Michael's Italian Restaurant

I've been going here since I was a baby. It's tradition to get a kiddie cocktail and the cheese and crackers. You should plan at least 2 hours for dinner time... Order the C&C, have a drink from the full bar, and just enjoy the atmosphere. This place has tons of history and if you're from Elkhart, it's likely you see someone you know. Don't be afraid of the neighborhood... There seems to be some unspoken respect for Michael's guests. Maybe I'm just naive 😊. Anyways, go treat yourself.

While the outside looks a little rundown and not in the best of neighborhoods this place will definitely fool you. It is nice inside as well as the people that are serving you. The food was excellent and the proportions at lunch were huge, so I can't even imagine what the dinner portions would be. I took my leftovers home and ate them for the next 2 days. I definitely cannot wait to go back and try something else. Like I said the staff was very nice and accommodating. Yum yum.

My family has been getting pizza from Micheal's for almost 50 years, but we stopped when family was no longer able to go and when I moved from Elkhart. While visiting recently, I stopped in for a large pepperoni pizza. The taste is exactly as I remember. The crust has a nice crunchy rim and a great chew. The sauce isn't too thick, or applied too heavily. The cheese is ample, without being stringy. The closest style it resembles is Chicago tavern style. Great pizza.

I’ve been coming here for as long as I can remember & it’s by far the best Italian restaurant in the area. I live in Florida now & crave the chicken parm & fried ravioli weekly, but have to wait until I visit IN in order to get my fix 😂. My family has created a lot of memories here over the years as well as making new memories with my now husband. I’ll be a forever customer & look forward to many more years of memories & amazing delicious food! I’ll add more pictures when I find them

the atmosphere of this place is so fun and friendly! however, the highlight of my visit was the gluten friendly alfredo sauce! i have a lot of trouble finding places i can eat good pasta and specifically with cheese or alfredo sauces. i thoroughly enjoyed my dinner at michael’s! our server was so helpful with providing allergy information as well.

We were there for our anniversary, this passed Saturday. Our waitress was Ashley. She was absolutely the best waitress we have ever had there. We loved the food, and like I said, Ashley was the very best. We laughed and talked as she waited for our party. Do yourself a favor and go visit Michaels. The good is the best. You can't go wrong!

If you're looking for an authentic neighborhood Italian restaurant with great food and great service in a quaint setting, head to Michael's. It is a hidden gem. The pizza is phenomenal, I can't wait to go back and try some of their entrees especially the eggplant parmigiana.

I worked at an Italian Restaurant in Kansas City called Garozzos it was located at 526 Harrison so I was blown away from the start! FOOD WAS GREAT! ATMOSPHERE AMAZING!! SERVER WAS PERFECT!! DO NOT MISS THIS PLACE IF YOU GET NEAR ELKHART, IN!!!!

Delicious Italian food !!
Located in a small neighborhood filled with locals. The smell of sauce overwhelms you as you enter the door. It reminds me of grandmas home made sauce simmering on the stove and the aroma of fresh spices. The chicken parmigiana is outstanding. There is something for everyone on the menu. All modestly priced with a nice small bar for cocktails.
Try it,you will love it

Angela was a great server. She was always one step ahead of our needs. The food was excellent. I could feast on the delicious garlic bread with cheese. Mmmmm.

Wait staff was very friendly and attentive. Food was delicious! No wait for a table but we were there at 5:30.

Little locally owned place with a great vibe, good food and better service! Erin was amazing and attentive even while busy! First time going here, went be the last though!

Great atmosphere and food! Just make sure you have plenty of time since food is cooked to order so will take longer than chain restaurants...worth the wait!

I've been here several times and have never been disappointed! Their chicken parmasean is the best that I've ever had. The chicken stays crispy and doesn't get soggy from the sauce. Their pizzas are huge and so good! Their sandwiches are always delicious and are a quick option for lunch. Love it!

Great little family Italian restaurant. Good selection, Friendly service, great prices and cozy atmosphere.
Had the Meatball sub. Nice portion, good quality ingredients. Will be going again

Great food and service. Good value. Nice, clean atmosphere.

Wonderful food! And the owner is a super nice person!

First time here! Jess W. Was excellent in telling us of their specialties ! She went above & beyond in her service! We even took home a loaf of their fresh bread-thanks to Jess for letting us know that was an option! Will be back!

Great atmosphere! Great customers! Good pizza. The pasta dishes, being honest, aren’t that great, I was expecting real true authentic pasta from this Italian restaurant. Overall we had fun here!!

We love Michael's ❤ restaurant! It is a local icon.