BJ's Market Street Tavern & Oyster Bar

I had such a wonderful experience Tuesday night at BJ's! We sat on the quaint patio and had amazing service by Haley and everybody else were very nice as well. The food was delicious and came out in a timely manner! I just wish we lived closer! We live in Cleveland and we were going to Knoebels for the day! I highly recommend this place the atmosphere the great little town it's in the food and the service were all top notch!!

We were there Monday night and had a wonderful time! We came in for the “Two Bucks a Shuck” promotion but we stayed for the outstanding service and main courses.
When we first walked the host Cate and the Manager Lonna were very friendly. Our waitress Ashley was very friendly and knowledgeable about the food. If we didn’t already have it in our minds to get the promotion Lonna would’ve sold us on it. She was very enthusiastic about it and how it’s an unbeatable deal.
We will 100% be coming back for another wonderful dining experience!

Alley, you did a great job serving us and my compliments to the chef who prepared the swordfish. Absolutely, delicious! This restaurant is one of our favorite places to dine!

Consistently one of the best places in PA. Fresh oysters are fantastic, and I just had a sea bass entree that was one of the 10 best meals of my life! Service is always top shelf also.

Really good food.. great time we had there.. music was awesome.. service was outstanding. The staff was incredibly helpful..Would definitely recommend having a few meals at this place. The wings were really tasty and the cornbread/cake was really good as well... well we went back for another meal.. a celebratory one.. service was great.. food was great.. did miss the strawberry shortcake that I had before but the snicker pie deal was pretty damn good also

What a wonderful restaurant! The food at BJ's Market Street Tavern and Oyster Bar was absolutely perfect and delicious. We had not one complaint about anything. From the atmosphere to the service, from the employees to our meal everything was spot on.

This restaurant was recommended to us by the manager at the Hilton Hotel that is approximately 6 walking blocks away. We are so pleased we listened to her suggestion.

Our appetizers, our entrees and our dessert were all perfectly prepared. The portions are perfect and the prices reflect exactly what you are getting.

Great meal. Goods service. Perhaps a bit slow, but the food was great. (Original review from 2019)

Updated review.... They renovated the main dining room and destroyed the charm and feel of the room. It is terrible now. The bar still had the same great charm and character. Service was still slow but adequate. Biggest two issues are the dining room has or had a terrible odor, and there are just so many flies. I could not cut my steak one handed while I kept trying to brush the flies away from our table.

My advice is only eat in the bar or outside.

Great experience as always at BJ's ! .... We were seated in the remodeled dining room, which we really like the Booth configuration as apposed the former table seating. My Wife and I decided to keep it simple, both of us ordering the "Blue Cheese Burger" and starting with the ever popular "Bongo~Bongo Dip" our burgers were cooked to perfection and the dip, bubbling hot! .... Ending our meal with BJ's Pressed coffee and a slice of the richest cheesecake ever! Service was top notch! And our entire meal in a word ...DELICIOUS! We will certainly return!

The food was amazing, but expect a high price when the bill comes due.

My girlfriend and I ordered a variety of food. We ordered two crab cakes, 1 american freedom pizza, and a chicken sandwich. For drinks we had two alcoholic beverages, one Caribbean Punch and one Mojito. The bill all together was $40+ all together.

Of course, we did have many left overs... but none the less the food was amazing. We are roughly in town every few months. We definatly will be back.

I highly recommend checking this place out.

Great place to stop for a quick lunch after touring the campus at Susquehanna. The server was amazing and the food was really good. I highly recommend you stop here the next time you're in the area

We had an awesome time! We started it with the bongo bongo dip amd rhe creaminess of the dip on a garlic bread was very good. We both had the Chicago steak and split it, however even then it was still filling for us! For desert we had chocolate cheesecake, which made be rich but it was very satisfying.

Outstanding service....seated and drinks quicky....we got on the appetizer steamed oysters and calamari....oysters fantastic.... steer clear of calamari ....New England clam chowder just full of meat...hit just the right note of broth....Raw bar we sample 3 of the ones on menu delicious with great presentation..we got all the condiments they ordered...oyster casino and oyster Rockefeller you could not get better at the shore ....dessert was great .....bill was more than fair.....

This place was amazing. Christina was my waitress and told me the pasta and scallops are her favorite and I will agree with her on that, the scallops were huge and delicious. This is by far the best place I have eaten at in Selinsgrove and I WILL be back.

First time there. Wonderful service. Delicious food. Coconut shrimp..amazing 👏

I never would have guessed I would find a raw bar in central Pennsylvania but what a find! Staff was friendly and put out a very relaxed and casual vibe. I was allowed to walk around with my mask on to check things out and decided to stay. Good choice! I only wanted an appetizer and picked four oysters and two shrimp cocktail from the raw bar. Ice cold and very fresh, well shucked and hardly any grit! Delicious! If I ever get a chance to go back I’ll be bringing an appetite! Extensive menu and I want to try the steak!

Best food around, staff so sweet and attentive, food was out of this world💜

Awesome rotating selection of boutique oysters & amazing artisanal pizza! We stop every time on our trip between York & Eagles Mere, PA!

Wow! So good. Excellent service. Amazing food. My husband had the Bongo Bongo dip and said it’s very good. He also said the chili, though a bit too hot (and he loves spicy things), the flavor is fantastic. He had the Chicago Steak Salad, he said it was delivered. He was pleasantly surprised by how well the fries and sweet and sour enhanced the salad. I had the ribeye. It was one of the best steaks I’ve had in a long time. The steamed broccoli was perfect. And the French onion soup was just what I lovely.

The food was so good!! Their homemade salad dressing was so tasty we bought a container to take home- A++

This was our first time eating there and the Food was amazing!! They spaced the food perfectly in between servings. You didn't feel rushed to eat and get out. Our waitress was just as amazing as the food. Will be going back again for sure. Definitely worth the price. Oh and if you love oysters definitely seek this place out.