Mario's Pizza

When I first moved to Greenville Mario's was a little piece of home. The food is almost identical to what my grandfather served in his pizzeria when I was growing up. I later found out it's probably because both of our families are from the same part of Sicily. Wait times are sometimes long depending on how busy they are. But that's because of the way things are made, and the ovens they use. Just bake the wait time into your expectations and you won't be disappointed. The food is always top notch, and the people are always great.

incredible! This is probably the best pizza in the entire region! Love the amazing staff! small town hospitality big city taste!

This is one of my absolute favorite hometown places! There is always a welcoming atmosphere and fun service from the employees.

Got off the highway to pick this pepperoni pizza up on the way back to pennsylvania. Cheese tasted amazing. Crust was good. Sauce was average. Pepperoni was average. Best pizza i had on the trip out west and back though. Could use a little more pepperonis on the pizza. But all and all a great pizza i would order again.

1st time visitors from St. Louis. We were treated like family. Mario's will be added as a stop every time we pass by Greenville.

We love pizza 🤤 always ready for a new pizza place to eat at and this is one to come back to over and over again.

Absolutely awesome. We loved it, especially the fact it is small and independent. The best restaurants in the region are the small businesses where owners pour their heart and soul into making the experience memorable. Great pizza, especially the perfectly baked crust!

As out-of-towners, we were treated nicely and had a great experience here. The pizza was delicious and the cheesy breadsticks were awesome.

Very good pizza, fresh ingredients

So so so good! The Olympian was my favorite. What a good idea to have a hummus base. I think they gave us a Mario's supreme instead of a regular supreme. Had pepperoni on it. Still good tho!

We usually order for pick up. The food is always good. The crust does come thin and the toppings are plentiful. However they do not overwhelm the crust to where it cannot stand the weight of them. Their Mario's (supreme) and the Ham pizza are our favorite but we are exploring others on their menu and finding them all to taste great. They also have some of the best homemade salad dressing around and you can even purchase it at the restaurant. Good people, good service, good food. Recommend for others to try.

Mario's Pizza has always been, and I'm sure always will be, the best pizza place in the area. I'm particularly fond of their Italian sub sandwich. It is the benchmark that I use to rate all other Italian sandwiches. You can't go wrong eating at Mario's.

What a great find while traveling along highway 70! We had to drive into town but the detour was well worth it! Small little town operated pizza shop with an authentic heritage. The bread sticks and pizza was all excellent in taste and quality. Pizza is easy but truly well made dough and perfectly seasoned fresh sauce is not always easy to find. This place has it covered! Seeing Mario himself (assuming) well up there in age still hands-on and making fresh dough was a delight and gave me my first clue as to what was to come! Do yourself a favor and take the advice I was given. This place is a "must try"!!!!

Always consistent, excellent pizza every time. This was the place I used to go in high school and coming back after 30 years I'm happy to say it's still the best pizza around!

Ordered from them for the first time on a Thursday night and they completely messed up our pizza order. However, when we called to let them know, they apologized and offered to make us a new one. Although it was a bit of an inconvenience to have to drive back, the second pizza was hot, fresh, made perfectly and DELICIOUS!

Best pizza in town. I really like the davinci and thin crust styles. If we're hungry, two people can tackle a large size. The salads are also a good size.

Pizza is always great. Calzones too. Restaurant could use a bit of updating. But it is clean. Don't let the faded sign fool you. This is a great place to get a good pizza. Hint: Marcoots' Cheese and Basil is a good option.

Absolutely the best pizza you can get in our area! We have lived in Mulberry Grove for 6 months now and have tried to get over there so many times, tonight we finally went and... WE'LL NEVER GET PIZZA ANYWHERE ELSE!!! Mario's was authentic pizza with fresh ingredients and a sauce that was the perfect balance of tomato and spices/seasonings. I will also be getting as much house dressing as I can get every time we go from here on out. Thanks for staying true to your roots, Mario's. It shows in your food and the atmosphere of your clientele!

The construction outside made parking hard.

Great family owned pizzeria. Friendly staff. Excellent crust. Busy weekend evenings but well worth the wait.