Bay Pony Inn

Lovely experience again! Attended private event in ball room. Owner Edward and wife greeted us and ensured our needs and wants were met thru out the evening. Excellent service from bartender and wait staff. Buffet style meal with great apps, entrees, and sides.

What a lovely gem! Had a family dinner here for my mother’s 90th birthday and everything was amazing. All of us were more than happy with our meal. Tasty and beautifully presented. Great service and atmosphere.

We celebrated my Boyfriend's Birthday there last night the service, drinks, atmosphere was AWESOME!!!! Thank you Florence for your HELP for making it such a PERFECT night!!!! I HIGHLY recommend this PERFECT PLACE!!!! 👌 ❤
Debbie Fach

Relaxing bar with piano music that is the perfect volume, great well made cocktails and the pork chop is out of this world! I usually would never order a pork chop out but theirs is THAT good that I will get it every time from now on.

The food and drinks were great,but the people were even better. Literally everyone we met were wonderful friendly people. Mark (bartender) was accommodating and helpful. My wife and I had a great time and appreciated our fun experience. We will definitely be back!

Went to the Bay Pony Inn with my husband for his birthday. Wonderful dinner. My husband had mussels and filet mignon, and I had the monk fish and the portobello soup. The food was excellent and the service was attentive but not rushed. I would definitely recommend this restaurant.

Had my Boyfriend's Birthday party on Saturday at Bay Pony Inn and everything from drinks to food to atmosphere and servers was FANTASTIC!!!! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND this PERFECT PLACE 👌

We met friends here for an exceptional dining experience. We reserved the train car and had a room to ourselves. My husband is still raving about the thick pork chop cooked to perfection. I enjoyed grilled salmon. Everything was amazing. After dinner we enjoyed live music in the cozy bar. Staff helped place tables together so we could all sit together. Staff went out of their way to make this a wonderful meal out with friends.

Can't say enough. Wife coming home from a long trip I called at the last minute they got us in for dinner last night. We pulled up and the parking lot was full. How he did it I don't know but we had two very nice seats and table in the dining room. Turns out they had an event going on as well. Now I am starting to think this might be a mistake. I would have been wrong. The service was great, dinner came out it was perfect. I have no idea how they did everything so well with that many people and still handled the regular crowd. Can't say enough good things about the staff.

Exactly where I wanted to be on this weekend away. Was greeted by lovely staff who made us feel very welcome. I had the roast duck (so good) with a few of glasses of pinot. Live pianist was also great. Leaving now feeling very content.

Delicious food and drinks. Love the atmosphere and bar area. Always enjoy dining here.

Very nice dinner. Solid, standard American fare - steaks chicken and fish. Good desserts. Not inexpensive, but reasonable. Nice for a special family outing.

What a beautiful jewel! For my mother's 90th birthday, we had a family meal here, and everything was wonderful. We were all quite pleased with our lunch. Delicious and nicely presented. Excellent environment and service.

Great food and service. 10 person birthday celebration in a private room!

A great formal dining experience. Food atmosphere and service were great.

Mother's Day brunch buffet. Very nice assortment of both breakfast and dinner foods. Delicious spread of desserts as well. It seemed the atmosphere was good for adults and families as there were separate rooms to dine.

We held our wedding reception at the Bay Pony Inn. The food and service were exceptional. All of our guests commented about how delicious and hot the food was. Florence and her staff were friendly and attentive to every detail. Everything was exactly how we wanted it. I am so glad we chose The Bay Pony Inn for this special day. I will recommend them any chance I get. Thank you Florence and Eduard for a beautiful day!

a beautiful, cosy country tavern! must visit. such kind service, love the old interiors and horse themed memorabilia. flatbread and pasta were so good, and the dessert was on another level. can't wait to come back when i'm in the area next

Mother's Day brunch buffet with the perfect combination of delicious, perfectly prepared foods. Everything from French toast to mussels, fresh fruit, salad, Danish, variety of cakes and fresh whipped cream. Did I mention the quiche!! Foods were cut in easy to manage portions, which was perfect for the children in our group, and made it easy to take some of everything. And, since it's a buffet, we cpuld go back for more. Service was excellent. And, the restaurant is beautiful. From the bright, airy dining room with buffet, to the beautifully decorated old train car (both in use during holiday buffets or parties only) to the rustic bar and main dining area. Will definitely go back again. And again.

Had the best wedding here 15 years ago and 15 years later. The food is still amazing and it still feels like everyone is in your family. Great atmosphere and such a wonderful place with great attention to personal details. And the food is exceptional.