Big Bill's New York Pizza

We got a small New York style pizza and the manicotti. Both were absolutely delicious. I’m a pizza fanatic so I’m constantly trying new pizza joints. Pizza had great flavor- and just the right amount of olive oil and cheese.
Service was friendly, we told them it was our first time and they gave us some garlic knots on the house which were fantastic- loved the dough and marinara. Food came out FAST and hot. When they hit us with the check we were pleasantly surprised to get two drinks, a pizza, a dessert and an entree for under $40.
If you’re thinking about giving this place a try I highly recommend.

Walked in here for a quick bite between dropping my kid off at practice. Was able to get two slices to go. Great, high quality pizza. Staff was awesome. The place was packed on a Monday night too. Keep up the good work, I’ll be back!

Best pizza in town! Definitely need to get 'El Presidente' over here. Probably around a 7.5 on the ole pizza scale. 7.8 just on the history, people, and environment.

My wife and I visited Big Bill's New York pizza tonight for the first time and it was excellent. Ainsley was our waitress and she was awesome to say the least. Such a friendly warm environment with great food. We will definitely come back for another enjoyable dinner in the near future.

I am ashamed that it took me 15 years to finally swing by this pizzeria. Will definitely be back to check out their cannolis. Service was excellent

We were visiting from out of town and ended up finding this place by chance after doing a google search. Just so happens we were in NYC exactly one year ago. We ordered 2 New York style pizzas and they were amazing! The salad and garlic knots were also very good. Excellent service and the food came out fast. We will be back whenever we’re in the area again.

I’ve been eating at Big Bills since I was a kid. BEST NY style pizza in Colorado. The staff are amazing as well and most have been there for years and little turnover and I think that comes down to the family atmosphere. I love this place

I got the Sicilian slice with ham pepperoncini and ricotta cheese. It was amazing. The crust is perfect, light and soft in the middle and crunchy in the bottom. Delightful. Service was fast and friendly. Will be coming back to try their hero’s.

One of our favorite New York style pizza, pizza thin and crispy and not overly sauce. Service fast and friendly staff. Highly recommend and family friendly.

I have no words. The best pizza I’ve ever had in my life! 10/10 recommend and the workers were all so nice!

Staff from start to finish were very friendly and attentive! Our server Laura was helpful and friendly as it was my first time here. Food arrived hot and tasted excellent!

GREAT pizza. A large combo pie is $16. AMAZING cheesy bread, the BEST I've probably ever had and the customer service was great :) If I lived in the area I'd come here more often! It's very spacious inside too so perfect for a big family or anyone who has a stroller.

Seeing ourselves in Centennial, we decided to find a local New York pizza restaurant to support during our time in this city. Growing up I remember always going to Big Bill’s after soccer matches and enjoying their breadsticks, nostalgia, and big New York slices of pizza.

Almost a decade later & nothing has changed which is incredible!

Walking into this establishment, you will be immortalized by the amount of photos of New York & sports memorabilia. There’s a wall full of pictures of Big Bill (the owner) with numerous famous people which is really intriguing. Don’t be off-put with the green and white inside decor and older chairs and tables. It helps bring in the atmosphere of a true New York pizzeria.

We ordered the Sticks & Bones (Garlic Breadsticks & Garlic Knots) and for $4.75 the amount you receive is enough to feed 3-4 people easily. Great value and the quality is not sacrificed. Their marinara sauce was a great compliment to their light, fluffy bread appetizers.

We also ordered a medium New York style cheese pizza and we ended up getting a large - seeing that it was only $0.50 more. The pizza came out hot and ready to eat. The pizza has the perfect amount of sauce to cheese ratio. The oily nature of the pizza really brought us back to the time we were in New York City. This pizza was a home run. Again, enough to feed 3-4 people easily.

All together it was $22.15 before tax which is a huge steal for the quantity and quality of food you received.

If you’re in Centennial, there’s no debate. This is the Best New York Pizza in the city - just like I remembered it as a kid.

Awesome place to grab yourself some great pizza, the customer service was on point and even while really busy, helped me carry my food to the car because my hands were full. Great people and great quality. 10 out of 10 would recommend.

Oh my goodness! I may travel all the way to Denver just for this pizza. My dad and I found this place while on a road trip and we "ohh" and "ahhh'd" our way through a pizza and salad.
First, the service is INCREDIBLE! Our waitress found out we were traveling and it was our first visit to Big Bill and she comped us some freakin tasty appetizers.
We ended up with a pepperoni pizza and salad and they were both delicious. The crust was light, flavorful in its own right, and crispy on the outside. The meat was spicy and perfectly flavorful. And, unlike most places, the salad was just as fantastic.
One of the best tasting pizza's we've had in a long long time.

Great pizza place, clean spacious with room for families. No mask required, the restaurant crew that we saw, generally wasn't masked. The garlic bread is unique, in that it definitely is more of a homemade affair. The supreme pizza was pretty good too. Give them a try!

Best place to get New York style pizza here in Colorado... And Bill, the owner does so much charity work and is such a huge member of the community. You can't help but love the people and the atmosphere. Simply the best for a multitude of reasons.

This is truly a place to enjoy delicious NY Pizza. His garlic Knots with marinara dip is also a hit. Fast service and courteous staff made it a great evening. Lucky to meet Bill as well. He is a huge supporter of 9/11 charity and it was a reason to visit and donate. Great evening.

Great pizza! We ordered two large pies and they came out bubbling hot with gooey cheese so thick it made our mouths water while dishing it out. The crust was thin with a crunch as you bite into it. I ordered the wings naked with sauce on the side and they were really good. The sauce is sweet and spicy, so I double dipped in blue cheese. I loved it.. We are fans and will be back for a second try next time we are in town.

Loved their beer so much we bought a pitcher. Excellent pizzas and a definite at home, family feel. Someone spilled something at a table and an older gentleman yelled for Anthony to bring a bucket. Four times "Anthony bring me a bucket!" You know Anthony never brought a bucket but he did bring a spray bottle! Excellent experience for us out of towners! We even took home a box of Ring Dings!