The Old Mill House Pub

Great little pub in downtown Creemore. Tasty pub food. Typical pub style decor. Service was quick and friendly. The French fries were INCREDIBLE

Nachos are unbelievable I love them . Took my brother here when he was visiting from Saskatchewan and we all loved it . My brother is a head manager at Olive Garden and he said his corn beef sandwich was the best he’s ever had . I had the chicken sandwich tossed in sweet chilli sauce and it was great I will define get it again. Service was amazing , fast and even the washrooms are clean. Never have had a bad experience here they always make you feel like your at home and the portions are big !!

This is my first visiting the old mill house and it was absolutely amazing the food and service is here is incredible and food comes steaming hot and awesome looking I can't wait to come back and enjoy another jam burger

An old school pub! Loved the atmosphere and nachos were absolutely amazing!!! Definitely a return to eat more on the menu. Outdoor seating available!

I can't get enough of the chicken carbonara!!! The sauce and portion of everything in this dish is just heaven!!! Thats all i order from this place, well and calamari. The employees are very nice too!! Its a cute little place to eat in such a small town.

Update:
Regarding to our last visit on Saturday October 15th 2022; I am now providing the 5 stars.

I changed my review due to the amazing and outstanding service received from Caitlyn. In all my years coming to The Old Mill House Pub, we can say that we had an amazing experience and service... she is just wonderful and caring.

Kudos to Caitlin for her amazing personality and actitud and also to the chef for the delicious food.

More than ever... Fully recommended 😉😁😎🤟🏻🍁🇨🇦

-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-

When you come to Creemore, The Old Mill House Pub is your must stop.

Their food was great and very tasty. My wife ordered the chicken wings that she loves and she said that they were amazing. I got the burger and added cheese and bacon... just wonderful.

My son almost 3 years old son, enjoyed the hotdog with fries.

Their staff is very friendly and polite.

Fully recommended 😉😁😎🤟🏻🇨🇦

My husband and I have eaten here 5 or 6 times and have tried multiple menu items and all were exceptional. Service is good too and the patio being dog friendly is a huge plus for us.

One of my go to pubs, amazing food & great atmosphere. Would highly recommend checking it out! Gives that “small town” feel, the staff is super nice and inviting!🙌🏻

Pretty good beer list, the burger was excellent! The sticky toffee pudding was like heroin! Definitely will be coming back!

This was our first time at The Old Mill House Pub; honestly just googled restaurants in Creemore, liked the name...and hoped for the best 🤔😁

We have been friends since grade 5 and met halfway between our respective homes for a meal and some catching up. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming with the feel of a much loved, local gathering place.

The. food. was. to. die. for! Delicious flavours, generous portions and beautiful presentation. It was clear that the cook/chef takes pride in their work.
The bartender and waitresses were friendly and engaging without hovering.

We were relaxed and spent 6 hours (we were shocked by this!!! Time stood still it seemed), talking, eating and catching up. We would recommend this pub again, and again, and again.

(The only suggestion would be padded seats on the chairs) 😉

Homely little pub on mill street, near the creemore brewery. A must visit in Creemore. Friendly bartenders, great food, nice sampler of local brew.

We had chicken wings, pasta and burger. Price is worth it. Love the atmosphere at the back.

I love the food here! The burgers are awesome, and their portions are great. I’m also a big fan of the corned beef Reuben, as is my mom. My partner loves the nachos. He’s from Toronto and says they’re the best he’s ever had that he hasn’t made himself! Lol. Service is always friendly!

This was my last stop in Creemore and it left me craving more. Not only was the service incredible, not only was the food phenomenal with massive portions , not only were the prices exceptional, but the vibe in the place was like no other. Everyone seemed so happy. Almost joyful. It was the best small town experience I've ever had. I strongly recommend anyone to go here.

What a delightful stop. We have decided to make this our regular 1/2 stop on our way up to our cottage with the kids. The place was really full of life and all sorts of people gathering, families, friends, couples. We were there for lunch on both occasions with two young children 2 and 2 months and they made us feel right at home. Our waitress Caitlin went ABOVE and BEYOND when we lost our hand quilted diaper bag somewhere between the pub and our car. We connected with her asking if they may have had it. While it wasn't there, Caitlin offered instead to write about it on the towns FB page, where eventually it turned up! She even dropped it off in Waterloo (where we live) on her way to St. Jacobs! Thank you Caitlin. Looking forward to visiting again next year.

I had a Buffalo Chicken Wrap, and it was a very generous size. The fries were really good too. The only thing to consider when going here is that it's not a very big place and it can get a little crowded when busy. That may be an issue for some people.

Great service. Amazing pub food, we loved it!!

This place is awesome and super chill vibe...staff is chill too..... had the Rueben.... Wow is all i can say. Just order it and you will agree. The Creemore beer on tap wasnt too shaby either!

Great service...great food.... not just run of the mill pub fare... our waiter... amazing... got everything right... made several recommendations... glad we ate there

Quaint place with local brews and homemade food. I loved the casual atmosphere and our server made us feel very welcome. The food was AWESOME! I had a fresh salad wirh homemade balsamic and herb dressing and French onion soup (probably the best I've ever had). My friend had a tasty burger special paired with local beer from the brewery next door. I would say that anyone travelling near Creemore should stop here and enjoy this place.