be eating here again. Loved everything about it!

My son and I have been on a quest for the best pizza, and this place is amazing. As of Feb 2024 they had a 4.1 rating and that initially led me to overlook the place. That 4.1 rating is a crime. This pizza is so so good! And the staff was very friendly. We will definitely be back!

Went in tonight for dinner. Ordered the large steak bomb calzone and kid's chicken tender dinner. By far best we've ever had. The calzone was loaded and dough so delicious. The chicken tenders are made with fresh chicken and not the frozen ones other restaurants serve. The customer service was top notch as well. We'll definitely be back. Kudos to your staff and the quality of your food.

I am a regular here and I ordered 20 pizzas for noon on a Sunday (the busiest possible time) with just a few days notice. They had all the pizzas ready and hot and everything was perfect. Thank you

The menu here is incredible... So many options! The sandwiches were delicious and I'm definitely going back for pizza at some point. Canolis were tasty as well!