Pie O My Pizzeria

Absolutely amazing pizza and staff. I didn't realize the pizza contained parmasan on the it and unfortunately can't eat it. They were very understanding and remade it without any issues or hesitations. Thank you!

Yummm delicious pizza - we visited in July 2022 from out of town and was impressed with their pizza. Loved everything about it - crust, cheese, sauce! Worked so well together. Def recommend!!!

Always amazing pizza no matter what time you order, great service and rarley ever have to wait more than 15 minutes 👍

Stayed at Caswell Resort for my birthday weekend and were recommended pizza from your store. Had the Northern Hawaiian and omg !!! The best, absolutely the best. My husband and I couldn't stop eating it and an XL that would normally have leftovers did not happen. So good....the sauce, the cheese, the maple ......just delicious. Wanted to take a pizza home the next day (Sunday) but sadly they were not open until 4:00 pm

Amazing staff! Perfect pizza with loads of toppings. The prices are on the low side compared to the amout you get. I drove 35 minutes from Huntsville and we'll worth it! Great job I'll be back soon!

Honestly the best pizza I've had in a really long time. There's been a couple different restaurants in that space, but this has to be the best so far. We tried the sunny Ridge and the maple glazed crust was simply delicious.
The love and dedication that is put into this business is VERY evident in their food and their costumer service. Very friendly polite and efficient. They offer delivery AND take debit.

Simply amazing. Will 100% order again.

we live 45 minutes south of sundridge and frequently visit the town. i have been craving pizza for so long but all of our pizza places in our town have fallen so short these past couple of years. we visited our friends and ordered from pie o my, and it was absolutely great. plentiful toppings, delicious sauce, oiled and seasoned crust, everything was fabulous. thank you for such a great pizza! 🖤

This place is a gem!!! Not only amazing food, but amazing people. While we were staying in town we had some mechanical problems with our motorcycle. The folks there did everything in their power to help us.. it was very touching to see them call help for us, and offer to take us sight seeing. It was incredible. Now the pizza..... heck ya it was delicious....support this tasty establishment, they wont disappoint.

Unexpected deliciousness! :)
Something about the dough - so smooth on the tongue and so satisfyingly chewy. Not too much crust, but not thin either (although I'm relatively certain you could ask for thin if you wanted it). We had the supreme with added roasted red peppers YUM. Our pizza also was delicious on a reheat the next day (I didn't microwave it, just grilled it crust down in the cast iron pan).

Best pizza I have had in a long time! The staff were great too. Northern charm that's hard to find down in the city

Hayley is amazing she is such a good worker

Great pizza place will a delicious soft crust. The gluten-free option was also wonderful.

AMAZING PIZZA ! Thick tasty crust and the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. This is the best pizza I have ever had. The staff is super friendly especialy steve and the prices are affordable. My only complain is that it is close on mondays and tuesdays.

tried 4 different pizza's and their wings. every pizza was top notch and the wings were great too. staff was really friendly. cozy dine in area as well.

One of the …. If not THE BEST pizzas I’ve ever had in my life. Customer services is also beyond exceptional! Can’t wait to go back for another wheel!

Amazing pizza! We will most defiantly make the over 2 hour drive another weekend just for this pizza!

Amazing pizza!!!
Was totally surprised!!!
Reasonably priced for the quality of pizza they make.
We stayed at the Caswell resort and it's very convenient.

Best pizza in the area. May cost cpl dollars more but it was worth it.

Great service fast and cheap the best pizza we have had in over 10 years if you are craving pizza this place is a must I will be getting pizza once a week or more now.

Best of the best!! Their crust, sauce and cheese are perfect. The staff is also very sweet and customer service is top notch.