DeMarco's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Cosy place and very friendly and attentive staff. Ordered a cheese pie for dine in. The cheese had a cheese pull and the crust was perfectly toasted and not doughy. I would recommend it.

First of all, the girl at the counter was so nice it was a pleasure to order from them. The pizza is delicious. I asked for light garlic knots, they delivered !!! Best pizza in town.

This place is unreal. Usually was a Franks Pizza in west milford regular. I found a coupon in the paper for a free pizza from DeMarco’s so decided to give it a try. The food is 10/10 awesome. Since getting that free pizza my family has ordered from there 4 times in the past 7 days. The chicken buffalo with ranch sandwich is my go to and I highly recommend. All of their pastas are great as well, the penne Alfredo with chicken is absolutely delicious.

Staff are also great people, I went in there and pretty much reiterated everything I’m writing in this review to them and they were loving it. 11/10 food + they deliver!!!

Ended up at DeMarco’s after a hiccup with the bus schedule back to NY. The stuffed calzone and spinach and cheese slice was so delicious. Quality ingredients and crust with just the right amount of chewiness. Great people running the place, let us hang out past closing while we sorted out our transportation. So glad we stumbled upon this authentic Italian spot. Great to see a family owned restaurant serving hot honest food.

Despite the amount of garlic, Margarita pizza was really good. We just couldn't stop eating it. Highly recommended.

We love this place!!! Sicilian pizza is to die for! OMG! Our newest favorite!! Delicious! Crispy, cheesy and consistently cooked to perfection! Family owned which is the reason they take such pride in their finished product. Do yourself a favor and give them a try, you won't be disappointed . Chicken Parm and Eggplant is delicious as well .
Anthony and Michele Schmidt, Hewitt .👍🙏🙂

Fantastic food! So happy they're still thriving! Known the owner for almost 20 years great people!

Stopped in for a quick bite. Had a slice of sausage and pepper pizza and a Sicilian slice. Very good. Also got an Italian sub to go. Fresh and tasty. Owner was friendly and attentive. I'll be back.

I stopped in today and was pleasantly surprised to find a pizzeria owned by Italians. The environment was so communal, one of the patrons called the owner by the honorific "mamma " I am not exactly close by but I'll be sure to stop by whenever I'm up there. Grazie di cuore

This place has the best stuffed slice I've ever tried. A great selection of rotating pies too. Always friendly and quick with a joke. Excellent place for a quick bite.

Some of the best tasting pizza I’ve had in a long time. Also my so , who is the pickiest eater especially with buffalo wings, absolutely LOVED it. 5 stars all around from us. Their ingredients are top notch, nice to see a pizza place not cut corners and choose the good stuff instead. We will always be ordering from here!

May favorite area pizza . Delicious pizza and friendly staff .

I was Happy to do a Food Review on their Wings and I enjoy them my Father grew up in the Development behind the Strip and I always feel great coming and seeing all these faces I haven’t seen in Years, The Veal is Delicious the pizza is great and the Employees are Family Friends they Catered my Uncles Services and I wanna thank them for being so Nice and Caring for that.

Great family owned place, food was fantastic, what I can assume was the owner greeted me at the counter made sure my girlfriend and I got everything we needed (included dietary restrictions) with our meal. 10/10 would recommend.

Great food, excellent service, nice atmosphere. Love this place! Pizza was delicious.

superb lunch ! Thanks Karen & Rosy

Best family owned pizza place in West Milford. The Muto family is one of the most beloved and kind hearted around. Never a disappointment, always a pleasure!

I just had bloodwork and asked the women that worked there where they had gotten their lunch that they had just brought back into the office.

They told me De Marco’s!
I figured that people who work in the area would know where the best place to eat was.
They weren’t wrong!

I ordered A grilled chicken wrap with roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella and balsamic vinegar. I was surprised by the zucchini fries that came with it! Oh my goodness, they were heavenly!!! Sooooo GOOD! The sandwich was good too.

I was talking with the owner about his soups. He said they are all homemade. Can’t wait to try them next time!

So glad I asked for a recommendation and found this place. I wanted to pass that recommendation along!

Best pizza place in town hands down. Everything tastes great, service is prompt with a nice atmosphere. Their dine in section has a very peaceful aura as well, separate from the counter area. Their menu also covers anything an Italian restaurant would carry.

As a traveling Local Guide, having been through 48 states, I must say Demarco's is easily top 3 pizza in the US. I'm pretty sure north Dakota, Tennessee, and Michigan doesn't make comparable pizza.

We had our baptism celebration there everything was amazing. The food was delicious as always, but I can't praise enough about the atmosphere. Lou and Karen are amazing thank you!