Pizza Mike’s

Great food, we had the Alfredo fettuccine and 5 cheese tortellini with garlic knots. Everything is very fresh and made in front of you. We returned the next day for pizza and garlic knots which were great. Only thing to keep in mind wait times are about 1 hour for a pizza which is a little long - Mike the owner is usually on site helping the staff

I’m not one to go with places that have a lot of hype. But our second year on the island we decided to try Pizza Mike’s. It is AMAZING!! We did take out. We got pizza, spaghetti with meatballs, chicken Parmesan, mozzarella sticks and cannolis. We ordered a total of three separate times. Everything was hot and delicious. The sauces are the right mix of tomato/garlic/herbs. The staff was friendly and helpful.

Who knew — The best New York Pizza would be 1,545 Miles away (as the snowbird flys) on an Island where the Gulf of Mexico and the Caribbean Sea meet.
The first thing you'll notice is, the employees love their jobs, taking pride in what they make, working hard but having f
un — and you can taste it in the food.
Then the smells of walking down the side streets of Brooklyn, New York wafting from the traditional pizza ovens.
Then the colors of red and green and freshness.
And finally the taste. You can tell the team take pride in the complexity of flavor.

I am a Neapolitan Italian from New York. My first time visiting the island and after hearing rave reviews from friends, we decided to eat here. Best calzone and sauce I've ever had! My husband said his pizza rivaled any NY pizza. Manga!

I love this place. A must go to if vacationing in Isla Mujeres. Great staff that are friendly and will help you. While, I was waiting for my pizza my wife who is bilingual took a pizza order. It was awesome for her to help. As a sign of appreciation staff gave us two pieces of pizza while we waited. My kids love this place.

This place is fantastic! We enjoyed pizza - thin crust... Italian sausage.and pepperoni. Also, lobster Alfredo pasta... Yummy. They deliver but have a few tables out front of the restaurant. They don't sell alcohol but you are welcome to bring your own and have while eating. Mike the owner was there every time we went. Great guy!

BEST PIZZA ON PLANET EARTH. We stop by ant least 3 times during our weeks stay. Mr Mike came out and said hi to our kiddos, gave them coloring pages etc. Extremely affordable and if you order their Promotion special, you get 2 slices of pizza, 2 garlic knots and a mini coke or water bottle for less than $4USD. When I say it’s made fresh, it’s made FRESH as soon as you order so don’t mind the wait, it’ll be worth it.

Best cheese sticks, pizza, and spaghetti! Blown away at how good everything tasted. I’d rate 6 stars if possible! Very friendly staff too!
Definitely making a trip here each time we go to Mujeres!

A tiny hole in the wall pizza place. Nothing fancy but great pizza and wonderful service! Ate here twice in 3 days and enjoyed every bite. Had such a great conversation with “Just George” who seemed to be running the show. Prices are wonderful, very inexpensive for quality food!

Pizza Mike could just as easily call himself Pasta Mike as he makes an absolutely fantastic Lobster Alfredo. It's decadent but not too gloppy and stick-togethery, with a creamy taste that doesn't overwhelm the very generous portions of fresh and perfectly seared lobster bits. I've got a salty palate so I had to sprinkle on a bit but then I was in Alfredo heaven! If you really want to taste joy in food form though I'd recommend snagging some meatballs on the side and chucking them right into the Alfredo pasta. It seems pretty sinful but it was by far the most memorable and tasty dish I ate out on Isla Mujeres. There was enough that I got to take some home and after sitting around a bit the flavors bloomed to the point of transcending all ideas of how delicious pasta could be. Favorite restaurant on the island hands down!!

This is our fourth year coming to Isla Mujeres and Pizza Mikes. They are hands down the best pizza and pasta on the island. Also excellent customer service and great prices

Warm and delicious garlic knots that aren’t too salty. Love the very herby flavor. We had the half vegetarian, half lobster pizza and it was divine. The crust was buttery and flavorful. We’ve had other pizzas in the island and by far, this is the best. Service was on point!

Pizza Mike’s pizza was amazing! It’s a thin crust type pizza and was absolutely delicious! We drove by this place many times before trying it. Glad we did as we will be back for sure!

Pizzas were sooooo good, I got an Alfredo pasta where was a bit bland. The garlic knots there give out are delicious, service took a bit of time but was worth the wait

We had Pizza Mike’s twice while we were on Isla Mujeres. We had the spaghetti with meatballs. It was delicious! 2 good size meatballs and also included are garlic knots! We also tried the sausage and the chicken parm sandwiches. They are prepared on the garlic knots bread. 3 pcs each per order. Very good. We had the everything pizza and it was a winner! All fresh ingredients and baked to perfection! It also includes garlic knots. We also tried the cannolis! Superb!

We have tried the other popular pizza places on the island,in our opinion Pizza Mike’s is the best.

Amazing food! Very good people. Owner was very nice. The garlic knots are amazing and the pizza was also tasty. Would definitely go again if I go back!!

Great food. My wife and I got a pizza and lasagna and either could have fed us both, despite it being a good price. So delicious too. Fun to hear Mike's stories.

Oh my God, do you want real Italian pizza? Send great service Mike’s pizza is the place lasagna pizza and the chicken wings were fantastic true Italian cooking at its finest.

Amazing staff and best pizza amazing crust and delivery right to the resort. We asked for the pool side and no problem at all. Pizza Mike we love you Thank you for an amazing dinner.

Best pizza on the Island! The garlic knots are amazing, and the meatball pizza is sooooo good. When you need a break one night from all they great authentic local food on the island, definitely hit up Pizza Mike.