Original Italian Pizza

Giuseppe went over and above to make sure our family had what we needed..... We had a family member who passed and someone was sending food to a large group of our grieving family. The individual who called in the order got things mixed up, but the team at Millville OIP got it straightened out and had the food...... a TON of food..... Delivered promptly to our rural location. The chicken Alfredo and baked ziti was sooooo good and the canoli.... Oh mio dio! Molto bene!

Very clean establishment. I have trouble finding GF stuff in take out places. But OIP in millville has Udis GF sub rolls and pizza crust. They also have salads and alternatives for GF people. The sub roll was steamed with bacon, chicken steak and onions. Very good! Most places leave bread unsteamed and it's very dry. Great job in prep!

We ordered cold subs to go! They were very good, fresh Ingredients, quality cheese. Fast service and the young gal was pleasant who took our order. Ashame we have drove by this place so often. We absolutely will be making this OIP a stop in our travels. Thank you for providing a excellent product. By the way, they had plenty of help and everyone was working hard.

So we stopped here to take food for my Uncle's BDay & I'm so happy that we did. This place is AMAZING!!! Best meatball sub I have ever had in my life...full of fresh made huge meatballs that were quartered to fit in the most delicious soft homemade bread I have had. They do not skimp on the cheese either. We ended up eating one because it was so big and full of meatball & cheese. Honestly I would drive the hour and half to get their food again. They are true Italians, very hospitable & good looking to boot! If you are within a hour distance of this place I guarantee it is worth the trip for true Italian food. I can't wait to try the pizza, I heard it's great!

This place has the best lunch special. 2 HUGE slices of cheese pizza and a big cup of soda for $5. You cannot beat it.

Great Pizza stop along my travels. Friendly service and quick food prep. Chicken Cheesesteak was great and enough to take half home for later.

Great staff, They know me and they know how I like my pizza, especially the calzone and they always do a great job lol. A family buisness run by authentic Italians. My fiance loves their homemade bread. They offer delivery, be sure to call ahead of time because especially in the winter they do get busy. Definitely recommend.

This place is the picturesque setting for the typical thought of a rural family diner. It is small and cozy, “outdated” enough in style that it doesn’t feel stuffy but is still kept up with, and very homey. The menu is extensive! It took me awhile to narrow down my dinner, but I don’t think I could’ve gone wrong no matter what I chose. Oh, and you get heaps of (deliciously made with love) food for the price. My cheesesteak took two meals to finish! And was an absolute delight to eat (for just under $9, I believe it was?). I certainly plan to return.

I stop here almost every time I head to my cabin in Sullivan County. I love there food alot. Always have great pizza and sandwiches. The service has always been great. I know I will be back soon

Great food and very nice staff.

Absolutely amazing! Best Stromboli that I have had. Got the meat lovers and it was loaded. Will be back for more. Staff was very friendly and helpful too.

Food: we’ve eaten here four times now in the last year. Two were dine-in and two were take away. We’ve never had a single thing that we wouldn’t order again. The Stromboli (meat lover) is my favorite and there is enough for three meals (2 leftovers the next two days).

Staff: are always polite and attentive. We wouldn’t change or ask for anything different.

Support the local places! Thank you.

Nice clean little Italian restaurant.
Pepperoni pizza was great.

So I visited my mom for the holiday and she was in the mood for pizza, I had the California burger she had a pineapple slice, I have to tell you I'm from New York and it was probably one of the best burgers I've had, definitely top five!! Thank you!

Great food. Absolutely wonderful service. Great place to take the family for dinner or just to stop for a slice.

I am originally from this area but have lived in Kentucky for 18 years. We visit Pennsylvania about twice a year and EVERY single time we come up, we always go to OIP. It is the best pizza in my opinion! They have plenty of other options on their menu also and it is all good!

Always good at Millville oip. Best to true Italian. Considering he is . And his wife. Now the sons old enough. Never said bad. Foods good. People's nice service is fast and clean

I love this restaurant. The food is so good and portions are huge. Plus the boss and employees are absolutely amazing

The workers here are very friendly. The server and food were great!

Pizza very good, piping hot and ready right on time. Staff friendly and polite. Excellent!