Little Italy Pizza

I really like Little Italy. I eat here a lot. Fair prices, super quick service. The cheapest delivery around and a pickup window is good too. But more than anything I love their crust. It’s a great cracker like crust that still is thick enough to have substance. Customer service can be a bit spotty sometimes but honestly it’s barely worth mentioning. It’s just good pizza.

This place has been around for years and has always had quality ingredients and great pizzas. They have gluten free options, great subs and have always been my favorite pizza place in town. They have some of the best tasting sauce and delicious, crispy dough. Worth every penny.

Excellent pizza. Small place and service was outstanding! We are from Fairborn Ohio, and this was recommended by another guest that stayed in the cabin prior to us. So glad we tried this pizza place!

No better pizza in The Plains. Pizza is always high quality. Subs are decent. Usually a half hour for pickup. Better bang for your buck than anywhere else around.

Bomb! They even hit it right on the extra marinara cups! Sub is melting in my mouth as I post lol definitely got there gig together! Nice work guys! Always grab it when I'm grabbing pizza!

My favorite place for pizza. Always delicious and reasonably priced.

Our favorite Friday night place to get pizza.

At times there delivery can be slow, this is made up by the amazing food, not just good pizza all around the border. All in all the food is made with a quality that only a family chain can provide. Leaving the taste buds seasoned and dazzled.

Really GREAT PIZZA! I’ve lived in Athens for more than 50 years. Have tried many Pizza facilities and always return to Little Italy’s to get what I crave. GREAT PIZZA with friendly service.
Specialty - Meat Pizza, is my favorite! Try it out and you’ll not be disappointed.
Thanks,
Dan D.

Love little Italy’s subs. I always get the Italian and my hubby gets the Philly.

We're from Cincinnati and we loved this pizza.. But the subs were the star! Meatball sub was delicious as was the roast beef. I recommend doubling up on toppings for the few extra dollars though. Friendly service .. we were satisfied :)

I've started going to little italy when I was only 6 years old I'd walk over and get a pizza or pop chips whatever and they've never once started hating on me they knew I grew up with two parents who didn't care what I did. I consider these guys as family, i haven't seen them in years but their great people and their service is amazing and so is there food.

I'm always on the lookout for a good sub shop, and pizza places tend to have the best Italian subs. Being in Athens makes this place is a bit out of the way, but now that I've tried it, I feel I've been missing out. It is a pretty decent sub. I like that the bread is nice and toasted, and having the dressing on the side is a nice touch as it keeps it from getting too sloppy and soggy especially when getting takeout (and when isn't it takeout these days).

The food is always hot and fresh, delicious, and made with fresh ingredients. The portion sizes are phenomenal for the price! The staff has always been friendly and customer-oriented. I highly recommend Little Italy Pizza in The Plains, Ohio. I cannot attest to the quality at other Little Italy locations, but if they are anything like The Plains location, they are superb.

I've lived down the street from them for almost five years, and I still haven't managed a review until now. They have the absolute best strombolis that I have ever had in my life. We order them regularly and are never disappointed (bacon and onion is the best). In the past half decade, they have only improved.

Family run local business. Good pizza and I love the Pizza sub sandwich as well. Reliable and convenient.

This is consistently the best pizza we’ve ever had and nothing else comes close. Yes, really. A couple things you learn over time with this place is always order it well done and always get the hand tossed w sweet sauce! I like my cheese carmelized on the top and they always get it perfect. The philly pizza is amazing and a regular ol’ cheese pizza are our faves. This is the only place where I can find a cheese pizza that actually has flavor and isn’t bland as a board. Not to mention that this is great leftover pizza too, I just get a large every time and then I have lunch for a couple days afterwards. There is one caveat to coming here, and that you can usually expect to wait a while if it’s a Friday or Saturday evening (we’ve only ever used carryout and not delivery), but trust me it is worth it. We moved away recently and miss this pizza dearly

So far, all great experiences. I've only ordered here a few times, but I call in an order for a personal pizza with something like 5 toppings and it only costs around 5 bucks. I then hang up and walk to the joint and it is ready (about 20 minutes later).

Some great pizza! Our family usually eat in a couple home games a year and order out quite a bit. Great pie! I recommend eating in so you get it as soon as it comes out of the oven!

Always have great pizza!! Delicious pizza and nice staff. You seriously need to check this place out1!!! YUMMY 🍕